Skip to content

Dining Out NYC Rule Amendments



Rule status: Proposed

Agency: DOT

Comment by date: November 9, 2026

Printable Version of Proposed Rule Text
Notice-of-Public-Hearing-and-Opportunity-to-Comment-DONYC-Rule-Amendments-with-certifications.pdf

This proposed rule would amend sections 5-01, 5-02, 5-03, 5-07, 5-09, 5-10, 5-11, and 5-12 of Chapter 5 and section 3-01 of Chapter 3 of Title 34 of the Rules of the City of New York to implement recently enacted local laws, clarify and update existing Dining Out NYC program requirements to align with policies and practices, and make additional amendments to improve the administration and operation of the Dining Out NYC program.

Send comments by

  • Email: [email protected]
  • Mail: Dining Out NYC, New York City Department of Transportation , 55 Water Street ; New York , New York 10041

Public Hearings

Attendees who need reasonable accommodation for a disability such as a sign language translation should contact the agency by calling 1 (212) 839-6500 or emailing [email protected] by November 2, 2026

Date

November 9, 2026
10:00am - 2:00pm EST

Connect Virtually
https://zoom.us/j/91864978875?pwd=efRyTYBpH1oA3dRUCycUIKMbQTCzhb.1
Meeting ID: 918 6497 8875 Passcode: 575347 Join by phone only Phone: 1-929-205-6099 Access code: 918 6497 8875 Password: 575347

Disability Accommodation
  • Closed Captioning

Comments are now closed.

Online comments: 408

  • Daniel

    No comments

    Comment added October 14, 2026 1:50pm
  • Stacie Johnson, District Manager, MCB4

    RE: Sidewalk Café Enclosures Law

    Dear Commissioner Flynn:

    At its October 7th Full Board meeting by a vote of 40 in favor, 1 against, 0 abstentions and 0 present but not eligible, MCB4 provides the following comments. Manhattan Community Board 4 (MCB4) wants to express its serious concerns regarding the sidewalk café outdoor dining program. The intended clear path for pedestrians on the busiest streets and avenues is being severely encroached upon due to changes in interpretation. The situation would worsen if a new law permits café enclosures without careful guardrails. We ask for your assistance in resolving those problems and promulgating clear rules that support the law’s original objective to safeguard pedestrian clear paths.

    The term “clear path” is defined as a straight, unobstructed path on the sidewalk or sidewalk widening for pedestrian circulation. Although it is not spelled out in the rules and contradicts the definition, recesses have been approved that constrain the clear path by forcing pedestrians to walk in the café perimeter to avoid obstructions.

    The rules spell out that (C) the clear path shall be measured from the outer edge of the perimeter of the sidewalk cafe to the nearest element or object affixed to the sidewalk between such perimeter and the nearest curb line. As a result, the clear path distance does not apply to any obstruction that is located a mere 2 inches away from the café perimeter. This results in bottlenecks for pedestrians.

    The combination of these two interpretations has led to numerous exceptions that obstruct appropriate sidewalk circulation and jeopardize the advancements made by utilizing DOT’s pedestrian mobility plan, which defines clear paths for congested avenues (3% of all sidewalks).

    Now, Intro 0894-2026, which allows cafes to suspend a readily removable vertical winterization covering that may be attached to an overhead covering or to an awning, will make the aforementioned problems worse because the overhanging covering is difficult to chisel out. Furthermore, most awnings are larger than cafes’ footprints, which will further reduce the unobstructed path.

    We recommend that in the revised rules, recesses not be permitted, that measurements be taken as a radius from the cafe boundary, and that enclosures be strictly compliant with the café boundaries and in transparent plastic only to reduce visual “walls” on the sidewalks.

    Another proposed Intro 0724-2026 would go further (it has not passed yet); It would limit the power of DOT to impose a clear path requirement upon a sidewalk cafe larger than 8 feet or 50% even on heavily congested corridors. Thus, sending a clear message now is more important than ever.

    It is all about balance. The roadway cafes are about to generate 30% more revenue in the roadway – which we applaud – there is no need to expand the use of the sidewalk unreasonably. If we want New York city to be the envy of the world, we should allocate walking space accordingly. Thank you for your support.

    Thank you,
    Leslie Boghosian-Murphy
    Chair
    Manhattan Community Board 4

    Comment attachment
    31-EXEC-Letter-to-DOT-re-Sidewalk-Cafe-Enclosures-Law.pdf
    Comment added October 15, 2026 4:50pm
  • Emma

    Thank you so much for revisiting outdoor dining. It should be year round, but it should also be meaningfully “outdoors.” As someone who regularly dines with an immunocompromised family member, the opportunity to be outdoors with at least one open wall and real airflow is paramount. The air quality in the “enclosed structures” that restaurants sometimes create is horrible and unsafe for anyone with a compromised immune system (and the Co2 levels these unventilated spaces have aren’t great for any of us). It’s often worse than actual building air. I realize this set up is harder to keep heated when it’s cold and that’s why some restaurants want more airtight structures, but out door dining should be *outdoors.* My father can’t safely eat indoors at a restaurant at any time of year and these last few years with virtually no outdoor dining half the year has been really depressing for all of us. Short of a city-wide initiative to drastically improve indoor air quality, maintaining access to outdoor dining options is an accessibility issue for many. I’m so excited to see expanded outdoor dining, but I’m concerned the current version of these rules will deny vulnerable people access to this important part of city life. Keep outdoor dining year-round, but make it accessible for all New Yorkers. The City Council should consider revisiting its rules about how these spaces are heated. European cities have open air outdoor dining year round that is used even when it’s quite cold because they can access better options for heaters.

    Comment added October 22, 2026 12:03pm
  • Brendan

    I second Emma’s commemt

    Comment added October 22, 2026 4:19pm
  • Where is this hearing?

    Please post the location of the hearing. Citizens should be permitted to attend, not simply to watch on Zoom.

    Thank you.

    Comment added October 22, 2026 4:28pm
  • Anna Pakman

    Re: Sections 5-11(a)(1)(i), 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C), 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), and related provisions governing vertical protective coverings

    Dear NYC Department of Transportation,

    I am a New York City resident with a disability that makes me high risk for serious complications from COVID-19. Because of these risks, I always wear an N95 style mask in public indoor spaces. Outdoor dining allows me to participate in New York City’s restaurant culture and maintain social relationships with friends and family without unnecessarily compromising my health. Additionally, I am a full-time wheelchair user and outdoor dining removes many of the architectural barriers presented by indoor dining rooms. I utilize outdoor dining patios at least a couple of times a week, and without them, I would be isolated from my community.

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining. However, I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to enclose outdoor dining areas on all sides would undermine accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, create public health risks, and potentially threaten the long-term success of the program.

    I would also like to emphasize that DOT, as a public entity, has obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), as well as applicable provisions of the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL), to ensure that people with disabilities have meaningful access to public programs and services. These protections extend to people with a wide range of disabilities, including those whose medical conditions make them particularly vulnerable to respiratory infections. DOT should therefore consider whether its proposed regulations create unnecessary barriers to access for disabled New Yorkers. Unfortunately, the proposed provisions permitting fully enclosed outdoor dining structures are doing exactly that. Below, I outline the specific accessibility concerns and propose a straightforward amendment that would help address them before the rules are finalized.

    1. Fully enclosed structures are not meaningfully outdoor dining.
    Sections 5-11(a)(1)(i), 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C), and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D) would permit restaurants to install transparent vertical winterization coverings on all sides of sidewalk and roadway cafes between November 30 and March 31. The proposed rules also permit vertical protective coverings during adverse weather conditions outside the winter season, potentially reducing genuinely open-air seating throughout the year.

    Although these structures would remain legally classified as outdoor dining, enclosing them on all sides creates conditions similar to indoor dining, and cuts off natural ventilation. For disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers like myself who cannot safely dine indoors, a fully enclosed outdoor structure is not an accessible alternative.

    The COVID-cautious community is an especially important customer base for winter outdoor dining. While many diners move indoors during colder months, those of us taking precautions against airborne illnesses actively seek out open-air seating year-round. For many of us, it is the only way we can patronize restaurants.

    Allowing restaurants to fully enclose these spaces would make them unusable for precisely the customers who depend on and have most patronized winter outdoor dining venues.

    2. Fully enclosed outdoor structures create avoidable public health risks.
    Fully enclosed outdoor dining structures may lack the mechanical ventilation and filtration standards applicable to indoor restaurant spaces. Without adequate air exchange, respiratory aerosols can accumulate, potentially making these structures even less safe than properly ventilated indoor dining rooms.

    This is particularly concerning because the proposed winterization period, November 30 through March 31, overlaps with the season when influenza, RSV, COVID-19, and other respiratory viruses circulate widely.

    Authorizing poorly ventilated, enclosed dining spaces during this period could contribute to preventable infections, hospitalizations, and additional strain on the healthcare system, disproportionately affecting people most vulnerable to respiratory illness and having a trickle down effect on the economic health of the city through increased absenteeism from workplaces and schools.

    Thus, the City should not authorize what are effectively indoor dining environments without ensuring appropriate ventilation protections. Outdoor dining should remain a genuinely open-air alternative, not a separate category of enclosed spaces with potentially weaker air quality safeguards.

    3. Vertical coverings also create barriers for wheelchair users.
    As a wheelchair user, I am concerned that the proposed rules do not adequately address how deployed vertical coverings affect physical accessibility.

    Even when retractable, these coverings can obstruct entrances, narrow circulation space, and make it difficult to maneuver between tables or access seating. Their supports and attachment mechanisms may also interfere with accessible sidewalk paths.

    The rules should explicitly require that coverings, when deployed, preserve accessible entrances, pedestrian clearances, and sufficient wheelchair maneuvering space within dining areas.

    4. Fully enclosed structures could jeopardize public support for outdoor dining.
    Large, substantially enclosed dining structures were among the features of the initial early pandemic outdoor dining program that generated public criticism. Allowing similar structures again risks reviving concerns about bulky enclosures, their appearance, and their impact on public space. Likewise, addressing accessibility proactively reduces costly ADA litigation risk for both the department and businesses in the program.

    I strongly support making outdoor dining permanent and would hate to see renewed opposition jeopardize a program that benefits restaurants, diners, and people with disabilities.

    Preserving its genuinely open-air character would help protect both accessibility and the program’s long-term viability and political will.

    The solution: Amend the proposed rules to require at least one fully open side during service.
    I urge DOT to amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), along with the corresponding provisions governing vertical protective coverings, to require minimum ventilation opening standards that can be achieved by requiring at least one entire side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe remain fully open to outside air whenever patrons are present.

    This requirement should apply year-round, including during winterization and adverse weather conditions.

    Proposed regulatory language:

    “When utiliing vertical protective coverings, at least one entire side of a sidewalk cafe or roadway cafe shall remain fully open to outside air whenever the cafe is occupied by patrons. Such opening shall extend across the full available width of that side, from above any required safety barrier or perimeter demarcation to the overhead covering, if present, and shall remain unobstructed by curtains, panels, or other materials that substantially restrict natural airflow.”

    I also request that DOT establish enforceable minimum ventilation-opening standards and explicitly prohibit coverings or associated structures from obstructing accessible pedestrian routes, entrances, exits, or wheelchair maneuvering space.

    Requiring at least one fully open side is a practical minimum standard that would preserve meaningful outdoor dining access for disabled and immonucompromised New Yorkers while still allowing restaurants to provide weather protection.

    I urge DOT to adopt this amendment and ensure that Dining Out NYC remains accessible, safe, and sustainable for all New Yorkers.

    Thank you for your consideration.

    Sincerely,
    Anna Pakman
    New York City Resident

    Comment added October 22, 2026 10:33pm
  • Anonymous

    Hello,
    In these proposed rules, you are basically authorizing a design that can effectively eliminate meaningful OUTDOOR dining access for some disabled New Yorkers and people who covid vigilent and trying as hard as they can to protect there health by not eating indoors. The designs need to REQUIRE FULLY OUTDOOR seating that enables people to eat in a clear air environment. The current design plans look to enable businesses to basiaclly create an additional INCLOSED space. OUTDOOR dinning should be OUTDOORS so that all NYCers can benefit and have access to dinning and not only people who don’t wear masks. Please make it possible for people who wear masks to more easily particiapte in this economy.

    Comment added October 30, 2026 2:06pm
  • Joshua Shapiro

    Regarding potential changes to the City’s outdoor dining regulations, I would hope that in exchange for allowing a great deal of public space to be used to generate private profit, that the City will require some common-sense parameters within which this program would operate. To that end, I, and many others, strongly believe that the rules associated with this program must comprehensively deal with the following:

    1) Promulgation of design standards to ensure high quality, easy to maintain, attractive and durable setups, and no return of the “crap shacks” or similar. Rigorous enforcement of these standards, with penalties for violations great enough that self-enforcement will be more prevalent than it has been.

    2) Rules requiring temporary dismantling of street dining structures during snowstorms severe enough to require declaration of a “snow emergency” (or if that terminology is no longer utilized, whatever snow accumulation was necessary for it to be used).

    3) Rules requiring temporary dismantling of street dining structures when the roadway they sit on is scheduled for milling/repaving. This was not the case before, leading to hundreds of instances of non-repaved stretches of roadway that were beneath dining structures when the roadbed was resurfaced.

    4) Rules to ensure that street dining structures and sidewalk tables are actually for proper dining rather than simply corrals for loud drinkers?

    Comment added October 30, 2026 2:55pm
  • Lindsey Cormack

    I am a Co-Chair of the Street Life Committee of Manhattan Community Board 8, but I am writing in my individual capacity as a citizen to offer comments on the proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC regulations.
    Outdoor dining has become an important part of New York City’s restaurant scene. However, through my time on Community Board 8, I have become increasingly concerned about the loss of accessible public sidewalk space, the proliferation of structures that appear inconsistent with outdoor dining requirements, and the difficulties residents face in obtaining enforcement of existing rules.

    Our sidewalks are public spaces that serve everyone. Their primary purpose must remain the safe and accessible movement of pedestrians. We need rules that recognize the importance of commercial activity without allowing that activity to compromise the public’s right to move freely throughout our neighborhoods.

    I urge DOT to consider the following 3 comments before adopting the proposed regulations:

    1. Protect pedestrian clearances
    The proposed changes to Sections 5-01 and 5-11 would clarify that the width of the curb is included in the pedestrian clear-path measurement and allow drive rails to be excluded as obstructions, subject to a six-foot clearance requirement. I am concerned that these changes could reduce the amount of space that pedestrians can actually use.

    A pedestrian clearance should reflect the space through which people can safely and comfortably travel, including people using wheelchairs, walkers, strollers, or other mobility devices. A curb is not the equivalent of usable sidewalk space.

    I urge DOT to:
    • Preserve the existing minimum pedestrian clear-path widths, generally eight feet or more depending on corridor classification and sidewalk width, without counting space that cannot reasonably be used for pedestrian circulation.
    • Require a continuous, unobstructed path rather than allowing irregular café boundaries and recesses to create narrow pinch points.
    • Clarify that the proposed six-foot clearance from drive rails does not supersede the otherwise applicable pedestrian clear-path requirement.
    The goal should be a genuinely usable sidewalk, not one that technically complies with measurements but is difficult to navigate.

    2. Reconsider reduced setbacks near crosswalks and intersections
    The proposed amendment to Section 5-11(b)(1)(vii) would reduce the minimum setback on the approaching-vehicle side of certain crosswalks. Intersections are where pedestrians are most vulnerable, and roadway dining structures can interfere with sightlines between drivers and people entering crosswalks.

    I urge DOT to retain stronger setbacks wherever necessary to protect visibility and publish the safety rationale for any reductions. I also support the proposed eight-foot clearance from pedestrian ramps, provided that it protects the full accessible approach to and from those ramps.
    Flexibility for restaurants should not take priority over the visibility and safety of people crossing our streets.

    3. Make enforcement meaningful and timely
    The proposed penalties provide a first-offense fine of $200 and a subsequent-offense fine of $500 for many violations, including failures to maintain required pedestrian clearances and comply with approved site plans.

    I appreciate the effort to establish more specific violations, but fines alone are insufficient if noncompliant structures remain in place.
    A restaurant should not be able to treat a fine as an acceptable cost of occupying public space.

    I urge DOT to establish clear correction deadlines, prompt follow-up inspections, and escalating enforcement for repeated violations, including suspension or revocation of licenses when appropriate.

    Violations that obstruct accessible pedestrian routes should receive priority attention and require immediate corrective action.

    My central concern is that we should not continue expanding the use of public sidewalks and roadways for private commercial purposes without equally strengthening the protections that allow the public to use those spaces safely.

    As we consider these rules, I hope DOT will place particular emphasis on the experiences of pedestrians, older adults, people with disabilities, parents with strollers, and others who rely on unobstructed public sidewalks every day.

    Thank you for considering these comments.

    Comment added October 30, 2026 5:10pm
  • Talya

    I second Emma’s comment!
    We need better and more safe [in terms of clean air] outdoor dinning options.

    Comment added October 31, 2026 6:51am
  • Jeff G.

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining. However, I am deeply concerned about these proposed rules, which could undermine the success of the program and shut out the very people who most rely on and support it. I urge DOT to amend these rules to preserve open air dining.

    NYC’s outdoor dining program was originally created to give people a safer way to eat out and gather with a lower risk of viral infection. Many New Yorkers, especially those who are disabled, immunocompromised, and high-risk, continue to rely on it for this purpose. My family and I are able to enjoy the great food and cultural life offered by this city only when there is outdoor seating to allow us to do so safely. While many diners choose to head indoors during the winter, we and others like us reliably support restaurants’ outdoor spaces all year, and are a core part of the constituency that makes year-round outdoor dining economically feasible.

    An outdoor dining space enclosed on all four sides with plastic sheeting, as allowed in these proposed rules, is functionally no longer outdoor dining. It is an indoor space transported to the sidewalk or street, with no meaningful airflow. It is not a safe environment for medically vulnerable New Yorkers and others trying to avoid getting sick.

    Furthermore, DOT’s proposed rules go far beyond the legislation passed by the City Council to allow winterization. The Council legislation allows enclosures from December through March, and specifically applies to sidewalk cafes. DOT’s proposed rules apply these changes to roadway cafes as well, and allow enclosures year-round during “adverse weather,” which is very broadly defined. You allow structures to be enclosed for cold temperatures, but do not give a maximum temperature that qualifies. You allow structures to be enclosed in the case of actual or forecast adverse weather, so if there’s a 20% chance of rain at 8pm a restaurant could choose to enclose their outdoor dining all day. Because of the vagueness of the definitions, there is no real limit on when enclosures can be used and it is purely up to restaurants’ discretion. As written, these rules will threaten the availability of open air dining all year round.

    I encourage DOT to amend these rules to preserve meaningful outdoor dining access. I would propose the following changes:

    Require the sidewalk facing side of outdoor dining structures to remain open and unobstructed. This would still allow coverings on three sides plus a roof and heaters to provide protection from cold and rain, while ensuring that outdoor dining remains open air.

    Allow winterization only from December through March, consistent with the legislation passed by the City Council. Even during this period, at least one side should remain open and uncovered for ventilation.

    Thank you for considering my comments.

    Comment added November 2, 2026 1:05pm
  • Anonymous

    I’m requesting that there be an update that preserves genuinely open-air dining options, that is, my family and friends who are immunocompromised and at risk would like winterized cafes to maintain a meaningful and well defined opening for ventilation during service, so we can enjoy dining at their establishments.

    As currently framed, the city is authorizing a design that can effectively eliminate meaningful outdoor dining access for at-risk New Yorkers, my loved ones included, who need to continue taking airborne pathogen avoidance measures; outdoor dining is a godsend for folks in our camp. Please don’t shut us out.

    Comment added November 2, 2026 3:24pm
  • Talia Miele

    As a disabled person who also has immune deficiency issues, outdoor dining can be a lifeline. I cannot eat indoors given the constant, year round spread of COVID and the what was once season, flu. Eating outdoors allows me to socialize and enjoy what NYC does best, food, more than just 2-3 months of the year. If not, I am extremely limited in what I can do in the months restaurants don’t have genuine outdoor seating. Outdoor seating must be safe and accessible for ALL disabilities, not just physical ones. That includes providing clean air and air flow for those of us with invisible disabilities and chronic illnesses, but also our fellow NYers experiencing chemo, etc, or who just don’t want to be reinfected again and again during COVID/flu waves.

    I ask that you require that winterized cafes maintain a meaningful and well defined opening for ventilation during service.

    If the city allows fully enclosed dining outside of the restaurant’s original square footage, that’s is an extension, and not actually outdoor dining.

    I ask that you create a dining experience that is inclusive for all NYers and not assume that disabilities are solely ones that require a wheelchair. There are many kinds of disabilities and all require that we have clean air. Please remember that the disability community is the only one that WE ALL become a part of eventually. So if not for your fellow NYers, create safe outdoor dining for yourselves and your loved ones. Everyone benefits from clean air, and everyone deserves to enjoy the unique food scene that makes NYC the most diverse and unique city in the world.

    Comment added November 2, 2026 9:41pm
  • Ellen M

    I have long covid having contracted covid 3x even with protection, and i have barely (and only at great personal risk) spent any time in an enclosed space without a mask in the last 6 years. When there was genunine open air dining (and wherever there may still be) i can at least enjoy a meal with friends, meet a colleague or prospect or client, or simply sit down on a weary day for a bite (and because of my condition which includes fatigue along with some more structural issues in the legs– i need to sit and rest frequently)

    For outdoor dining to benefit anyone it must have adequate ventilation, even in winter. I seek a revision that preserves genuinely open-air dining options. While i personally am not a great crafter of legislative language it seems this should be framed to require winterized cafes to maintain a meaningful and well defined opening for ventilation during service. I see some others have commented with good suggestions which may be worth taking up.

    The city is authorizing a design that can effectively eliminate meaningful outdoor dining access for disabled New Yorkers such as myself without addressing that impact in its design standards.

    Comment added November 3, 2026 7:00am
  • Kate

    Hi, I would love for the amendments to include language to preserve the open air dining experience. I personally choose outdoor dining for many reasons some of which are a genuine love of being outside, people watching of course, and a big one is the ventilation of being outdoors. The ventilation of a fully open or even semi open structure feels especially important in cold/flu season. If there is a way to discourage outdoor sheds from becoming fully enclosed in the winter (or year round) for those of us who don’t want to (or can’t afford to) get sick that would be ideal.

    Comment added November 3, 2026 8:41am
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining is important and is a huge benefit to both restaurants and customers but allowing them to be fully enclosed hurts wheelchair users and limits access it also removes any benefit to immunocompromised individuals, who were the initial target of allowing outdoor dining to begin with.
    COVID was and still is a mass disabling event that continues to injure and kill our community. Please take steps to protect those who are vulnerable, which in reality is everyone, not only those who are aware and vocal

    Comment added November 3, 2026 3:19pm
  • Vicky K

    I strongly urge the NYC DOT to require that at least one side of every outdoor dining structure remain open to the air.

    Fully enclosing outdoor dining structures defeats much of the purpose of outdoor dining and creates significant barriers for people with disabilities. I know people with disabilities who would be directly and negatively affected by this policy, whether due to limited mobility, the need for wheelchair accessibility, or health concerns that make proper ventilation especially important.

    Outdoor dining should be an inclusive option that makes restaurants more accessible to everyone, not a space that inadvertently excludes people who already have fewer options. Requiring at least one side to remain open would preserve ventilation, a necessity for many.

    Restaurants can still protect patrons from cold weather with heaters, awnings, and other weather protections without fully enclosing these spaces.

    Please prioritize accessibility, public health, and inclusion in the final regulations. New Yorkers with disabilities and compromised immune systems deserve to enjoy our city’s restaurants and public spaces just like everyone else.

    Comment added November 3, 2026 4:10pm
  • Jan McGold

    The NYC Council passed year round outdoor dining but included a provision that effectively kills real outdoor dining as we know it by allowing restaurants to fully enclose their outdoor dining spaces, rendering them useless to disabled people like me who need to stay safe from respiratory viruses and less accessible for other types of disabilities as the walls will obstruct the free movement that makes outdoor patio tables easier to access in a wheelchair.

    Please ensure that outdoor dining patios remains open air to allow for ventilation and easy wheelchair/mobility device access. This still allows restaurants to “winterize” these spaces with heaters and protection from the elements while maintaining accessibility and the outdoor nature of outdoor dining.

    There is still hundreds, if not thousands, of New York City residents who cannot socialize indoors without a mask because of health issues. The city had a chance to protect its citizens when the pandemic started by ensuring the public indoor spaces upgraded to high quality ventilation, air purifies, hepa HVAC and far uvc tech. Since that was not done, outdoor dining is one of the few places that provide a lower risk for us to eat and drink without a mask.

    Though covid mitigation is a thing of the past, covid isn’t. Don’t lock us back in our homes for the winter with no safe options for experiencing a small semblance of normal life

    Comment added November 3, 2026 6:36pm
  • Anonymous

    Please keep outside dining available to those who have health issues and cannot eat indoors. Please at least leave one side open for people who cannot eat in a closed space. If the outdoor space is enclosed then it is not any different than eating indoors. Please help those who have health issues and cannot eat indoors.

    Comment added November 3, 2026 9:35pm
  • Stacey

    Outdoor dining should remain OUTDOOR. At least one wall open. Fully enclosed structures defeat the whole point of outdoor dining. For the immunocompromised in our community, outdoor dining options are crucial given the increased transmission of covid and other respiratory illnesses during the winter months. Outdoor dining is great as long as it actually remains outdoor.

    Comment added November 3, 2026 11:08pm
  • yolanda trujillo

    Supporting New York City’s Restaurants and Small Businesses

    As someone who works closely with the daily financial, administrative, and operational challenges of running neighborhood restaurants in New York City, I welcome the opportunity to share our experiences and advocate for a more supportive business environment.

    Our restaurant group has served the Upper West Side community for more than 35 years. Throughout those years, we have provided employment, supported families, contributed to our neighborhoods, and worked diligently to remain responsible business operators.

    However, the challenges facing restaurants today are extraordinary. Rising operating expenses, insurance premiums, utilities, rent, labor costs, regulatory requirements, and administrative obligations have made it increasingly difficult for independent restaurants to remain financially viable.

    We understand and respect the importance of regulations designed to protect employees, customers, and the public. What we ask for is a system that is easier to navigate, more transparent, and more responsive to the realities of operating a small business.

    We would welcome improvements such as streamlined licensing and permitting, clearer guidance on compliance requirements, better coordination among city agencies, reasonable opportunities to correct unintentional violations, and more flexible payment arrangements when businesses experience financial hardship.

    For small restaurant operators, time spent navigating complicated administrative procedures is time taken away from serving customers, managing employees, and growing our businesses.

    Behind every restaurant are people—employees who have dedicated decades of their lives to their jobs, families who depend on their income, and communities that have grown alongside these establishments.

    We are not asking to be excused from our responsibilities. We are asking for a reasonable opportunity to meet those responsibilities while continuing to operate, employ New Yorkers, and contribute to the economic and social fabric of our city.

    Making New York City more business-friendly means recognizing that the survival of neighborhood restaurants is about much more than business owners. It is about preserving livelihoods, opportunities, and the character of the communities we serve.

    Thank you for inviting our input and for considering the voices of those working every day to keep New York City’s restaurants open.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 1:16pm
  • Erin

    Please do not make “streeteries” enclosed. Please amend the rules to require at least one side of the structure to be fully open to the outdoors. You can still effectively heat the space, if needed, this way. I lived in New York City from 2014 to 2021 and during the early days of the pandemic, I was so grateful to still be able to get out and enjoy New York’s food scene without worrying about contracting a disease. In 2026, contrary to popular belief, Covid is still raging, especially in densely populated areas, and hundreds of people living in and visiting New York would be thrilled to have options for eating outdoors.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 1:45pm
  • Emily Hooper

    Please amend the rules to require at least one side to be fully open to the outdoors.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 2:13pm
  • Anonymous

    I am a frequent visitor to NY (and lived there for many years). Outdoor dining is the way I keep myself and loved ones safe. I’ve even eaten outside in the winter with strong heaters going. Please keep outdoor dining easy for restaurants to adhere to any requirements. It will be hard for me to continue my visits if restaurants take it away.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 3:01pm
  • Inna

    Outdoor dining is important to my family as we continue to protect ourselves from respiratory viruses, especially in the winter. We welcome year round outdoor dining, but it’s important that the rules are updated so that outdoor dining stays actually outdoors. Fully enclosed outdoor setups are useless for us as that eliminates all ventilation, but I would be able to continue to eat out if at least one side of the dining structure remained completely open air. Thank you.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 7:15pm
  • Aviva

    I am immunocompromised. Without truly open outdoor dining I completely lose my ability to go to restaurants due to my disability.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 8:50pm
  • N R

    The rules should be amended to require at least one side to be fully open to the outdoors. This worked for most of us who do outdoor dining as it was the most common setup during 2020-2024 before the rules changed, because it still allows restaurants to effectively heat this space, while still providing ventilation.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 10:27pm
  • Ruth Goldberg

    As a disabled person who need to stay safe from respiratory viruses the new provision allowing restaurants to fully enclose their outdoor dining makes dining out completely inaccessible for me and thousands of other disabled New Yorkers. Please ask the DOT to ensure that at least one side of each outdoor dining patio remains open air to allow for ventilation and easy wheelchair/mobility device access. This still allows restaurants to “winterize” these spaces with heaters and protection from the elements while maintaining accessibility and the outdoor nature of outdoor dining.

    Thank you!

    Comment added November 4, 2026 10:36pm
  • Deborah

    As someone with friends and family who must be Covid safe due to medical conditions, I ask you to amend the bill to support true open air dining. An outdoor dining space enclosed on all four sides with plastic sheeting, as allowed in these proposed rules, is functionally no longer outdoor dining. It is an indoor space transported to the sidewalk or street, with no meaningful airflow. It is not a safe environment for medically vulnerable New Yorkers and others trying to avoid getting sick.

    Furthermore, DOT’s proposed rules go far beyond the legislation passed by the City Council to allow winterization. The Council legislation allows enclosures from December through March, and specifically applies to sidewalk cafes. DOT’s proposed rules apply these changes to roadway cafes as well, and allow enclosures year-round during “adverse weather,” which is very broadly defined. You allow structures to be enclosed for cold temperatures, but do not give a maximum temperature that qualifies. You allow structures to be enclosed in the case of actual or forecast adverse weather, so if there’s a 20% chance of rain at 8pm a restaurant could choose to enclose their outdoor dining all day. As written, these rules will threaten the availability of open air dining all year round.

    Please consider adopting the council’s rules that will allow outdoor dining for all of the city’s population, including the chronically ill, for most of the year.

    Comment added November 4, 2026 10:57pm
  • Anonymous

    Please require that at least one side of outdoor dining structures remain open. Many people, including me, only eat outside for the sake of health and safety, and doing so in enclosed structures takes away all benefits of sidewalk or parklet dining. Outdoor dining needs to be outdoors and open air in order to have the benefits of accessibility. I just want to eat some of New York’s amazing food without risking my health, and that’s impossible with fully enclosed outdoor structures that typically have even worse air circulation than indoor dining, a situation that benefits no one, regardless of their health situation.

    Comment added November 5, 2026 12:55am
  • Anonymous

    I am not an NYC resident, but I do frequent the city for business, and would love to continue to enjoy and support the local restaurants. As someone who is at high risk to complications from airborne illnesses such as COVID-19, it would be in the interest of not only my health, but the health of every New York resident and visitor, to also require at least one of the long sides of the outdoor dining area to be completely open to the outside, or that at least 3 sides are open for at least one third of their surface area to the outside (e.g. windows, holes of lattices, etc.). Giving people a health-conscious option will help restaurants by making their services accessible and also reducing the severity of the current and future pandemics such that full lockdowns are not as necessary.

    Comment added November 5, 2026 1:17am
  • Andrew Goldstein

    I have been a resident of Hell’s Kitchen since 1991. My apartment faces both 9th avenue & a side street in the west 50’s with a school at the end of my block. I am a member of the HK50-54 Block association but speaking as an individual here.
    During & after the pandemic my neighborhood became the wild west in regard to outdoor dining. No clear paths. Bars cut out windows to play music for people outside. Stage constructed in street for daily live concerts which took months to get taken down. Hell’s kitchen residents (& the rest of the City) need a better balance between helping businesses survive while balancing out QOL concerns of the public. The 2024 revised Dining Out policy helped some but there are still major gaps in the new amended rules in August which I think should be addressed as we have both good & bad business operators.

    1) Enforcement is lacking.
    It appears that the DOT inspectors of complaints work mainly during the day during weekdays. There needs to be DOT inspectors at night to investigate complaints, especially around hours & noise that do not occur 9am-5pm Monday-Friday.

    I think DOT should also take a proactive stance on violations and have teams of DOT enforcement officers take walks on Friday & Saturday nights in the more problematic neighborhoods looking out for the larger chronic offenders.

    2) Dining Out Complaint Reporting Issues & Resolution Follow Up
    It is extremely hard to find the correct 311 option to report the appropriate dining out complaint. Often there is not an option for a specific complaint, so I try to pick the best one. These complaints were incorrectly routed to wrong city agency and closed. When Dining Out 311 Complaints are investigated it’s extremely difficult to find out what the final resolution of the complaint was. The 311 system & DOT inspectors are critical to ensure the balance between the community and in scope business is maintained. There should be a specific 311 category for each type of complaint list in pages 22-28 which list types of violations.

    3) NOISE (musical instruments & sound amplification)
    I appreciate that speakers (including music, TV’s including sports) have specifically been codified for sidewalk cafes & street sheds. Outdoor speakers require a police permit.

    A big problem that NEEDS to be addressed is when establishments have loud music, TV, SPORTS, bands inside but leave the doors & windows wide open. I go to many MCB4 Beverage and Licensing Permit (BLP)Meetings where the applicants & community board agree on SLA Stipulations. One of these stipulations is that doors & windows need to be closed at all times when amplified sound is being played. Most operators in my neighborhood leave their windows & facades open all day/night long created noise issues from nearby residents.

    When I walk down 9th avenue, I don’t hear lots of outdoor speakers however the sound is BLASTING from inside establishments from open facades, doors, & windows. I THINK SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE ADDED TO THE LEGISLATION TO ADDRESS THIS or have it added into the list of violations.

    Many of the same establishments seat people until closing time which means there are usually people still there drinking 45 minutes-hour after the actual closing time. The new closing time of 11 needs to be communicated & enforced.

    4) There needs to be a Public Query portal for Outdoor Dining Permits/ Licenses with details including as much detail as possible such as seasonal/year-round, seating capacity and layout.

    5) Several establishments around me often combine smaller tables into large single tables to accommodate large groups (30+ on a single table in an outdoor shed & a single 16-seat table created at a Sports Bar on many occasions). This increases both noise & street congestion. Is it permissible for an establishment to rearrange seating plans at will to accommodate large parties?

    6) Many sidewalk cafes do not have full perimeter fences and waiters serve from the side walks further blocking clear paths. Often extra chairs are stacked on sidewalk next to street sheds and restaurant serving supplies (water bottles, bus trays) are not always in the café perimeter and intrude into the clear space.

    7) Inclement weather:
    After last Winter’s big snowstorm, the City created several giant snow mounds/glaciers on several corner of 9th avenue in Hell’s Kitchen which were they for about 2 weeks. During this period, I could walk across the street as the street shed at the corner had been removed. If the same shed is part of year-round outdoor dining and we have a similar storm, I will need to cross the street in the middle of the block while trying to look around the street shed to make sure no traffic is coming. THIS IS VERY DANAGEROUS. The procedures for clearing roads during large weather events does not seem to be actually vetted on how streets, sidewalks be kept clear to avoid people getting hurt. As aside, my street has not been cleaned since before the pandemic.

    8) Communication of Dining out Rule Changes needs to be better.
    I struggled to find out about the key meetings relating to the changes of outdoor dining so I could voice my opinion. I went to about 7 meetings MCB4, Block association from Feb-April and then everything went quiet until I heard the vote for the changes in August.
    Operators don’t seem to understand the rules and I’m not sure how they get the communications and details. I’ve been to many MCB4 BLP meetings where lawyers are sent and not the owners, so the establishment never ends up understanding their rules and doesn’t communicate them to staff. We have struggled to get some business owners to our Block Association meetings to discuss.
    The communication of forums where the community can speak up needs to be better so we can voice opinions before the legislation is voted upon.
    If nothing else if there was 1 DOT web page with the upcoming meetings, agendas and timelines for potential legislation that was in layman’s terms would help NYC residents greatly.

    9A) I agree with the comments from Leslie Boghosian-Murphy of the MCB4 that clear paths need to be better defined.
    In Hell’s Kitchen on 9th Avenue between 42nd & 57th streets its is extremely difficult to walk along the avenue. The number of outdoor tables (legal & illegal), plants, A frame signs, menu stands, bikes & garbage make it extremely difficult to walk down the street. It is imperative that the operators participating in outdoor dining UNDERSTAND & FOLLOW the revised Dining Out legislation. This does not seem to be the case and setup is not always communicated to staff.

    9B) I strongly agree with comments from Lindsey Cormack about the need for clear paths especially:
    “My central concern is that we should not continue expanding the use of public sidewalks and roadways for private commercial purposes without equally strengthening the protections that allow the public to use those spaces safely.
    As we consider these rules, I hope DOT will place particular emphasis on the experiences of pedestrians, older adults, people with disabilities, parents with strollers, and others who rely on unobstructed public sidewalks every day.”

    Comment added November 5, 2026 4:12pm
  • And.rew Wa.ng

    Dear NYC DOT:

    Outside dining or dining outside is an important offering. It has dual purposes, an option for NYers to enjoy pleasant weather while enjoying a meal with restaurants to expand their business as well as ensure a public benefit for any future pandemics that are airborne based diseases.

    As a public health professional, I appreciate outdoor dining. The benefits of both are invaluable. I strongly urge DOT that the rules ensure at least one side or area of any outside enclosures to be fully open to ensure good airflow from the outdoor air. Pragmatically this ensures restaurants are able to effectively heat this space, while still providing ventilation.

    It is important to ensure these new guidelines work for the short and long-term.

    Thank you,

    And.rew Wa.ng, PhD, MPH, CPH
    Columbia School of Public Health 2010

    Comment attachment
    Comment-Re-Outdoor-Dining-NYC-11-5-2026.pdf
    Comment added November 5, 2026 9:03pm
  • Anonymous

    I enjoy actual outdoor dining throughout the year. The rules to enclose outdoor dining goes against the intent and the purpose of what outdoor dining is meant to seeve. Why would the City allow an enclosure? An enclosure not only takes up public space (which people will complain about like they did during covid), but what is the difference between an enclosure and regular indoor space? An outdoor space should be opened on at least one side AT THE MINIMUM to allow fresh outdoor air to be ventilated throughout the space. There is no rationale to have an enclosed “outdoor” space.

    Comment added November 5, 2026 9:59pm
  • LM

    This rule to allow enclosures defeats the purpose of outdoor dining. Enclosures cost money to set up. For restaurant owners (where the margins are thin), setting up the enclosures and taking down the enclosures cost the restaurant money and time. Therefore, does the City actually believe that the restaurants will ever take down the enclosures after winter is over? The vague rules that allow these enclosures during undefined “bad weather events” will make it exceedingly difficult for the DOT to enforce these rules. Therefore, restaurants should not be allowed to enclosure “outdoor” dining, and outdoor dining should remain truly outdoors.

    Comment added November 5, 2026 10:14pm
  • Lisa

    As a person who is self-employed and a caregiver for my mom, I am very health-conscious and dining outdoors allows me to be able to go out and socialize without as much risk of getting ill. By having only fully-enclosed outdoor dining structures, to be this is comparable to dining indoors, and thus, excludes me from being able to go out to eat during the winter season. Even if these weren’t my concerns, I’m not truly understanding how a fully enclosed structure even qualifies as “outdoor dining” as it’s merely an extension of the restaurant’s space onto the sidewalk or street. How is this appealing to the average customer? I would much prefer to be in the main restaurant than on the street where the atmosphere would be considerably nicer. I love being outside and with heaters and perhaps a lap blanket, it’s quite nice. I urge you to consider those who are immunocompromised and health-conscious when making decisions on outdoor dining, as this population would be completely excluded if there was no outside airflow in the enclosed space. This would also clearly impact the financial benefits of being able to accomodate additional diners with more space.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 6:43am
  • Alexa

    As a frequent visitor of NYC, and also someone who takes Covid and airborne illness very seriously due to having multiple immunocompromised family members, having a safe space to eat outdoors is incredibly important. 3 of the 4 sides can be enclosed for warmth, but to enclose them all, especially without an HVAC system, is not an option for those of us who want to try to avoid getting sick. We need good air quality and air flow and I believe clean air is a human right! Please change the rules to have at least one side open and give us folks a place to eat drink and be merry!

    Comment added November 6, 2026 9:46am
  • Talese

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 9:56am
  • Makenzie

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 9:56am
  • Carina K

    I am a New York City resident with a condition that makes me high risk for serious complications from COVID-19.
    Because of these risks, I wear a KN95 style mask in public indoor spaces.
    Outdoor dining allows me to participate in New York City’s restaurant culture and maintain social relationships with friends and family without unnecessarily compromising my health.
    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining. However, I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to enclose outdoor dining areas on all sides would undermine accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, create public health risks, and potentially threaten the long-term success of the program.

    1. Fully enclosed structures are not meaningfully outdoor dining.
    The COVID-cautious community is an especially important customer base for winter outdoor dining. While many diners move indoors during colder months, those of us taking precautions against airborne illnesses actively seek out open-air seating year-round. For many of us, it is the only way we can safely patronize restaurants. Allowing restaurants to fully enclose these spaces would make them unusable for precisely the customers who depend on and have most patronized winter outdoor dining venues.

    2. Fully enclosed outdoor structures create avoidable public health risks.
    Fully enclosed outdoor dining structures may lack the mechanical ventilation and filtration standards applicable to indoor restaurant spaces. Without adequate air exchange, respiratory aerosols can accumulate, potentially making these structures even less safe than properly ventilated indoor dining rooms.

    This is particularly concerning because the proposed winterization period, November 30 through March 31, overlaps with the season when influenza, RSV, COVID-19, and other respiratory viruses circulate widely.

    Authorizing poorly ventilated, enclosed dining spaces during this period could contribute to preventable infections, hospitalizations, and additional strain on the healthcare system, disproportionately affecting people most vulnerable to respiratory illness and having a trickle down effect on the economic health of the city through increased absenteeism from workplaces and schools.
    Thus, the City should not authorize what are effectively indoor dining environments without ensuring appropriate ventilation protections. Outdoor dining should remain a genuinely open-air alternative, not a separate category of enclosed spaces with potentially weaker air quality safeguards.
    Thank you for your consideration!

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:01am
  • Anonymous

    I strongly support outdoor dining but am against fully enclosed outdoor dining. There should be at least one side open for fresh air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:03am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:04am
  • Jean Kim

    Outdoor dining areas should not be fully enclosed. A fully enclosed outdoor dining area is just making another indoor dining area. At least one (long) side should remain open. A fully enclosed outdoor dining area defeats the purpose of outdoor dining. A fully enclosed outdoor dining area will have insufficient air flow and ventilation.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:05am
  • J. Kirby

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Outdoor dining is important to me because I can eat at a restaurant without risking illness from infectious diseases. Once the area is enclosed, it’s back to being off-limits.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:09am
  • Mick

    I am immunocompromised and outdoor dining has been an important part of my ability to socialize with others, especially since the COVID-19 pandemic began.

    COVID isn’t over, especially for those of us who are disabled and immunocompromised. Please take care to not only preserve outdoor dining year round, but to ensure that these structures are not simply more fully enclosed dining on the sidewalk. Outdoor dining MUST have air circulation. **At least one long side of all outdoor dining structures must remain open to provide air flow.

    Please include this in the outdoor dining rules.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:10am
  • Laura

    I support outdoor dining and would be thrilled to see more restaurants have outdoor dining setups. However, I do not support full enclosures. That would defeat the purpose of an outdoor dining setup for my partner and I, who are Covid-conscious. My partner has long Covid and we seek to minimize our exposure by dining in open air places. At least one side of an outdoor set up should remain open/unenclosed. Thank you for listening to these comments and taking them seriously. It is much appreciated!

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:14am
  • Anonymous

    I fully support our door dining and would like it to remain year round. However, I oppose allowing it to be a fully enclosed space. There are many people who rely on outdoor dining who have concerns about being in fully enclosed spaces for health reasons who would be excluded from using a fully enclosed space. Leaving one side open allows for fresh air for those who still wish to outdoor dine and avoid the cold. Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:16am
  • Anonymous

    I appreciate the efforts to make outdoor dining year round but agree with others that it should be meaningfully outdoors. Being enclosed does not help those who are seeking outdoor dining for health purposes. As someone with Long COVID, I have not eaten inside in a restaurant since 2020 to protect my health and I would like to keep it that way. Outdoor air flow is very important as is the opportunity eat at restaurants and support NYC dining. Please consider stipulations for
    truly outdoor dining with air flow.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:32am
  • Michele

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:32am
  • Rachael Metz

    Please amend the outdoor dining rules so that they are not fully enclosed. I only eat outdoors to reduce COVID infections and will not eat if fully enclosed because it is not open air. I fully support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:34am
  • Olivia Chavez

    Please make sure that outdoor dining structures are open air – at least 1 side being open for ventilation. I cannot dine inside restaurants due to my disability and enclosed outdoor dining does not solve the issue.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:45am
  • Bre Bat

    I support outdoor dining, but not full enclosures. At least one side should be open at all times to air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:55am
  • Anonymous

    Please do not fully enclose the outdoor dining; at least one side should remain partially open for air flow, for the air quality to remain safe. Outdoor dining is frequented by Covid conscious people and will NOT be if the dining is enclosed. Protect everyone by maintaining air flow

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:12am
  • Michelle

    Please allow outdoor dining to continue in NYC. This is the only way some of us can safely enjoy a meal without the risk of sharing indoor, germ-filled air. Don’t take this safer option away from the people that really need and enjoy the outdoor dining experience.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:21am
  • allison hurwitz

    I support outdoor dining, and it’s a real benefit to both restaurants and customers. However, fully enclosed outdoor structures undermine its purpose. They can limit access for wheelchair users, and they remove the air-flow benefits that make outdoor dining safer for immunocompromised people.
    I’d ask that at least one side of every outdoor dining setup remain open to the air. This keeps these spaces accessible and allows immunocompromised individuals to safely dine at restaurants.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:24am
  • Kimberly Billingslea

    I am reporting this slumlord that abused his power which is in Brooklyn.

    Locations are:
    The Community Solutions Group
    Elite Management

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:24am
  • Susan Barnett

    I love that restaurants across the boroughs have outdoor dining year round. Let’s expand, not contract, this kind of support for the many food options that reflect our vibrant city. NYC is not the suburbs and was never meant to be. The great cities of the world support outdoor dining, and so should we.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:25am
  • Anonymous

    I miss the days of unique food options late at night in NYC. I understand that for a variety of reasons that kind of availability has changed, but I’d like to say, as a native, it gave the city’s robust nightlife a bit of charm.

    While charm is on the topic, there are way too many basic, tasteless and unnecessary food establishments in my neighborhood. There are at least five bodega style stores within a two block radius of 29th and 10th, why?

    While many of the street sheds have disappeared, some still remain and they are an eyesore, not to mention safety concerns for their proximity to cars in the road. Lastly, should the street sheds return in warmer temps, please consider that many of us who live here drive and seek parking for our cars on a daily basis. I I understand the popularity of Manhattan and the need for several people‘s needs to be met, but I often feel like as someone living here we’re the last to be considered, and I’d like that to change.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:38am
  • Ella Ryan

    I fully support outdoor dining in our city but please keep it outdoors! Fully enclosing structures is problematic for many reasons. We’re not trying to cover our city in shacks just to expand seats for restaurants. Outdoor dining in every other city remains outdoors – in all weather. The whole point is to be outdoors. Fully enclosed structures have no airflow – negating the reason many people want to dine outdoors. They are more unsafe – essentially buildings without the same safety rules. They have more surfaces for graffiti and posters. More material to degrade, more places for vermin to hide. Outdoor dining enclosures tend to be built cheaply with unsightly materials.
    Many people rely on outdoor dining because they don’t feel safe dining indoors. Why are we making outdoor dining essentially an indoor experience?
    True outdoor dining makes you feel connected to your city, sitting outside and people watching. Think any European city. If we allow enclosures they will probably stay up all year and take away the whole experience of outdoor dining. Instead of being vibrant social spaces, outdoor dining just becomes little fogged-up capsules of people in parking spots.
    An awning and a heat lamp is enough for most weather. Anything worse and it’s probably not safe to be in a shack made of vinyl and chipboard anyway.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:49am
  • David

    I’m a Hell’s Kitchen resident, and I fully support roadway dining sheds year-round, even where they take up parking. More public space to enjoy is good for the city. My concern is upkeep, because we’ve seen sheds fail in the past.
    I urge DOT to set and enforce clear maintenance standards. Sheds should never be used for storage or trash. Restaurants should be responsible for rat control, cleaning around and under the structure, and keeping drainage clear. Structures that rot or fall into disrepair should be fixed or removed promptly. Electrical work, especially for winter heating and lighting, should be signed off by a licensed electrician to prevent fires.
    Because street sweepers can’t reach the curb lane where a shed sits, or the gaps right before and after it, debris builds up in those areas. Restaurants should be required to keep the curb and gutter along and next to their shed clean, or DOT and Sanitation should set up another way to clean those stretches.
    I also ask DOT to inspect sheds regularly, with extra checks before and during winter. Fines should go up for repeat violations, and a restaurant that racks up a set number of them should lose its license. And 311 should have its own complaint category for sheds, with a set response time.
    If these standards are enforced, year-round sheds can be an asset to every neighborhood.
    David, Hell’s Kitchen Resident

    Comment added November 6, 2026 12:27pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 12:28pm
  • Shoshana

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining, but I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to enclose outdoor dining areas on all sides would undermine accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, create public health risks, and potentially threaten the long-term success of the program.

    If the space is fully enclosed, it’s not really outdoor dining. As someone who doesn’t want to take their mask off to eat indoors while Covid-19 is still a threat, I rely on full outdoor dining to eat at restaurants. If a space is fully enclosed, I will not eat there. I’d love to be able to eat at restaurants this winter.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 12:39pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 12:53pm
  • Anonymous

    I fully support outdoor dining, but if it’s fully enclosed it is no longer outdoor dining. One side, at the very least, should be open-air. Please consider this. Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:03pm
  • Anonymous (Bronx, 10460)

    Please allow airflow through outdoor dining spaces to keep them fully accessible to people with longterm illnesses/immunocompromised. My spouse has Long Covid and I am recovering from a longterm illness; we are sociable people and would love to be able to more fully participate in NYC life. That means keeping outdoor dining spaces open on at least one side, with windows or other means for air to flow in and out of the structures. Thank you for considering.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:10pm
  • Nick Flutter

    Thank you to the DOT for its work on year-round outdoor dining, and for the opportunity to comment. I’m co-founder of re-ply, an outdoor dining structure vendor listed on the DOT’s Dining Out NYC marketplace. I’m submitting these comments on re-ply’s behalf.

    Background

    re-ply designs, builds and services modular roadway café structures for about 100 restaurants in New York City. We have long supported the program, and we support year-round roadway dining and the direction of the proposed rule. We have always argued for a balanced approach, that meets the needs of the hospitality industry while being fair to communities, inclusive for people of all abilities and positive for NYC’s public realm.

    Having built and maintained these structures for 6 years, we find that the draft provisions on overhead coverings, side coverings and barriers leave several questions unanswered. Clear rules will:
    • give operators certainty and help them operate safely and legally;
    • reduce the risk that a structure fails in severe weather and injures someone or damages property; and
    • reduce the enforcement burden on the Department of Transportation (DOT).

    We don’t want to see injuries or property damage from a structure failure. A failure would be bad for everyone involved in the program, from operators and vendors to the DOT.

    1. Snow load standard for overhead coverings
    (5-11(b)(2)(iv)(B)(3) and 5-10(q))

    The draft requires winter roofs to be “fabricated from materials designed to resist snow and wind loads,” with no quantifiable test. Any roof qualifies by assertion, so an inadequately engineered structure could comply and still be vulnerable to collapse under reasonably heavy snow and strong wind.

    This poses a significant public safety risk. Even when a café is closed for the storm, a collapse may impact nearby pedestrians or vehicles. The alternative, removing the roof during a severe weather alert, is impractical and puts crews on site in dangerous conditions.

    A clear standard also protects restaurants, who would be the first to be held responsible if a roof fails. It gives them a benchmark to specify against when building a structure, and a standard they can show they met. Any operator can meet it with an engineer’s letter; it does not require buying from a vendor.

    We propose:

    1. From winter 2027–28, roofs kept up over winter are certified by a New York professional engineer for the New York City Building Code’s 25 psf ground snow load, with the maximum snow depth defined.
    2. For winter 2026–27, we recommend that operators keeping roofs up obtain an engineer’s letter stating capacity and maximum snow depth, recognizing that timing may not allow this for everyone this season.
    3. Operators clear snow before it reaches the posted depth, and close the café for safety reasons while it is exceeded.

    25 psf is the New York City Building Code’s ground snow load; the engineer converts it to a roof load for each design. Expressing the result as a snow depth gives operators and inspectors something they can measure.

    2. Approved roof designs
    (new clause, modelled on 5-11(b)(2)(i)(G))

    The rule already lets the DOT approve engineered alternative barrier designs. The same route for roofs would mean one engineering review per design rather than one per café. Each restaurant could carry an approval letter – the same as currently happens with engineered barriers. In this way, one-off roofs may still be certified individually.

    3. Vertical winterization coverings
    (5-01 definition; 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D))

    We take no position on how much of a winter café should be enclosed or left open. Our concern is what the enclosure is made of. “Retractable, non-rigid” limits operators to vinyl or other curtains, which flap in wind or traffic, wear quickly and seal poorly. We ask that demountable framed or rigid panels, including sliding doors, be permitted alongside curtains between November 30 and March 31.

    “Clear visibility is maintained” is hard to measure. For example, a transparent zone on every side from 42 to 84 inches above the floor, framing excepted, would be clearer. The zone could be transparent material or slatted or perforated screens, minimum 25% open, that keep sight lines.

    4. Alternative barriers for year-round use
    (5-11(b)(2)(i)(G))

    An alternative barrier design already approved by the DOT should not need to be resubmitted for year-round use, unless the design changes.

    5. Antifreeze in liquid-filled barriers
    (5-11(b)(2)(i)(C))

    As drafted, “liquid-filled” does not prescribe the liquid, so automotive ethylene glycol antifreeze would be permitted. It is toxic to children and pets, and barriers drain to the storm water system. Restaurant staff and install crews will be exposed to it when the barriers are drained, and the natural environment will be impacted when it drains to the sea. We ask that permitted fills be limited to water, calcium chloride brine or propylene glycol.

    6. Service-ready condition
    (5-10(o))

    A year-round café will not open every winter day, and as drafted, stacked chairs on a snow day are a violation. We ask that the requirement apply only during hours the operator has chosen to open, and not during adverse weather or a severe weather alert.

    We would welcome the opportunity to discuss these proposals with DOT staff.

    Comment attachment
    261106_Dining-Out-NYC-Year-round-outdoor-dining-rule-feedback-re-ply.pdf
    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:14pm
  • Amelia Merrill

    Dear NYC Department of Transportation,
    I am a New York City resident who has many loved ones with disabilities that make them high risk for serious complications from COVID-19. Because of these risks, I always wear an N95 or KN95-style mask in public indoor spaces. Outdoor dining allows me to participate in New York City’s restaurant culture and maintain social relationships with friends and family without unnecessarily compromising my health or anyone else’s health.
    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining. However, I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to enclose outdoor dining areas on all sides would undermine accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, create public health risks, and potentially threaten the long-term success of the program.
    I would also like to emphasize that DOT, as a public entity, has obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), as well as applicable provisions of the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL), to ensure that people with disabilities have meaningful access to public programs and services. These protections extend to people with a wide range of disabilities, including those whose medical conditions make them particularly vulnerable to respiratory infections. DOT should therefore consider whether its proposed regulations create unnecessary barriers to access for disabled New Yorkers. Unfortunately, the proposed provisions permitting fully enclosed outdoor dining structures are doing exactly that. Below, I outline the specific accessibility concerns and propose a straightforward amendment that would help address them before the rules are finalized.
    1. Fully enclosed structures are not meaningfully outdoor dining.
    Sections 5-11(a)(1)(i), 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C), and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D) would permit restaurants to install transparent vertical winterization coverings on all sides of sidewalk and roadway cafes between November 30 and March 31. The proposed rules also permit vertical protective coverings during adverse weather conditions outside the winter season, potentially reducing genuinely open-air seating throughout the year.
    Although these structures would remain legally classified as outdoor dining, enclosing them on all sides creates conditions similar to indoor dining, and cuts off natural ventilation. For disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers who cannot safely dine indoors, a fully enclosed outdoor structure is not an accessible alternative.
    The COVID-cautious community is an especially important customer base for winter outdoor dining. While many diners move indoors during colder months, those of us taking precautions against airborne illnesses actively seek out open-air seating year-round. For many of us, it is the only way we can patronize restaurants. I do not want to see locally-owned restaurants lose this customer base for a substantial portion of the year.
    Allowing restaurants to fully enclose these spaces would make them unusable for precisely the customers who depend on and have most patronized winter outdoor dining venues.
    2. Fully enclosed outdoor structures create avoidable public health risks.
    Fully enclosed outdoor dining structures may lack the mechanical ventilation and filtration standards applicable to indoor restaurant spaces. Without adequate air exchange, respiratory aerosols can accumulate, potentially making these structures even less safe than properly ventilated indoor dining rooms.
    This is particularly concerning because the proposed winterization period, November 30 through March 31, overlaps with the season when influenza, RSV, COVID-19, and other respiratory viruses circulate widely.
    Authorizing poorly ventilated, enclosed dining spaces during this period could contribute to preventable infections, hospitalizations, and additional strain on the healthcare system, disproportionately affecting people most vulnerable to respiratory illness and having a trickle down effect on the economic health of the city through increased absenteeism from workplaces and schools.
    Thus, the City should not authorize what are effectively indoor dining environments without ensuring appropriate ventilation protections. Outdoor dining should remain a genuinely open-air alternative, not a separate category of enclosed spaces with potentially weaker air quality safeguards.
    3. Vertical coverings also create barriers for wheelchair users, and I am concerned that the proposed rules do not adequately address how deployed vertical coverings affect physical accessibility.
    Even when retractable, these coverings can obstruct entrances, narrow circulation space, and make it difficult to maneuver between tables or access seating. Their supports and attachment mechanisms may also interfere with accessible sidewalk paths.
    The rules should explicitly require that coverings, when deployed, preserve accessible entrances, pedestrian clearances, and sufficient wheelchair maneuvering space within dining areas.
    4. Fully enclosed structures could jeopardize public support for outdoor dining.
    Large, substantially enclosed dining structures were among the features of the initial early pandemic outdoor dining program that generated public criticism. Allowing similar structures again risks reviving concerns about bulky enclosures, their appearance, and their impact on public space. Likewise, addressing accessibility proactively reduces costly ADA litigation risk for both the department and businesses in the program.
    I strongly support making outdoor dining permanent and would hate to see renewed opposition jeopardize a program that benefits restaurants, diners, people with disabilities, and their loved ones.
    Preserving its genuinely open-air character would help protect both accessibility and the program’s long-term viability and political will.
    The solution: Amend the proposed rules to require at least one fully open side during service.
    I urge DOT to amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), along with the corresponding provisions governing vertical protective coverings, to require minimum ventilation opening standards that can be achieved by requiring at least one entire side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe remain fully open to outside air whenever patrons are present.
    This requirement should apply year-round, including during winterization and adverse weather conditions.
    Proposed regulatory language:
    “When utiliing vertical protective coverings, at least one entire side of a sidewalk cafe or roadway cafe shall remain fully open to outside air whenever the cafe is occupied by patrons. Such opening shall extend across the full available width of that side, from above any required safety barrier or perimeter demarcation to the overhead covering, if present, and shall remain unobstructed by curtains, panels, or other materials that substantially restrict natural airflow.”
    I also request that DOT establish enforceable minimum ventilation-opening standards and explicitly prohibit coverings or associated structures from obstructing accessible pedestrian routes, entrances, exits, or wheelchair maneuvering space.
    Requiring at least one fully open side is a practical minimum standard that would preserve meaningful outdoor dining access for disabled and immunocompromised New Yorkers while still allowing restaurants to provide weather protection.
    I urge DOT to adopt this amendment and ensure that Dining Out NYC remains accessible, safe, and sustainable for all New Yorkers.
    Thank you for your consideration.
    Amelia Merrill, 10025

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:14pm
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining is a great way to enjoy a meal in NYC.
    However, fully enclosing outdoor dining areas in NYC restaurants seems to be counter to the idea of eating al fresco.
    For many who prefer eating outdoors for the benefits of fresh air both for health and general enjoyment, it’s a deal breaker. The air inside those enclosures doesn’t even have the benefit of an HVAC system circulating air. For the immunocompromised citizens, it’s even worse than eating indoors. They will just not eat there.
    At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.
    Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:17pm
  • Megan McNeill

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. A roof and 2 sides are ok. The spaces need to be as open air as possible to keep them accessible.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:18pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining and year-round outdoor dining, BUT I do not support fully enclosed outdoor dining. That defeats the purpose! Outdoor dining should have at least one side un-enclosed/open out of four total sides.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:18pm
  • Anonymous

    Hello.

    Re: Sections 5-11(a)(1)(i), 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C), 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), and related provisions governing vertical protective coverings:

    Please preserve genuinely open-air dining options. Specifically, there should be one (1) fully open side as a minimum standard. This would preserve meaningful outdoor dining access for disabled and immunocompromised New Yorkers while still allowing restaurants to provide weather protection.

    Some quick public health information: Covid is transmitted occurs via airborne transmission. (It is not transmitted via droplet transmission. Hand sanitizer is not going to help you.) Please research the difference between the two forms of transmission if it is not clear. And one (airborne) Covid infection could be a death sentence for a disabled or immunocompromised person.

    Accordingly, these winterized cafes should be required to maintain a meaningful and well defined opening for ventilation during service. Otherwise the city is authorizing a design that can effectively eliminate meaningful outdoor dining access for disabled & immunocompromised New Yorkers.

    There must also be a requirement that these installments are wheelchair accessible.

    Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:24pm
  • Jason Roth

    Outdoor dining enables the immunocompromised to enjoy going to restaurants with the same access as everyone else. Closing in outdoor spaces eliminates this access and creates an unsafe environment for us. Please keep outdoor dining truly open (in all senses of the word) and do not make it into enclosed spaces that lock out already-marginalized communities.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:24pm
  • Brian Griffin

    I’m in favor of more dining sheds because it gives homeless a nice warm place to sleep at night. Everyone should have a comfortable place next to the sidewalk to perform sexual favors in exchange for drugs. I think it will look very nice next to the migrants selling drugs and the new compost bins. Come to think of it, why do we need a sidewalk or public space at all? #equity #equitable

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:31pm
  • Anna Pakman

    In addition to my earlier comment, I would like to point out that there is no way that a fully enclosed vertical covering setup could possibly comply with the requirement to maintain sight lines as naturally the types of materials needed to winterize would fog up or be otherwise obstructed by rain and snow while in use there for rendering sight lines obstructed. The only way to ensure the visibility requirements are adhered to is to not allow vertical enclosures on all four sides

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:34pm
  • Kiki

    I’m sure everyone can think of at least one specific outdoor dining setup in NYC that comes to mind as romantic and beautiful. A place you walk by and think, wow, I would love to have dinner there sometime! A place you’d bring a good book to on a beautiful Saturday, to enjoy your coffee and breakfast in some sunshine. A place you’d bring your friends to when they visit the city, to show them how beautiful your city is. I can think of several such restaurant spaces and would love for there to be more. I strongly support creating a system for our city’s restaurants to implement more outdoor spaces.

    Of course, I understand that some of the outdoor sheds during the pandemic were home to rats or were left uncared for and became eyesores. But we don’t live in a binary world: we absolutely can create a city that has more beautiful, sanitary, and romantic outdoor dining without rats and trash. If you need more inspiration, look to the beautiful outdoor dining so common in Europe and other parts of the world!

    I also want to emphasis that open-air outdoor dining is essential in expanded access for our neighbors, friends and family who are immunocompromised and feel at risk in indoor settings with low ventilation (I absolutely believe improved ventilation should be prioritized for our indoor spaces schools, restaurants as well).
    I’m sure we all agree that adding elevators to all subway stations so that folks with mobility issues, strollers, or heavy bags have equal access to mass transit. In this vein, we should also increase access to restaurants to those with more invisible medical needs, like those who are immunocompromised. Creating more outdoor dining spaces that is not closed off with plastic walls or insulation (these defeat the purpose) will provide that increased access.

    Everyone will benefit and enjoy the romantic, beautiful outdoor spaces!

    Comment added November 6, 2026 1:46pm
  • Anonymous

    As a senior I am concerned about outdoor dining shed impeding sidewalks and street crossings. Several times in the past I have forced into the traffic by a shed. In addition, rats congregate around sheds that are not kept clean. I hope the city is being compensated for the additional space given to restaurants at the expense of the pedestrian.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 2:52pm
  • Therem

    I strongly support outdoor dining, but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 2:59pm
  • Anonymous

    I support Emma and Anna Pakman’s comments.

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 3:12pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures since they remove ventilation from the dining space. My spouse and I have medical vulnerabilities and outdoor dining has been a lifeline during the COVID period to reduce our risk by being in fresh air. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air so patrons can choose between the freshest-air section and the interior (perhaps warmer) section. This also allows people in wheelchairs to access the outdoor dining space more easily.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 3:17pm
  • Michal Richardson

    As a person with Long Covid who needs to protect my health, I use outdoor dining options in order to avoid illness while still participating in life in NYC. An outdoor dining structure enclosed on all four sides would not be effectively “outdoor dining” for my purposes, and would not be accessible to me. Incentivizing open-air, or even partially open options, would make outdoor dining more accessible to those of us who are frequently excluded from public life.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 3:30pm
  • Emily Fishman

    It is critically important that outdoor dining spaces remain open to the air and unenclosed. This is an important public health issue, and it is the only way to ensure the safety and proper accommodation of individuals disabled by COVID, immune disorders, and other similar conditions. Open air dining is an important safety measure that protects against the circulation of viruses, including COVID, a disease that remains especially dangerous and disabling for many of us. Without language in the proposed rules to keep the enclosures open, individuals such as myself, who are disabled by COVID, and who now need to avoid reinfection, are left completely without access to the same public accommodations that others in our community can enjoy. As a person disabled by long COVID, outdoor dining has become one of an exceedingly few activities that I can still take part in, as well as one of the few outlets available for socializing with family and friends. Please take this into account and consider the need to accommodate those for whom COVID remains an extremely dangerous and ever-present threat. Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 3:37pm
  • Alexandra

    I’d like to echo many of the comments that I’m seeing here. I strongly support outdoor dining, but the rules must be amended to require at least one side of every outdoor dining setup to remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 3:57pm
  • Cole P

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    As someone who is high risk for viral infections due to lung disease, and with a partner who is significantly immunocompromised, outdoor dining setups are our only options for dining and supporting NYC’s restaurants/dining establishments. Fully enclosed “outdoor” setups have the same barriers for people like us and do not allow us to partake. Please consider those of us with health conditions and protecting loved ones with health conditions and move towards accessible, actually outdoor (open air) dining regulations that allow us to dine out and support our local businesses.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 4:02pm
  • Celeste Tooth

    I have rare immunodeficiencies that make in unsafe to dine indoors (per my immunologist). Enclosing outdoor seating would make dining out impossible for me. This is an accessibility issue.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 4:13pm
  • Anonymous

    We are extremely glad to be able to eat out of doors, even in the winter. It is often quieter outdoors than indoors these days (except for sirens). And it reduces the chance of picking up an infection from other diners indoors.
    However, for the safety of restaurant employees and patrons, we suggest that the NYPD enforce speed and direction limits to all bicycles, and prohibit motorized vehicles in the bicycle lanes.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 4:15pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but fully enclosed outdoor dining spaces will heighten the risk of COVID transmission, making it inaccessible to disabled and immunocompromised New Yorkers who also deserve a fun night out.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 4:17pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 4:31pm
  • Lisa M.

    Outdoor dining sheds and patios been a blessing for those of us with high-risk loved ones. It allows many of us to enjoy a delicious meal out and support local restaurants.

    A fully enclosed shed is not safe for those of us who have immunocompromised family/friends. Please consider prioritizing air flow in outdoor dining.

    It also helps keep restaurant staff and fellow patrons safer by preventing the spread of viruses and other illness in the colder months. Thank you for your consideration.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 4:31pm
  • Ali

    I do not support the full enclosure of outdoor dining spaces.

    Outdoor dining setups should remain and it is essential that they are accessible to New Yorkers with disabilities and open to fresh air as a matter of public health.

    SARS-COV2 transmission continues to kill and disable New Yorkers while national transmission has surged for the third time this fall; influenza cases in NYC have quadrupled since September; RSV and TB rates are also rising; we just had yet another outbreak of Legionnaires over the summer. The city has no preventative policies in place, yet somehow it’s “mysterious” why everyone is sick, coughing, calling out of work or absent from school while we are told we have to learn to live with it.

    I am devastated watching the declining health of my friends, family and neighbors while NYC’s leaders and institutions minimize the spread of disease and abandon basic health mitigations.

    Outdoor dining is a lifeline for immunocompromised people in this city, often one of the only relatively safe options for staying in community, and enclosing these spaces will reduce our ability to participate in public life if not shut us out entirely – a contemporary Ugly Law, if you will.

    We are a city that blasted through bedrock to build modern sewer systems to keep our water safe, pioneered the concept of a municipal sanitation department, raised street levels and changed building codes to provide citizens with access to light and fresh air and prevent disease. It is stunning to me that the 1918 NYC BOH understood that open windows and airflow are an essential aspects of good ventilation – especially in cold weather – but the NYC DOT in 2026 does not!

    I see outdoor dining as essential to city life as curb cuts and I urge the DOT to recognize the public health benefits of open air dining structures. NYC must return to being at the forefront of proactive public health policy and the DOT must keep outdoor dining areas fully ventilated and open to the air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 4:40pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of outdoor dining setups should be open-air regardless of weather conditions, and it should be the longest side of the structure.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 5:05pm
  • Jonny

    Grateful for the change to year round outdoor dining, that will save restaurants the $$$ and headache of construction, de-construction and storage. Hopefully the benefits outweigh the costs of winterizing!
    The restaurants on west 8th Street, however, are restricted from participating in the program, still, due to the dated ‘no standing’ restrictions that plague the block. When the program started during Covid, we were granted allowance to participate, why not now? The difference between ‘no parking’ and ‘no standing’, we see, is for idling vehicles, which limit any overnight deliveries for the dozen or so restaurants that would otherwise eagerly take part in a program that their colleagues just even just one block away enjoy. Making the simple change to the signage from the archaic and unnecessary ‘no standing’ to ‘no parking’ would allow for this, without any result, other than more revenue for the city and healthier competition and variety for all the mom and pop owned small restaurants along this alley that have literally reinvigorated this neighborhood. Please consider this change.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 5:13pm
  • Ellen Markman

    While I am a strong proponent of the DiningOut program generally, I do not support the sacrifice of straight pedestrian clear paths for enclosed sidewalk cafes. We should be promoting roadway, not sidewalk, dining areas, and reallocating curb space currently used for private vehicle storage.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 5:22pm
  • Stevonnie Ross

    I am an NYC native who currently resides in Jersey City. I also have multiple health issues that put me at a higher risk for complications from COVID-19; as a result, I wear an KN95 or N95 mask in all public indoor spaces, and I only do social dining outdoors.

    As I have friends in New York with whom I would like to have social meals, I am an avid supporter of year-round outdoor dining. However, I am concerned about proposed rules that would allow restaurants to enclose such areas on all sides. This would effectively make them indoor spaces from the standpoint of airflow, and would negate their utility for me and other local people with disabilities.

    (This has already been an issue; I made plans to go for pho with a Manhattanite friend and only when we got there did we find that the sidewalk dining Yelp had promised had since been “upgraded” to an enclosure with full canvas walls that made it inaccessible to me.)

    So, please do what you can to make outdoor dining more readily available, but please also ensure that it is accessible to those with differing access needs, including room to maneuver wheelchairs and other mobility aids and including plenty of ventilation.

    Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 5:24pm
  • Anonymous

    Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this rule. I am disappointed by the extension of the authorization beyond the seasonal period, which I think was a good compromise. About this rule, I would like to see (a) a clearer mechanism to report violations and ensure enforcement including for illegal sound systems (b) enforcement of the 11 pm closing hours, which in my neighborhood are NEVER respected and NEVER enforced and a real nightmare for residents (c) a clarification that loud, amplified sound system inside that reverberates on the side walk should also be forbidden.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 6:18pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 6:22pm
  • Anonymous

    Dear NYC Department of Transportation,

    This is regarding Dining out NYC Rule Amendments 5-01, 5-02, 5-03, 5-07, 5-09, 5-10, 5-11, and 5-12 of Chapter 5 and section 3-01 of Chapter 3 of Title 34

    I am a Queens resident who for health reasons cannot catch Covid or other airborne viruses. I mitigate this by wearing a respirator mask both indoors and out, but things like indoor dining are siply not possible because of my health limitations. Open-air dining is a crucial way I can maintain both my health and my social relationships.

    I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to fully enclose outdoor dining areas undermines their accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, as well as creating the same public health risks as indoor dining and thus inadvertently discriminating against disabled New Yorkers – a violation of the ADA, as well as state and local civil rights laws.

    Please remove any potential barrier to service – and to safety – and require, at bare minimum, at least one fully-open side on any outdoor architecture. I urge DOT to amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D) and require this fully-open side on any outdoor dining architecture or structures, year-round, including winter and inclement weather. In 2020 and 2021 such structures were still a large draw, and so should not impact business; however, not having them impacts vulnerable communities a great deal.

    Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 6:32pm
  • Monica

    I am a New York City resident who cannot afford to catch COVID or other airborne viruses. Because of these risks, I wear a respirator style mask in public indoor spaces. Outdoor dining allows me to participate in New York City’s restaurant culture and maintain social relationships with friends and family without unnecessarily compromising my health. 

    I depend on year-round outdoor dining. However, I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to enclose outdoor dining areas on all sides would undermine accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, create public health risks, and potentially threaten the long-term success of the program.

    I would also like to emphasize that DOT has obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), as well as applicable provisions of the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL), to ensure that people with disabilities have meaningful access to public programs and services. Disabled people currently do not have true access to public space and yet these protections extend to people with a wide range of disabilities, including those whose medical conditions make them particularly vulnerable to respiratory infections. DOT should therefore consider whether its proposed regulations create unnecessary barriers to access for disabled New Yorkers. 

    I ask you to amend the proposed rules to require at least one fully open side during service.

    I urge DOT to amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), along with the corresponding provisions governing vertical protective coverings, to require minimum ventilation opening standards that can be achieved by requiring at least one entire side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe remain fully open to outside air whenever patrons are present.

    This requirement should apply year-round, including during winterization and adverse weather conditions.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 6:34pm
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining regulations should create *outdoor* dining spaces. Allowing full enclosure (even with “non-rigid” transparent sheeting) on all sides for half the year does not accomplish this. There are many reasons why New Yorkers would want to dine outside, the most important of which is being outside, which means good ventilation. Allowing these structures to become essentially indoors doesn’t do that. There should be at a minimum one of the longest sides fully open for both ventilation and accessibility, and large enough vents on the other sides to promote cross-ventilation. As others pointed out, this also helps reduce visual clutter. Allowing full enclosure on all sides in the winter would basically look like trailers being parked on the roadway all winter throughout the city.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 6:35pm
  • Anonymous

    The outdoor dining has hurt me badly. I live in the west Village where the restaurants and bars have taken over our narrow side walks and streets. There is no regard for safe pedestrian spaces or the noise coming from these establishments. And then there is all the garbage and rats. Our restaurants are very rich and very crowded with lines blocks long on our sidewalks. Why should I have to have a miserable life on what was once a quiet landmarked neighborhood that I invested every penny that I had 50 years ago. Don’t I have rights?

    Comment added November 6, 2026 8:49pm
  • anonymous

    i have multiple cancers and the ability to eat outside allows me to continue to be social, improving my mental wellness.
    enclosed dining shelters are barely better than regular indoors.
    please allow maintained more open dining spaces

    Comment added November 6, 2026 9:29pm
  • Anonymous

    Please do not enclose the outdoor seating!

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:23pm
  • Ethan Jeremy Sacks

    Please keep outdoor dining options open air in New York City to allow immunocompromised New Yorkers to have access to restaurants and bars in the city. In the COVID era, these open-air dining options have been proven to be successful and essential and there is absolutely no reason to go backwards now.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:36pm
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining isn’t actually outdoors if it’s fully enclosed. A lot of restaurants might just value the extra seating but the reason people need it is for there to be some airflow. I live in NJ, am in the city a lot and will only eat outdoors. This proposed rule affects commuters and other visitors negatively too. If there is nowhere for me to sit with friends at any restaurant in the city and I’m stuck on someone’s stoop with takeout why should I give them money? This rule also would serve to isolate people who have any kind of chronic illness, or who are just more health- conscious. There is the concept of Universal Design. That is what thr City should think about when issues like this arise. Plan for people of all abilities ahead of time so they can go about their lives without a need to ask for special accomodations, because they were automatically built in from the start.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 10:49pm
  • Anonymous

    Please retain true outdoor dining! People I know and love have conditions that make getting COVID highly dangerous, which enclosed “outdoor” dining will increase. If the proposal goes ahead they will no longer be able dine out , they will have to forgo this important social connection. Consider how to be inclusive.
    Thank you.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:17pm
  • Suzanne L.

    I support outdoor dining that is truly accessible. This means not fully enclosed – for those immunocompromised needing fresh air flow, for those with physical disabilities who need barrier-less spaces. Please listen to these voices as the guidelines are developed.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:41pm
  • Vanessa

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 6, 2026 11:51pm
  • Alexandra P

    Dear NYC Department of Transportation,

    This is regarding Dining out NYC Rule Amendments 5-01, 5-02, 5-03, 5-07, 5-09, 5-10, 5-11, and 5-12 of Chapter 5 and section 3-01 of Chapter 3 of Title 34

    Many NYC residents cannot afford to catch COVID or other airborne viruses. Outdoor dining allows them to participate in New York City’s restaurant culture and maintain social relationships with friends and family without unnecessarily compromising their health.

    I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to enclose outdoor dining areas on all sides would undermine accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, create public health risks, and potentially threaten the long-term success of the program.

    I would also like to emphasize that DOT has obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), as well as applicable provisions of the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL), to ensure that people with disabilities have meaningful access to public programs and services. Disabled people currently do not have true access to public space and yet these protections extend to people with a wide range of disabilities, including those whose medical conditions make them particularly vulnerable to respiratory infections. DOT should therefore consider whether its proposed regulations create unnecessary barriers to access for disabled New Yorkers.

    I ask you to amend the proposed rules to require at least one fully open side during service.

    I urge DOT to amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), along with the corresponding provisions governing vertical protective coverings, to require minimum ventilation opening standards that can be achieved by requiring at least one entire side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe remain fully open to outside air whenever patrons are present.

    This requirement should apply year-round, including during winterization and adverse weather conditions.

    Sincerely,

    Alexandra P
    Forest Hills, NY

    Comment added November 7, 2026 12:36am
  • Christine Bruno

    Dear Commissioner Flynn,

    I strongly urge the NYC DOT to require at least one side of every outdoor dining structure remain open to the air at ALL times

    Fully enclosing outdoor dining structures defeats the purpose of outdoor dining and creates significant barriers for people with disabilities. As a wheelchair user who would be directly and negatively affected by this policy, it must be said that the policy as currently drafted is both discriminatory AND shortsighted. While it comes as no surprise to us that disabled people were not considered when outdoor dining was instituted during the pandemic in an attempt to save businesses from shuttering, it may come as a surprise to the Council that during that time, thousands of disabled New Yorkers FINALLY had access to hundreds of restaurants that were previously inaccessible to disabled people since the founding of the city itself, long before COVID shut out the nondisabled population and even larger numbers of disabled people whose conditions make proper ventilation crucial. It may also come as a surprise that nationally, disabled people have an estimated $1 trillion in discretionary spending. Does it not then stand to reason that returning to an exclusionary and discriminatory practice would be detrimental to the Mayor’s goal of building a more equitable city, as well as to the cultural and financial health of the city?

    Outdoor dining should be an inclusive option that makes restaurants more accessible to everyone, not a space that inadvertently excludes people who have far fewer options to begin with. Requiring at least one side of the structure to remain open would preserve ventilation and access, a necessity for many.

    Restaurants can still protect patrons from cold weather with heaters, awnings, and other weather protections without fully enclosing these spaces. As someone who travels frequently, many cities around the world have found ways to make their outdoor dining spaces accessible without restrictions, including for colder temperatures and inclement weather.

    We urge you to prioritize accessibility, public health, and inclusion in the final regulations. New Yorkers with disabilities and compromised immune systems have an equal right as tax payers to enjoy our city’s restaurants and public spaces. If the Mayor and Council are serious about creating equity for ALL New Yorkers, as well as making our city more welcoming to disabled visitors, our policies MUST fully reflect that commitment without restrictions.

    Thank you.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 1:57am
  • anonymous

    outdoor dining has made the tenants who live in the buildings around and above the restaurants very uncomfortable because of noise and loud.music. the pedestrians who have to navigate the few inches of sidewalk make it dangerous and uncomfortable.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 5:43am
  • J. Pucci

    Awful looking dining structures remain on our streets. That cannot be allowed. The rules must be enforced and the penalty severe enough to discourage rule breaking. This is a tall order. Some business owners it seems have become accustomed to the lax enforcement of dining shed rules and confident in their ability to break those rules with impunity. Absent rigorous oversight, Covid-era shacks will return.

    Also, fully enclosing these outdoor sheds in winter should not be allowed. The sheds are meant to provide modest outdoor dining, not to function as tax-free room additions to restaurants. Casual and modest outdoor dining sheds, yes. Restaurant building expansions, no. Complicating the purpose of the sheds invites unnecessary additional problems. If the sheds cannot be warmed sufficiently for everyone to feel comfortable using them year-round, then so be it. That is not their purpose.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 7:06am
  • R. Kellman

    Outdoor dining that is not entirely enclosed is what enables me and others who are protective of loved ones at risk of serious air-borne illness to patronize NYC restaurants. If these spaces are closed in, fresh air cannot circulate and I and other COVID cautious residents wind up isolated, denied the ability to break bread together and socialize. Please ensure that the new regulations provide for at least one and preferably two sides to be open.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 7:40am
  • Jia Huang

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosure. One side should remain open for proper ventilation.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 8:16am
  • Cheryl Vasios

    I have been a resident of the west village since 1973 and I oppose outdoor dining for Greenwich Village. The streets are too narrow to have outdoor structures and the consequent garbage blocking access to the sidewalks. In addition, the current sheds are unsightly and make the neighborhood look like a shanty town.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 8:23am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 8:54am
  • Erika r

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. I am immune compromised and support establishments who have this type of outdoor dining so I am less likely to catch airborne illnesses that can further disable me.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 8:55am
  • Lyndsey J. M.

    I love outdoor dining, and returning to outdoor dining after covid closures is one of my greatest memories of the city of New York. However, I don’t like the idea of NYC becoming full of sidewalk “cabooses” where all four sides are enclosed — THESE are the eyesores and navigation nightmares I worry about. Sidewalk dining and partial enclosures can provide additional seating for people who use mobility devices, are susceptible to infectious disease, have a dog or a bike with them, et cetera et cetera. Four-sided enclosures that are essentially just enclosed sheds don’t have these advantages. The city making it harder for people to just throw out some tables and chairs is one of the biggest downgrades I’ve felt in New York City in recent years and I’d love to see us trend back towards “Parisian sidewalk” and not “there is a fully enclosed trailer with no HVAC on this sidewalk for some reason.”

    Comment added November 7, 2026 9:11am
  • S. Caragliano

    Dear NYC Department of Transportation,
    This is regarding Dining out NYC Rule Amendments 5-01, 5-02, 5-03, 5-07, 5-09, 5-10, 5-11, and 5-12 of Chapter 5 and section 3-01 of Chapter 3 of Title 34.

    I am a New York City resident who cannot afford to catch COVID or other airborne viruses. Because of these risks, I wear a respirator style mask in public indoor spaces. Outdoor dining allows me to participate in New York City’s restaurant culture and maintain social relationships with friends and family without unnecessarily compromising my health.

    Me and many of my disabled community members depend on year-round outdoor dining. I am concerned that the proposed rules allowing restaurants to enclose outdoor dining areas on all sides would undermine accessibility for disabled and medically vulnerable New Yorkers, create public health risks, and potentially threaten the long-term success of the program.
    I would also like to emphasize that DOT has obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), as well as applicable provisions of the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL), to ensure that people with disabilities have meaningful access to public programs and services. Disabled people currently do not have true access to public space and yet these protections extend to people with a wide range of disabilities, including those whose medical conditions make them particularly vulnerable to respiratory infections. DOT should therefore consider whether its proposed regulations create unnecessary barriers to access for disabled New Yorkers.

    I ask you to amend the proposed rules to require at least one fully open side during service.

    I urge DOT to amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), along with the corresponding provisions governing vertical protective coverings, to require minimum ventilation opening standards that can be achieved by requiring at least one entire side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe remain fully open to outside air whenever patrons are present. This requirement should apply year-round, including during winterization and adverse weather conditions.

    Sincerely,
    S. Caragliano

    Comment added November 7, 2026 9:50am
  • Mia Minen

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. This enables ventilation and protects more vulnerable New Yorkers.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 10:06am
  • Sheila Bailey

    Outdoor dining adds a layer of access for people who are trying to avoid respiratory infections and illnesses. Following the surge in COVID and flunl, I no longer dine indoors, and wear an N95 at all times indoors. Having the option to eat outdoors in truly “outdoor” spaces has allowed me to continue to eat at restaurants, and I specifically patronize only restaurants with an outdoor option or takeout.
    By allowing restaurants to “enclose” outdoor seating, the air quality worsens, dining is no longer meaningfully outdoors and the access provided by year round outdoor dining is negated.
    Please continue to encourage restaurants to have year round outdoor dining, but without fully enclosing the dining area.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 11:09am
  • Beth Oram

    Outside dining is especially critical during winter virus season for the many chronically ill, disabled, elderly and immunocompromised New Yorkers who would otherwise be isolated indoors. It also allows extra seating under heat lamps when restaurants are uncomfortably full or loud. It is good for restaurants and good for a large number of New Yorkers – a win-win!

    Comment added November 7, 2026 11:45am
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining must remain unenclosed in order to protect the disabled people of New York! Having open airflow reduces spread of illness like COVID and other illness that can permanently disable, or further disable New Yorkers. Please keep dining accessible to more New Yorkers by keeping outdoor dining unenclosed!

    Comment added November 7, 2026 1:11pm
  • Meredith Slota

    I deeply value outdoor dining — primarily for health reasons (fresh air and reduced COVID exposure risk compared to enclosed indoor spaces) and am thrilled to see consideration around this program (and the expansion to year round). As someone who has friends and family who are medically vulnerable and is covid-aware, I do not dine indoors at all, and having access to outdoor seating is a real quality-of-life improvement for me.

    I want to urge you to reconsider the rules around vertical coverings to ensure that “outdoor dining” does not just become “indoor dining but on the sidewalk” due to vertical enclosures like walls and windows, and that outdoor dining retains the health benefits we rely on. Please ensure that fresh air is FULLY accessible in all outdoor dining options — especially since COVID tends to surge in late winter and late summer every year, enclosing spaces even further during those times increases our exposure risk.

    Specifically: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8051020/ (outdoor spaces vs. indoor spaces for COVID risk) and https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15459624.2022.2053692 (evaluation of different kinds of “outdoor” spaces).

    True open-air dining (e.g. as close as we can get to under an open sky with no barriers) utilizes natural wind to dilute viral loads almost instantly. However, as the medical research demonstrates, if an “outdoor” dining option relies too much on plastic side flaps, zippered tents, or individual bubbles (the worst kinds) without continuous mechanical or cross-ventilation, it ceases to function as an outdoor space and mimics — or worsens — the relative risk of indoor dining.

    Help us keep NYC safe by keeping outdoor dining truly outdoor. Thank you!

    Comment added November 7, 2026 1:19pm
  • Anonymous

    Please amend the requirements for outdoor dining to disallow fully enclosed “outdoor” dining features. Full enclosure defeats the purpose of outdoor dining and makes it inaccessible for immunocompromised people who are trying to avoid getting sick/sicker.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 1:30pm
  • Eliza Ducnuigeen

    Please DO NOT require outdoor dining to be fully-enclosed! Outdoor dining with proper air circulation is an access need for disabled and chronically ill folks to be able to participate in the vibrant life of our city. Enclosed outdoor dining defeats that vital purpose!

    Comment added November 7, 2026 1:58pm
  • Ericka Andrea Alicea

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 2:57pm
  • Tracey Keij-Denton

    Dear Commissioner Flynn & the Outdoor Dining Team,

    I am an attorney at the boutique firm of Weinberg Zareh Malkin Price LLP, where we represent many small businesses in the hospitality community, including restaurants in NYC. I am writing here as an individual. I appreciate and agree with the comments here from immunocompromised people in support of outdoor dining. Additionally, I want to highlight that faster approval of outdoor dining = sidewalk and roadway cafes – is critical for job growth and wages. Many restaurants are crowded with customers, and waiting months and months for a sidewalk cafe that has no objection from the community board and the city council. Business are seeking more place to seat their customers, which in turn allows them to hire more workers, or give more hours to the workers they already employee. Restaurant workers are seeking more jobs and more working hours. Allowing sidewalk cafes and roadway cafes to have a quicker approval process will directly increase the wages of NYC workers, provide more options for dining customers, more revenue for small businesses, and increase city revenue. All this can be done while still incorporating the concerns of local communities.

    Thank you,
    Tracey Keij-Denton

    ~~~
    Tracey Keij-Denton
    Weinberg Zareh Malkin Price LLP
    45 Rockefeller Plaza, 20th Floor
    New York, NY  10111-3193
    [email protected]
      She/Her
    646-251-0680 (mobile)
    212-332-3209 (office)
    http://www.wzmplaw.com

    Comment added November 7, 2026 4:19pm
  • Anonymous

    I fully support outdoor dining year round but only if enclosures remain open to fresh air from at least one side, preferably more. If I wanted to eat indoors I would eat indoors – I want to dine outdoors for fresh air.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 5:16pm
  • Anonymous

    I am all in favor of making outdoor dining possible easier and available year round, but as an immunocompromised person who is choosing to eat outside for health reasons and safety, having outdoor seating be fully enclosed will take that access away making it unsafe to disabled and immunocompromised people who want to enjoy the amazing dining experience in NY without getting sick from other patrons.
    Thank you for your attention to this matter.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 5:25pm
  • Emily S.

    I am very concerned about the provision to allow fully enclosed “outdoor” dining. I am at high risk for severe complications from COVID; I wear a respirator at all times in public indoor spaces, and am unable to eat at indoor restaurants. Outdoor dining allows me to go to restaurants and safely have a social life because of the ventilation. I know many people who have the same need as I do. In addition, fully enclosed outdoor sheds are inaccessible to wheelchair users. Please require the dining sheds to have at least one long side (parallel to the sidewalk) be open so that disabled and chronically ill New Yorkers can eat outdoors safely. Thank you.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 5:37pm
  • Michael Graetzer

    I oppose allowing additional restaurants on public space that interfere with pedestrian traffic, and especially oppose making any of them enclose structures. That’s like getting a larger building without the appropriate rent increase, and the problem in Hell’s Kitchen is that there are so may pedestrians already, that interfering with their traffic will make it worse for everyone, not better. Please do not approve this.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 5:50pm
  • Adina Gerver

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. I enjoyed many a hot drink on a cold day at a sidewalk cafe or roadway restaurant in prior winters!

    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.

    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again.

    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.

    Thank you!

    Comment added November 7, 2026 6:12pm
  • Anonymous

    Hi,

    I’m writing to state that I support the expansion of outdoor dining. However, shelters should not be fully enclosed and have at least one side remain open air. Thanks for keeping eateries inclusive and accessible!

    Comment added November 7, 2026 7:28pm
  • Allison

    Open air dining allows me to see my friends during intense Covid and flu seasons! Please keep open air dining in NYC. If I wanted to dine inside, I would.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 7:53pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Please consider the disabled and immunocomprised communities in these decisions, especially as we have already been shut out of so many spaces.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 10:17pm
  • Marisa Harford

    In order to ensure proper ventilation, please require outdoor dining structures to have at least one open side or significant windows that can be opened to provide air circulation.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 10:18pm
  • Margaret McCarthy

    I agree with Lindsey Cormack –“ Our sidewalks are public spaces that serve everyone. Their primary purpose must remain the safe and accessible movement of pedestrians….
    Intersections are where pedestrians are most vulnerable, and roadway dining structures can interfere with sightlines between drivers and people entering crosswalks.”
    Not to mention cyclists, e-bikes, motor bikes, & micro-vehicles coming at all speeds from every direction around these corner structures.
    As Anna Pakman points out “there is no way that a fully enclosed vertical covering setup could possibly comply with the requirement to maintain sight lines as naturally the types of materials needed to winterize would fog up or be otherwise obstructed by rain and snow while in use there for rendering sight lines obstructed. The only way to ensure the visibility requirements are adhered to is to not allow vertical enclosures on all four sides”
    As Andrew Goldman points out “ After last Winter’s big snowstorm, the City created several giant snow mounds/glaciers…. If the same shed is part of year-round outdoor dining and we have a similar storm, I will need to cross the street in the middle of the block while trying to look around the street shed to make sure no traffic is coming. THIS IS VERY DANAGEROUS”
    Like Lindsey, “my central concern is that we should not continue expanding the use of public sidewalks and roadways for private commercial purposes without equally strengthening the protections that allow the public to use those spaces safely… I hope DOT will place particular emphasis on the experiences of pedestrians, older adults, people with disabilities, parents with strollers, and others who rely on unobstructed public sidewalks every day.”
    And yes, even if rules are enforced, the violation fees seem paltry—encouraging restaurants to treat fines as a cost of doing business. “A restaurant should not be able to treat a fine as an acceptable cost of occupying public space.”
    On 8th Avenue in Chelsea, an establishment can fill a single shed with one large party; some sheds have TV screens; in some places, diners & drinkers sit with their seat-backs on the line of the bike lane, sharing the bike lane with cyclists and e-bikes. The servers cross the bike lane to serve them, dodging all the bike lane traffic. It gives the city a feeling of cartoon-like insanity.
    Restaurateurs, I truly love, use and support my local Chelsea restaurants and businesses – but Commercial Rent Stabilization would have helped you during the pandemic a lot more than having to put up cheap plastic sheds at your own expense. The same holds true now.

    Comment added November 7, 2026 10:18pm
  • Vicki Nev

    I am requesting outdoor dining that is not enclosed. Outdoor dining protects immunocompromised individuals from getting COVID and RSV and other illnesses. if the structure is enclosed, it is just like Indoor dining. Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:06am
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining is an important accommodation for immunocompromised and disabled New Yorkers to be able to eat out in their communities rather than holed up in their apartments with take out. However, it must actually be OUTDOOR, meaning with ventilation from open air, to provide this accessibility and safety. Please consider requiring at least one side of structures to be completely open, but ideally, require whole areas to be fully outdoors and push for this to be the norm. It is possible to have outdoor dining safety in all seasons with proper heating, just as other countries do.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:30am
  • Jennifer

    PLEASE reconsider requiring that all outdoor dining be enclosed. It defeats the purpose of outdoor dining and excludes so many disabled/immunocompromised citizens who have relied on outdoor dining as a means of connecting with other people that don’t share the same precautions. One of the great things about NYC is its commitment to outdoor dining spaces—other cities do not offer nearly as many options

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:14am
  • Ken Coughlin

    Since the onset of Covid, I and thousands of other New Yorkers have used outdoor dining because of the ventilation it affords. The proposed rules would allow restaurants to fully enclose their roadway structures during winter months and inclement weather, making outdoor dining no different from its indoor counterpart. Requiring at least one of the structure’s sides to be fully open to the outdoors would be a fair compromise, allowing restaurants to heat the space while still providing ventilation.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:10am
  • Lucas Amodio

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. For my and my family’s safety we prefer to eat at outdoor dining setups where at least one side remains open to the air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:48am
  • Emma Eager

    I support outdoor dining. However, full-enclosure outdoor setups greatly reduce the airflow necessary to make outdoor dining accessible. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:59am
  • Alissa Stollwerk

    I am a Nassau County resident who regularly is in the city for both work and entertainment. I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. I’ve regularly eaten outdoors during the colder months for everything from business dinners to hot cocoa with the kids after a show.

    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live, work, and play. Some enclosures and heat systems make sense, but these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.

    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again.

    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.

    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:05am
  • Robin Messing

    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.
    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to be exposed to debilitating respiratory infections and possibly also become carriers that could infect the most vulnerable.
    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.
    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:06am
  • Evan Sachs

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. I enjoyed many a hot drink on a cold day at a sidewalk cafe or roadway restaurant in prior winters!
    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.
    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again.
    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.
    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:06am
  • Evan Sachs

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. I have enjoyed brunches, dinners, and birthday meals at all times of year via outdoor dining.
    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.
    Multiple sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again.
    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.
    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:08am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:24am
  • Meagan Lizarazo

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures, which defeat the purpose. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:32am
  • Katherine Terrell

    Please don’t enclose outdoor dining spaces! Open air outdoor dining is the only way the many immunocompromised and Covid-conscious among us are able to enjoy restaurants while protecting our health! We rely on open air dining; please don’t take it away!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:39am
  • Amanda

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:39am
  • Martha Licjtblau

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:56am
  • Michelle Masini

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. As a restaurant goer and immunocompromised person, not having outdoor ventilated options makes me and my family not be able to eat at restaurants.

    Photo of delicious outdoor sushi for the algorithm, please comment here once you’ve done it to help boost the post.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:11pm
  • Avi S

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:22pm
  • Julie

    Having outdoor dining options (not fully enclosed) is crucial to keeping restaurants accessible to those who need (or prefer!) to protect their health from airborne transmissions.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:28pm
  • Liza Wolsky

    For reasons of HEALTH, as well as aesthetics and enjoyment, Outdoor dining should NOT be fully enclosed. The reason for outdoor dining in the first place, was to allow open passage of air among the diners. For those of us who are immune compromised, or otherwise disabled, this is extremely important. It allows us to remain social, during period of time when otherwise we would be excluded from social areas.
    It is also delightful to eat outdoors. In Europe it is very common everywhere.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:31pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:44pm
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining with fresh air is critical to immunocompromised individuals.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:55pm
  • Amanda

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. Clean air is healthy air. Healthy residents and tourists decreases the strain on the medical system. Increased patronage supports the restaurant industry. It’s a win-win all around.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 12:57pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:00pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors, including those, like myself, who are Covid cautious due to health reasons.

    Thank you.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:01pm
  • Karen Van Hook

    I sincerely hope that outdoor dining spaces will not become fully enclosed. When we visit NYC (we live just 3 hours’ drive away), we want to be able to eat outdoors. There are still people out here who are conscious of the dangers of Covid, RSV and flu, and who enjoy restaurant meals in the open air. Fully enclosing outdoor spaces takes away options.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:05pm
  • C. Doyle

    Please do not authorize fully enclosed outdoor dining structures. Full enclosures are problematic from both public health and accessibility standpoints. Full enclosures will have no ventilation whatsoever, making them unusafe for all staff and patrons, and unusable for those patrons whose health precautions don’t allow them to dine in shared indoor spaces. These enclosures would also very likely not provide adequate accessibility for individuals using wheelchairs or other assistive devices, given the limited footprint. If the city’s public health apparatus refuses to make any steps toward cleaning indoor air for all NYers safety, the least they can do is ensure outdoor dining spaces to be ventilated so they remain accessible for all. Keeping the front open, by just allowing an awning and side walls, allows for some protection from the elements while still allowing airflow. Diners who prefer a fully enclosed experience have the actual restaurant to dine in. For those who cannot risk indoor dining., we are left with no option at all. Thank you for your consideration.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:09pm
  • Anonymous

    Please refrain from enclosing outdoor dining. The beauty of outdoor dining is being outside.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:15pm
  • Anonymous

    I fully support outdoor dining in the city but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to be considered outdoor dining.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:16pm
  • Dan Young

    As a resident of Brooklyn and NYC, I ask that you amend the rules for outdoor dining structures to require that one side always be fully open to the outdoors, rather than them being able to be fully enclosed structures. This will allow for both heating and ventilation and reduce the spread of contagious respiratory diseases like influenza, RSV, COVID, measles, the common cold, etc. in the general public. It will also make year round outdoor dining safer and more accessible to immunocompromised and other disabled people. Thank you for considering this amendment.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:17pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. Immunocompromised and otherwise vulnerable New Yorkers require spaces with some fresh air to protect their health. Full enclosures are no better –and sometimes worse — than indoors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:19pm
  • Sarah Evans

    Please amend the requirements for outdoor dining so restaurants may not fully enclose their sidewalk dining spaces. As an immunocompromised individual, outdoor dining is the safest option for me since it reduces the possibility of catching COVID or other potentially devastating illnesses. A fully enclosed space makes transmission of disease much more likely and removes or greatly reduces the ability for me and others like me to enjoy eating out.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:21pm
  • Elizabeth Turner

    As a resident and native of NYC, I write to express my general support for outdoor dining but to ask that you amend the rules for outdoor dining structures to require that one side always be fully open to the outdoors, rather than them being able to be fully enclosed structures. This will allow for both heating and ventilation and reduce the spread of contagious respiratory diseases like influenza, RSV, COVID, measles, the common cold, etc. in the general public. It will also make year round outdoor dining safer and more accessible to immunocompromised and other disabled people. Thank you for considering this amendment.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:21pm
  • Tanya E

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. I enjoyed many a hot drink or meal on a cold day at a sidewalk cafe or roadway restaurant in prior winters!

    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.

    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again. Some of us are health care, child care, or transit workers trying not to get sick or get others in our community sick. Some of us are immunocompromised or neurodivergent not wanting less stimulation in a public dining setting. Some of us just like the outdoors!

    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.

    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:25pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining, but I do not support full enclosures for outdoor dining. At least one to two sides of the outdoor dining structure should be open to allow for fresh air circulation, and to increase accessibility for NYC diners.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:26pm
  • S.A.Sorese

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. There are many people who’s lives depend on assessing risks of illness while still trying to be a part of a normal life. There is added benefit for restaurants and patrons to have some outdoor seating with any added features that would make it accessible year-round (i.e. canopy, outdoor heaters, umbrellas in the summer). New York is a great city & keeping it inclusive to all is its motto.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:33pm
  • Alex P.

    I love the ability to dine out but do not love how easy it is to get sick while doing so indoors. True outdoor dining is important for me to feel comfortable continuing to dine at a restaurant. As a former cafe employee for the past 8 years, I’ve been hyper aware to how frequently people with contagious airborne illnesses dine into restaurants. It’s why I personally chose to wear a respirator at work since the tool became widely available, and it’s why when I was dining indoors, it was usually at an off hour. Now that I’m much more educated about air quality, I only choose to dine outdoors these days. I know that the virons from ill patients tend to linger in the air, especially if the airflow isn’t up to par. Restaurants could at least work to improve their individual air quality with purifiers, but this is something that requires systemic change and resources.

    Now, to each their own to taking this risk. People are going to dine out regardless. And they should! But there should be safer options, especially for those who care and are aware of the risks. I speak also for the people who are more vulnerable, or are in direct contact with those who are more vulnerable. They deserve a safer place to eat too. And I speak as someone who just loves to eat outdoors when the weather permits. Allowing for these enclosures means eliminating a safer space to eat too It isolates a customer base. There has to be a better way to allow for true outdoor dining in any weather.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:38pm
  • Maria Swartz

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:45pm
  • Emily

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. I enjoyed many a hot drink on a cold day at a sidewalk cafe or roadway restaurant in prior winters!
    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.
    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again.
    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.
    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:49pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:49pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:50pm
  • Jason

    Please amend outdoor dining rules so that restaurants won’t be allowed to fully enclose their outdoor area. Fresh air is good for everyone’s health, especially for immune compromised individuals who can’t share fresh air with sick individuals – fresh air movement gives immune compromised New Yorkers, visitors, tourists, and commuters a chance to partake in the many great restaurants in our city. Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 1:54pm
  • M Forsythe

    Hello! As a NYC resident with a disability I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. This will also ensure wheel chair accessibility which many full enclosures do not have.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:02pm
  • Hannah

    As someone who lost four years of work to COVID, avoiding the indoors is paramount to protect my ability to work and socialise. If fully enclosed structures are present, this will mean I lose out on a vital source of socialising and getting out of the house. It may not seem like much but this is really the only thing I’m able to do to see friends.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:03pm
  • David Ruder

    Hello. I am a huge fan of outdoor dining’s proliferation in NYC. Having lived here for 21 years, it has definitely improved my quality of life. This has been especially true the past few years – as an immunocompromised person with Long Covid, I have not dined indoors in 6.5 years. I think it’s very important for the regulations to keep people like me in mind and make sure outdoor dining structures are never fully enclosed, but remain open on the sides etc.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:04pm
  • Anonymous

    I’ve visited New York as a tourist but I wouldn’t be able to do this without outdoor dining as I am covid cautious. Please maintain outdoor dining with covered areas open at the sides for ventilation.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:06pm
  • Helen B

    I am a Brooklyn resident. I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:12pm
  • Shannon

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:17pm
  • Alex

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every dining setup should remain open air to remain accessible for all residents and visitors. For many, ventilated outdoor dining is the only way they can dine at a restaurant and they deserve equal access to public life. They will also avoid tourism to cities where they do not have that access.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:17pm
  • Alison Lemer

    As a New Yorker who wants to eat out af local restaurants while also being able to avoid airborne viruses during waves of COVID, flu etc, I support outdoor dining but not mandated full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open-air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:20pm
  • Kathleen Burkhardt

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    As someone who has been following the science on airborne transmission and on immunosuppressants, outdoor dining is the only way for me to safely eat outside of my own home or private room. I cannot remove my respirator indoors, and a fully enclosed “outdoor” enclosure is just as dangerous as indoor dining. This proposal will endanger all New Yorkers whether they know they’re vulnerable or not, as long covid has been known to happen even with one infection in a healthy person.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:25pm
  • Rachel

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. Open air dining helps increase air flow and is a safer option for those with compromised immune systems. Please keep this option available.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:30pm
  • Martha Garvey

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. While I live in New Jersey, my artistic life is in New York City, and part of that life is being able to share a drink or a meal with friends and colleagues.

    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for many of us.

    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again. Keeping outdoor dining safe is the smart thing to do–and is good for business.

    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues. Making the glories of NYC available to EVERYONE is what New York City is all about.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:38pm
  • Anonymous

    Please let outdoor dining remain unenclosed year round. It is important to our family to have options for dining with fresh air. Otherwise, due to health issues, we wouldn’t be visit those restaurants at all. This has been one of my favorite parts of NYC. Please don’t take it away.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:38pm
  • Annie

    Outdoor dining is crucial for accessibility, and fully enclosing outdoor dining would make it far less likely that I (and many others like me) ever come back and visit New York City. Maintaining open-air dining also improves health and safety not just for diners, but for staff, and by extension all of NYC. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open-air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 2:51pm
  • Miriam C.

    Please preserve the open air dining experience. I am immunocompromised and rely on the ventilation of being outdoors. The ventilation of at least a semi open structure is especially important in the COVID and influenza season when people are more frequently sick with contagious illnesses.

    Fully enclosed sheds or tents are problematic from this perspective as they will shut me (and others in my situation) from using the outdoor dining.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 3:03pm
  • Lou

    This sounds like a great way to lose more customers at a time when restaurants are already hurting. If we can’t dine out in the fresh air, we just won’t go. Our health matters more than a plate of lasagna.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 3:03pm
  • Ann Sherman

    The preceding introductory paragraphs for DOT is maddeningly unspecific. Outdoor dining came to be during Covid. Why then does it need to be normalized? Why are these “vibrant public spaces” in support of the restaurant industry? Will they pay anything extra for the privilege of operating in that public roadway or sidewalk space? While they rake in hundreds of thousands of dollars. How will the extra trash be managed. As it is now DOS can’t keep the trash cans from overflowing and ignore the business trash that is supposed the be in bins THAT CLOSE but is then piled ontop. Let’s be clear. DOT wants outdoor dining because it eliminates parking spaces. Personally I think that parking your private car on the street is also wrong and unfair use of public domain. I say put benches and planting as a “vibrant public space”. Plant more trees! NYC IS NOT ONE SIZE FITS ALL. And who does decide the parameters and the rules? Not community boards. Their oversite is a joke. Blah blah blah with no power. And it’s stacked with a one sided mind set that wants to eliminate cars. The west village has its beautiful side street curbs taken up by City Bike docks that prevent the street from being cleaned and make DOS do gymnastics to collect garbage. The bikes are unregulated and millions of dollars goes into protected bike lanes that are underused down here . Please don’t say if you build it they will come. They won’t. Pedal bikes have been pushed out. The e-bike industry and delivery apps want the WHOLE PIE. They are making the money and our city is suffering because of it. There s absolutely NO REASON for deliveries to come from miles away. DOT employs phrases like “vibrant public spaces spaces” and I laugh. Look at Broadway above Union Sq. With a bunch of ugly metal tables scattered around and barely anyone sitting at them. A 2 way bike lane that is a safety hazard. No planting. NOTHING. And now none of us will have any say. Any more. Father Knows Best.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 3:11pm
  • Anonymous

    I second all the comments about keeping outdoor dining at least partially outdoors for proper ventilation, especially Anna’s comment on October 22, 2026 10:33pm. It is a matter of accessibility and equity. Why have outdoor dining, which is a wonderful option for many, if it isn’t actually outdoors? I’ve also been able to bring my infant in a stroller for outdoor dining, meaning I could patronize the restaurant, as inside does not have space next to my seat without being in the way so going out would be otherwise impossible.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 3:41pm
  • Jay

    Please don’t make it possible to enclose dining sheds. Post pandemic we still don’t understand how important changing the air over in a space is. There’s been so much research done about how many airborne infections can be prevented by just changing the air over in a space and the idea that we would willingly create a space where the air cannot change over is insane.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 3:55pm
  • Amanda Y

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. This really helps increase fresh air and reduce the spread of flu, covid, and other viruses. Many NYC residents and visitors still care about taking precautions, so please ensure we can continue to come and spend our money in your wonderful city!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 3:56pm
  • Ashley

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 4:00pm
  • Anonymous

    Please don’t fully enclose outdoor dining. The fresh air is the point. Thanks.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 4:02pm
  • anonymous

    I’m requesting that the outdoor dining rules be amended so that restaurants won’t be allowed to fully enclose their outdoor area. One side open would work well so there’s some ventilation but not all warmth is lost. The majority of people who eat outdoor off-season do so because we’re trying to avoid airborne illnesses (covid) so enclosing it fully defeats the purpose.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 4:03pm
  • Jeremy S.

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 4:44pm
  • Cory B.

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 4:45pm
  • Anna U.

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. As someone who loves to travel to NYC, not having spaces to dine outdoors would mean I would be much less likely to travel there as there would be safe places for my family with medical needs to eat.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:05pm
  • Melissa

    I support outdoor dining but not enclosed. That’s essentially indoor dining — it’s important to have good quality air flow available for those who are immunocompromised or avoiding catching a virus.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:19pm
  • Anonymous

    I second the comments of Lindsey Cormack and Andrew Goldstein. Each presents several important points about the practical day-to-day issues those of us living near outdoor dining establishments are compelled to live with. Businesses submitted plans with drawings and forms saying that they would operate in compliance with the regulations but then did as they pleased. I see widespread non-compliance all across the city seemingly due to lack of enforcement coupled with fines so low they are just considered the “cost of doing business.” What will the city council do to improve enforcement?

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:30pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    This setup will allow immunocompromised and disabled people the ability to dine outdoors safely year round, as it will allow for adequate air flow that helps folks avoid respiratory viruses.

    Disabled folks deserve to be accommodated!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:33pm
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining should be expanded. Businesses should have the option to provide both open and enclosed spaces to accommodate patrons of varying needs and preferences

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:39pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. I am immunocompromised and immunosuppressed on medication. This is the only way that I can dine in safely in the city. It’s such a small thing that supports restaurants and their financial well-being, the health of New Yorkers, and just general joy of getting to experience a true open air situation outdoor dining. Thank you for your consideration.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:39pm
  • anonymous

    It’s cold outside, there is no reason to have outdoor seating. If you’re that paranoid eat at home.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:48pm
  • Pauline U.

    Please don’t let outdoor dining become fully enclosed! Having at least one side open helps with ventilation, which allows people who are vulnerable to respiratory illnesses to dine out more safely.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:48pm
  • Anonymous

    I am writing to encourage you to please allow outdoor dining structures to remain open on at least one side. Outdoor dining became more prevalent in our city during and after the pandemic. This also came in time with increased understanding about air quality and the importance of fresh air for those who are disable or immunocompromised or otherwise trying to avoid catching a virus indoors. Enclosing outdoor dining will make the air the same quality, if not worse due to lack of a ventilation system, as inside dining. This means this option will be closed to those who need it the most.

    As someone who avoids indoor dining during flu and covid surges I can tell you it is already incredibly hard to find outdoor dining spaces. It often means if I am in the city that I don’t stay as long and patronize as many places as I otherwise might.

    Requiring outdoor dining to remain open on at least one side even in the colder months makes it accessible for those who need it. People can bundle or heat lamps can be deployed against the cold, but once you enclose a structure it will shut many people out entirely.

    As we are working toward a more inclusive NYC, this is an important step to allowing those who are often shut out to join us at the table.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:51pm
  • Maura

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. This supports disabled and immunocompromised community members, as well as the restaurants where they can continue to spend their money.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:56pm
  • Isa F.

    Outdoor dining is necessary for people vulnerable to airborne pathogens. I do not support full enclosures. Adequate airflow is needed to prevent the spread of airborne illnesses that can remain in areas with poor ventilation for hours. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:57pm
  • Lynn

    I’m immunocompromised and outdoor dining is the only way I can eat at restaurants. Allowing restaurants to fully enclose their outdoor setups will completely exclude me from dining out. The only good thing about the current rules is the open side rule. People like me should be able to count on outdoor dining being safe for us. Please require that at least one side remains open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 5:59pm
  • QB

    Keep our sideWALKS WALKABLE!!!

    Hundreds of streets throughout the city have very narrow sidewalks, especially neighborhoods like the East Village and the Lower East Side which are overrun with restaurants and bars.

    Having outdoor dining and sidewalk cafes where there is plenty of space for them is great. But having to navigate them where there are only a few passable feet of pavement is inexcusable. It is especially irresponsible when these establishments attract so many people who then block the sideWALKs waiting for a table – not to mention that it benefits only private businesses.

    Almost every street in the city already has tree beds, bike racks, and now multiplying trashcans (both residential and businesses who have no back yards or indoor space to keep them), not to mention obstacles chained to streetlights and signposts.

    Especially our extremely narrow residential side streets are not made for this type of dining, or the careless behavior of patrons. Many of our sidewalks are barely wide enough for strollers / wheelchairs / walkers not to mention two people walking abreast; sidewalk cafes / extra tables and chairs being used by establishments sometimes render them impassable, forcing pedestrians into the streets.

    It also unfairly enables the restaurant industry over any other businesses. While I support and enjoy sidewalk dining where there is plenty of room for it, I do not believe that it should be permitted on our narrow residential side streets. I also do not believe that even 8 feet clearance is enough space on busy avenues.

    Lastly, eliminating NYC’s residents’ / taxpayers’ voices in the making of these decisions, and allowing the restaurant and nightlife industries to make hay while the moon shines (pun intended), is absolutely not acceptable.

    PLEASE, keep our sideWALKS WALKABLE!!!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:02pm
  • Soleil

    Please keep the outdoor dining options available, they are so lovely and more accessible for some folks!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:02pm
  • Candice

    Dear NYC Department of Transportation,

    I support year-round outdoor dining, but I urge DOT to revise the proposed winterization and protective-covering rules so that outdoor dining remains genuinely open-air and accessible.

    For many disabled and immunocompromised New Yorkers, outdoor dining is not a luxury or simply a preference. It is an accessibility measure that allows us to participate in public life while managing our health.

    I continue to take COVID precautions and rely on outdoor dining rather than eating inside restaurants. For me and others who depend on this option, ventilation is the point. Enclosing an outdoor café can remove the very feature that makes it usable. A space does not meet our needs simply because it is located outside the restaurant’s original walls.

    People who prefer an enclosed dining space already have an abundance of indoor restaurants to choose from. Those of us who need genuinely open-air seating cannot simply go inside instead. Enclosing outdoor dining does not give us another option. It takes away one of the few options we have.

    Immunocompromised people and others taking precautions against COVID need genuinely open-air options. These concerns affect a substantial population. An analysis published in Open Forum Infectious Diseases in 2024, using 2022 national survey data, estimated that 7.4% of U.S. adults, approximately 1 in 14, had a medical condition or received medication or treatment that weakened their immune system. Preserving genuinely open-air dining should be treated as a meaningful accessibility issue, not a niche preference.

    COVID has not stopped circulating. NYC’s own respiratory surveillance reported a 10% increase in COVID-related emergency-department visits for the week ending October 31, 2026. But access to genuinely outdoor dining should not depend on whether transmission happens to be rising or falling in a particular week. People who need to reduce exposure deserve reliable options throughout the year, not only when a surge receives public attention.

    People should not have to choose between taking precautions for their health and sharing a meal with friends or family. We want to participate in our neighborhoods and support local restaurants, too.

    Temperature is another important part of access. I have postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), and heat makes it difficult, if not impossible, to leave home. My window for going out is essentially November through February, when cooler temperatures make activities possible for me.

    I am sharing my experience because the City needs to consider people whose access needs are not met by indoor dining. Heat intolerance can affect people with POTS and other forms of dysautonomia, multiple sclerosis, thyroid conditions, diabetes-related nerve damage, and other medical conditions. Not everyone with these conditions has the same needs, but for those of us whose symptoms are worsened by heat, cooler outdoor seating can make the difference between being able to participate and having to stay home.

    The need for ventilation and the need for cooler temperatures can overlap, as they do for me. Enclosing outdoor seating can remove both features that make it accessible.

    Making outdoor dining available through the winter should expand access, not replace open-air seating with another enclosed dining room. For people whose health limits when and where they can go out, that distinction matters. In my case, the only season when I can finally participate in city life could instead become another season of exclusion.

    I am also concerned about the accessibility issues wheelchair users have raised regarding vertical enclosures. Coverings and their supports must not obstruct entrances, narrow accessible routes, or reduce wheelchair maneuvering space. Accessibility needs to be assessed with coverings fully deployed and tables occupied, not just when coverings are retracted or the café is empty.

    I ask DOT to:

    Preserve genuinely open-air seating rather than allowing outdoor cafés to become fully enclosed dining rooms.

    Require meaningful, unobstructed openings to outside air whenever patrons are present. A doorway or a small gap should not be enough.

    Apply ventilation requirements during both winterization and any use of protective coverings for adverse weather.

    Define adverse-weather exceptions narrowly so they do not become a routine justification for enclosing outdoor seating.

    Preserve cooler, open-air dining options for people whose conditions make heated or enclosed spaces inaccessible.

    Require coverings, supports, and associated equipment to preserve accessible entrances, exits, pedestrian routes, and wheelchair maneuvering space, with clear enforcement procedures.

    Include immunocompromised people, people with POTS and other heat-sensitive conditions, wheelchair users, and other affected disabled New Yorkers in decisions about these requirements.

    Please do not assume that a partially enclosed space will meet everyone’s needs. The goal should be to preserve real outdoor airflow and usable outdoor seating while allowing reasonable protection from the weather.

    I am not asking the City to abandon winter outdoor dining. I am asking the City to ensure that expanding it does not eliminate the qualities that make it accessible to people who depend on it.

    Please keep outdoor dining genuinely outdoors.

    Thank you for considering my comment.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:07pm
  • M Aubé

    I’m writing out of concern for people affected by this—restaurant owners, diners, and disabled and immunocompromised New Yorkers who all stand to lose if the outdoor dining program is weakened or rolled back. I’d hate to see renewed opposition jeopardize a program that benefits restaurants, diners, and people with disabilities.

    Large, substantially enclosed dining structures were among the features of the initial early pandemic outdoor dining program that generated public criticism. Allowing similar structures again risks reviving concerns about bulky enclosures, their appearance, and their impact on public space—concerns that could threaten public support for outdoor dining altogether. Likewise, addressing accessibility proactively reduces costly ADA litigation risk for both the department and businesses in the program.

    Preserving the program’s open-air character would help protect both accessibility and the program’s long-term viability and political will. I strongly support making outdoor dining permanent, and I’m worried about what’s at stake for the people who rely on it.

    The solution: Amend the proposed rules to require at least one fully open side during service. I urge DOT to amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), along with the corresponding provisions governing vertical protective coverings, to require minimum ventilation opening standards that can be achieved by requiring at least one entire side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe to remain fully open to outside air whenever patrons are present. This requirement should apply year-round, including during winterization and adverse weather conditions.

    Proposed regulatory language:

    “When utilizing vertical protective coverings, at least one entire side of a sidewalk cafe or roadway cafe shall remain fully open to outside air whenever the cafe is occupied by patrons. Such opening shall extend across the full available width of that side, from above any required safety barrier or perimeter demarcation to the overhead covering, if present, and shall remain unobstructed by curtains, panels, or other materials that substantially restrict natural airflow.”

    I also request that DOT establish enforceable minimum ventilation-opening standards and explicitly prohibit coverings or associated structures from obstructing accessible pedestrian routes, entrances, exits, or wheelchair maneuvering space. Requiring at least one fully open side is a practical minimum standard that would preserve meaningful outdoor dining access for disabled and immunocompromised New Yorkers while still allowing restaurants to provide weather protection.

    For their sake, I urge DOT to adopt this amendment and ensure that Dining Out NYC remains accessible, safe, and sustainable for all New Yorkers.

    Thank you for your consideration.

    Sincerely,

    M. Aubé

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:15pm
  • Salome K. Braganza-Gallagher

    Please ensure that outdoor dining has to have good ventilation, meaning that it should not be fully enclosed. This is helpful to those of us who are disabled, immunocompromised or who just want to avoid respiratory illnesses.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:19pm
  • Beth V

    My children and I visited NYC over Christmas 2024. It was downright balmy in the 60s and beautiful for most of our trip, and we greatly enjoyed being able to dine outdoors which allowed us to take in the scenery as well as the food, and get a real feel for the city. From simple cafe tables at the pizzeria my kids fell in love with to the decorated stalls in Little Italy even when the temps dropped it was comforting to know that being in the middle of a Covid wave wouldn’t diminish our options to still enjoy so much of the food the city has to offer, as we were not comfortable with the idea of eating indoors.
    We loved the accessibility and it made for a wonderful experience we could not get at home.
    Please keep the sidewalk dining at least partly open air year round for those of us who have to (or want to) stay cautious.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:20pm
  • Patryk Braganza-Gallagher

    Please ensure that outdoor dining spaces have adequate ventilation and are not fully enclosed. Proper airflow is important for people with disabilities, those who are immunocompromised, and anyone who wants to reduce their risk of exposure to respiratory illnesses. Outdoor dining should remain genuinely outdoors, with the ventilation that makes it a safer and more accessible option.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:21pm
  • Rebecca Armendariz

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Open-air, well-ventilated outdoor dining is a necessary accommodation for all, especially sick and disabled people who must avoid airborne infectious diseases.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:24pm
  • Sam Rosenthal

    Please, please, please keep our precious outdoor dining but do not require full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should be allowed to remain open. As an immunocompromised New Yorker with elderly parents, the option to eat open air areas keeps restaurant accessible to me.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:28pm
  • Anonymous

    I am immunocompromised and my family no longer eats inside restaurants because of the risk of airborne virus. I love patio dining and this proposal would mean we would not be spending thousands of dollars per year at restaurants.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:29pm
  • T.B.

    As an immunocompromised NYer, I strongly support amending the outdoor dining rules to allow for those of us who do not want to (and cannot) compromise our health to be able to support and socialize at businesses in our city. I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures, and request that at least one side of every outdoor dining setup remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:29pm
  • Sarah

    I’m a frequent visitor to New York City from Canada and, due to my husband being immunocompromised, we are COVID conscious and can only eat at restaurants outdoors with good airflow. Enclosing the outdoor terrace spaces at restaurants would make it impossible for us, and many other people in the COVID conscious community, to safely dine at restaurants in New York and it would probably lead to us needing to choose to visit other places instead of New York and spend our tourism dollars elsewhere. Please save open air dining!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:42pm
  • Anonymous

    I love traveling to New York and I only eat in outdoor spaces, so it is really helpful to have outdoor dining year round.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:43pm
  • Rebecca B

    Outdoor dining is a great option for high risk indivuals plus being able to breath fresh air is always great. Please dont take away outdoor real outdoor options.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:44pm
  • Anonymous

    Hi, I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air so that it is safe and accessible for immunocompromised individuals.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:47pm
  • Anonymous

    I speak as someone who is not even immunocompromised, and even I myself, when I think about what would feel like a safe outdoor restaurant area, I think it would need to be open on one side. Having it fully enclosed, such a small space, sounds like a great way to get sick in fact. So I hope that for this reason and all the other great points that others brought up that this would be put into the regulations.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:48pm
  • Miranda

    Please don’t enclose outdoor dining! It’s so important that restaurants leave their dining open air, for the immune compromised, the COVID cautious, and those of us who want to bring dogs!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:49pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air, as ventilation is very important to help reduce the spread of illness. This applies to all the seasons, including fall and winter.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:50pm
  • Anonymous

    I love New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining, but if a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can’t eat there. The issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:51pm
  • Gianluca

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:54pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.
    Open air is better for ADA compliance and those who are immuno-compromized and cannot dine inside a fully enclosed space for their health.

    As a tourist, open air dining is FAR more inviting than an enclosed space on a street.

    I really hope this is fully thought through.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:55pm
  • Anonymous

    Please do not fully enclose outdoor dining. One of the things I love about NYC as a tourist is being able to dine somewhat outdoors year round. I’m very high risk for viral infections, many of which are airborne, so good ventilation is incredibly important.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 6:59pm
  • Wendy Kushner

    I support the continuation of outdoor dining options without full enclosures. At least one side should remain open air to accommodate those who are immunocompromised.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:07pm
  • Tony

    I support outdoor dining and believe that it should have at least one side open air, not fully enclosed. I third Emma’s comment which covers many of the Important elements at play.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:09pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining, but not full enclosures. When fully enclosed, there is no health or medical benefit to the space being “outdoors.” At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should be required to remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:09pm
  • Keira

    Outdoor dining areas must maintain adequate ventilation to preserve the benefits of open-air dining, particularly for people who are immunocompromised or seeking to reduce their risk of airborne infections such as influenza or Covid.

    Please require at least one entire side of outdoor dining structures to remain fully open to outside air whenever customers are present, including during winter and adverse weather. This should be a clear, enforceable requirement of outdoor dining permits.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:10pm
  • Amy

    I am a regular visitor in NYC to see family and attend school events. One of the reasons I enjoy visiting the city is to explore new options for outdoor dining, because those are so hard to find in the suburb I live in. However, I am immune compromised due to being on immune suppressants for a serious medical condition. I cannot eat in crowded places indoors—it is not safe. Outdoor dining options need to meaningfully reduce risk of airborne disease transmission. Please amend the proposal to require at least 1 open side or enough open portions of temporary walls so that there is consistent airflow. Rain cover and propane heaters are still excellent options for keeping truly outdoor spaces comfortable, and having 2-3 sides enclosed still protects customers from wind. People really enjoy outdoor spaces and generally even non-disabled people would just sit indoors if they wanted to be in a fully enclosed space. Please keep the outdoor dining spaces *outdoor*!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:11pm
  • Alan Belsky

    I support outdoor dining but it needs to be meaningfully outdoors. There should not be full enclosures, at least one side of a built-up outdoor dining shed should always remain open.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:13pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:19pm
  • Chelby Roberts

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. As someone immunocompromised, it is not safe for me to dine indoors anymore. Open air outdoor dining is the only option for people like me.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:19pm
  • Meredith M.

    I support outdoor dining but I don’t support fully enclosed spaces that happen to be outdoors. That defeats the purpose of fresh air, especially during times of high respiratory illness. Heat lamps can still be used to great effect if needed in the colder months. I feel very strongly that at least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air to remain a safer environment for those hoping to avoid getting sick.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:24pm
  • TJ

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:26pm
  • Anonymous

    see attached

    Comment attachment
    2026-11-08-comments-to-dot-amended-rules-for-dining-out-copy-4.pdf
    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:28pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. This helps my family remain more germ free during respiratory illness season and beyond.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:29pm
  • Anonymous

    I am a NYC resident and fully support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. This is critical, allowing airflow and therefore enabling immunocompromised or disabled New Yorkers to more easily access them. Many of us can not eat indoors, including in fully enclosed outdoor structures.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:30pm
  • Abby Mahler

    Re: Sections 5-11(a)(1)(i), 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C), 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), and related provisions governing vertical protective coverings

    I love visiting loved ones in New York, and very much support and enjoy outdoor dining—indeed it is the only way I can patronize restaurants due to being high risk of severe outcomes from infection by airborne pathogens. If a restaurant’s outdoor dining space is enclosed, then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can no longer eat there. I have walked out of restaurants for this reason. The issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:43pm
  • Ashley Adams

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:44pm
  • Anonymous

    As someone who has in recent years become a frequent visitor to NYC from the West Coast, I was already rather disappointed by the comparative lack of outdoor dining available. As someone who is immune-compromised, outdoor dining is a huge accessibility issue, and the loss of it would force me to once again write-off visiting NYC due the lack of accommodations. I shudder to think of the thousands of NYC residents that you would also be effectively shutting out from meaningful shared public dining opportunities. I sincerely urge you to maintain robust, fully-open air dining at as many restaurants as possible. The number of immune-compromised individuals continues to increase and NYC should be at the forefront of serving them as well as continuing to support spaces that lower the chances of others becoming immune-compromised.

    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:47pm
  • Nigel

    I love New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining, but if a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can’t eat there. The issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:48pm
  • Emily Greenspan

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:49pm
  • Anonymous

    Year-round outdoor dining is essential for my family, who comes into the city from New Jersey regularly. Due to health issues, my family continues to mask and take other COVID precautions. Outdoor dining allows us to continue to meet with friends and enjoy dining out, which had been a passion for our family prior to the pandemic. Please ensure that there is open ventilation in any outdoor dining setup (at least one side fully open) to allow enough ventilation to make it safer for families like mine.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:50pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. Part of the appeal of outdoor dining is fresh air; a fully enclosed space would eliminate fresh airflow and make the environment much more similar to indoor dining– which defeats the purpose of patrons choosing to eat outdoors and the availability of such a choice. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to preserve the nature of eating outdoors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:50pm
  • Anonymous

    As someone who has visited NYC, I strongly prefer that outdoor open air dining remain available. This is the only way I dine out and would be disappointed to lose this option the next time we visit NYC.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:57pm
  • Amanda Fowler

    Please do not do this! I am still COVID conscious for a variety of reasons and don’t eat inside restaurants. I have visited many of the outdoor dining establishments in the city but only eat in the outdoor area. Please keep them as they do infact matter to many people!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:58pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outside dining, but not as fully enclosed; in the interest of fresh air and virus mitigation, I think it makes the most sense to allow partial closure (for instance, in bad weather, etc.), but to at least have one or two sides always available to be left open. Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 7:59pm
  • Hector Torres

    I have health issues and can’t eat indoors. If you close them up it is not any different than eating inside. Clean air matters to many and we want the option to eat outside. Please think of those who are different then you and can’t eat indoors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:03pm
  • William Harford

    Outdoor dining should have at least one open side, please

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:04pm
  • Mollie

    I am so excited for the return of so much more outdoor dining! I will be patronizing restaurants a lot more. I am immunocompromised and can’t eat indoors and need airflow. Please keep the outdoor seating with at least one long wall open for ventilation, or this isn’t true outdoor dining and I won’t be able to be a customer there. Thank you!!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:05pm
  • Sydney

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Outdoor dining without full enclosures makes restaurants accessible to immunocompromised individuals.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:06pm
  • Austin

    The proposed rule to allow enclosed outdoor dining defeats the purpose of the outdoor option. When COVID-19 first impacted our community, outdoor dining options were a safer and more accessible option for many of our community members. Without proper airflow, the proposal makes dining out another challenge for people concerned about getting sicker or getting others sick. Immunocompromised people and their family deserve to enjoy dining out together in a way that minimizes disease transmission, not be subject to a rules change whose results punishes and isolates them for acting with health and safety in mind.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:08pm
  • Anonymous

    I love NYC and its amazing restaurants. But as a person with medical needs that make me vulnerable to viruses that spread through the air, outdoor dining with proper airflow is a must if I can fully enjoy them. Please consider the needs of New Yorkers (and NYC visitors) who are in a similar boat. Keep NYC dining accessible for all!

    Also, enclosures are stuffy and uncomfortable, and heat lamps work great in the winter.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:08pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:19pm
  • Anonymous

    Hi, I don’t live in New York but visit as often as I can, several times a year! My health makes it really important for me to avoid viruses like Covid. Please, please don’t allow the full enclosure of outdoor dining spaces. I won’t want to come as often to a city where there is no dining I feel safe with. Our health will suffer or we the cautious tourists will just take our business to other places where we can feel safer!
    Thank you!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:19pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but please not fully enclosed!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:25pm
  • Anonymous

    PROPOSED RULES on OUTDOOR DINING
    implementing
    Laws Enacted in 2026
    Testimony, DOT, Nov. 9, 2026

    I want to raise two issues: (1) What is missing from the proposed rules but should be included, and (2) the elephant in the room.

    The Missing Rules
    Posting the Site Plan: I note that the proposed rules would now require that licensees retain a copy of the approved site plan for the premises and produce it on request of an employee of any city agency. (Ch. 5, section 5-10 (p) “License and Site Plan Availability”.) This does not go far enough. The site plan should also be POSTED on the premises in a place that is visible to the public.
    The public has a right to know how much of the public space is being given over to a private company. Right now, there is no public notice of the fact that there is a defined footprint that limits how much of the public space each outdoor café or bar can take over, or that the footprint is a public document, or how to get a copy. The public should not have to presume that a setup on the public sidewalk or roadway is approved just because it is there. The public has the right to report a violation of the law and to expect some enforcement action. They cannot do this if they don’t know that the law is being violated.
    Posting the site plan would involve no hardship for the restaurant or bar. The site plan already exists as part of its application and license, so the restaurant/bar would not have to create a new document. In addition, a restaurant/bar is already required to post its sanitary inspection grade (with license number) and refuse collection schedule, so it knows how to make a posting. The public interest requires that when a private restaurant or bar is licensed to take over the public sidewalk or roadway for its own exclusive use, it must disclose to the public the size, shape, and location of any public space that it is licensed to use.
    Establishing the Limits of the Licensed Footprint: The rules should also require every sidewalk café licensee to lay down on the sidewalk a FIXED, visible, durable (but not permanent) pavement marking by a tape or other material showing the PERIMETER DEMARCATION of its licensed footprint. This would be in addition the removable base wall, railing, planter, fence, or stanchion and rope that is now required by rule Ch. 5, sect. 5-11 (a) (2) (i). That rule is inadequate precisely because it requires that the perimeter demarcation be removeable. A removeable demarcation is, by definition, a moveable one.
    In practice, restaurants and bars are notorious for violating the clear path rule, spreading far into the public sidewalk space, by the simple tactic of placing their removable barriers far beyond the perimeter of their licensed footprint. No matter whether this is intentional or mistaken, the unavoidable result is the illegal takeover of public space by private interests, to the detriment of the public. The only way to stop this unlawful taking is to affix a visible, durable line on the sidewalk showing the limit of the café license. The management and staff will then have no excuse for exceeding a café’s licensed footprint, and the public – as well as city agency employees — will know whether and how a café is unlawfully spreading into the public space, without having to bring along a tape measure or yardstick.

    The Elephant in the Room
    Outdoor restaurant/bar owners are notorious scofflaws. A survey conducted by City Council speaker Corey Johnson during the temporary dining out program found that over 90% of the existing sidewalk and roadway cafes were in violation of the rules – many in violation of multiple rules. The situation today is not visibly improved. Noncompliance is still widespread, flagrant, persistent, defiant, and contumacious.
    They get away with it because they know the law is NOT BEING ENFORCED. It doesn’t matter what rules you adopt if you’re not going to enforce them. They may as well be written on the wind, and we’re all wasting our time here.
    DOT ought to be enforcing the law. You owe it to the public to do so.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:26pm
  • Valerie

    I would like to echo the calls to require at least one side of outdoor dining spaces to remain open to the outdoors. This measure would support accessibility and inclusivity for all New Yorkers and visitors. Thank you for your consideration.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:30pm
  • Alia

    The City is well aware of the many serious objections to Covid initiated restaurant street dining including trash, rats, no street cleaning, noise impacting residents, hampering emergency vehicles, sidewalk obstruction for pedestrians and the unfairness that the City is entitling and providing advantage to the restaurant sector above all.

    Note that there is no City help for retail business.

    It also completely outrageous that pedestrians are being deprived of sight lines to which pedestrians are entitled!

    The City’s legislation which eases restaurant street dining and the Proposal which further eases restaurant street dining is something that the GOP would do.
    (The City is well aware that voters had no idea what they were voting for and voted based on the Mayor’s personal popularity.)

    Further:
    It is completely unacceptable to allow restaurants to put gates on roadway sheds which means restaurants can have enclosed space in the street.

    It is completely unacceptable to change “primary building entrance” to “major building entrance” as this means restaurants can put sidewalk tables next to a building door.

    It is completely unacceptable that the enabling legislation now allows a restaurant with less than 20 feet of frontage to expand a street seating adjacent to the abutting property (if permitted by the abutting property owner).

    It is completely unacceptable that DOT will give an “interim” license to a restaurant before the application is actually approved.

    To repeat – the City’s legislation and proposal easing restaurant street dining is something the GOP would do.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:32pm
  • Anonymous

    I like the idea of reinforcing against the elements, but I don’t want these outdoor spaces to become fully enclosed. There should be at least a stipulation to require one wall to remain open. I’ve been to restaurants that claim to have outdoor spaces, but when I arrived, the entire space was enclosed with tarp. There was no airflow. That’s just making the space indoors again!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:34pm
  • Anonymous

    I support and enjoy outdoor dining, but if a restaurant is fully enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’. Immunocompromised and other vulnerable individuals deserve to exist in public too. Without proper ventilation, entire communities are shut off from dining alone, with friends or with family. No one should have to risk life-changing illness to take part in one of the things that makes this city so great. New York City is for everyone! Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces. Heating for the colder months is fine and encouraged! But enclosed, poorly ventilated spaces make it less safe for everybody, especially during cold and flu season.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:34pm
  • Anonymous

    I love NYC dearly and enthusiastically support and frequently enjoy dining outdoors. If a restaurant is enclosed then it is not really ‘outdoors’ and I cannot dine there. The main issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to continue to utilize their outdoor dining areas as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:37pm
  • Anonymous

    Making the outdoor dining enclosed makes it a moot point. The purpose is to have open ventilation. There are countless options to eat inside. There needs to be an option for everybody else.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:42pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:46pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:50pm
  • Anonymous

    If a restaurant’s outdoor area is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’. Having fresh air options is critical to ensuring people who want and need to avoid getting sick have places to gather. Outdoor dining ensures a low risk option of keeping people involved in their community without putting them at risk. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:51pm
  • Anonymous

    As a lifelong NYC resident, I support outdoor dining. However, I am also a COVID realist with a doctorate in disease ecology, so I don’t support fully enclosed outdoor dining because it won’t meet my family’s accessibility needs, and it won’t create outdoor spaces for my family to dine at lower-risk of airborne illness. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open-air to mitigate the spread of airborne diseases. Thanks!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:53pm
  • Dawn

    Outdoor dining has provided great opportunity for safer air dining especially for those immune compromised. The atmoshere of ourdoor eating with at least one wall open to outdoor air is comforting and provides air exchange keeping harmful pathogens from lingering.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 8:55pm
  • Caitlyn Cibulsky

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Keep outdoor dining actually outdoor in order to prioritize airflow and respiratory health!!!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:04pm
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining is such a severwly underrated amenity in such a dense city, for locals, visitors, and tourists alike. Any barriers to allow businesses to enable and maintain such spaces should be removed for the betterment of the community.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:07pm
  • Anonymous

    I love my city, and I live outdoor dining, but I am disabled and enclosed outdoor dining sheds pose a risk to me with catching airborne illnesses due to lack of airflow and ventilation. Allowing at least one side open for ventilation is essential.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:08pm
  • Aaron

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air, well-ventilated spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:15pm
  • Anonymous

    For severe health reasons I am restricted to outdoor activities. Dining outside is something I do almost daily ( weather permitting). If restaurants enclose their outdoor spaces, it is essentially a handicap violation. Those of us who are restricted to outdoor activities for severe health issues will no longer be able to participate in one of the few activities that help us be a part of regular life. Please don’t restrict us more than we already are.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:19pm
  • Kathryn Sylvia

    I love New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining, but if a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can’t eat there. The issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:24pm
  • Jenny Boissiere

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:28pm
  • Antonio Martinez

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. This is ableist in so many ways, including wheelchair users (like myself) being obstructed from entering these dining areas!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:31pm
  • Anna Pakman

    Another unintended consequence of this rule proposal to allow restaurants to fully enclose their outdoor dining spaces is that it defacto creates a building with an occupiable space that is thus subject to DOB Chapter 4 regulations on ventilation and outside air exchanges amended by Local Law 77 of 2023, and likely similar health code violations. Leading businesses to believe they are in the clear to enclose without considering impacts to other city regulations (not to mention ADA and NYCHRL implications mentioned in earlier comments) is irresponsible as it will create false security that could result in fines from other agencies. These rules cannot pass without the ventilation issue being meaningfully addressed, and the simplest way is to amend design allowances so that these spaces are not fully enclosed and at least one full side is open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:33pm
  • Tasha Vest

    Good ventilation and/or filtration of air is necessary for public health, to ensure accessibility for the disabled (such as immunocompromised people), and to economically support a thriving restaurant industry by removing any barriers for patrons. It is more economical for outdoor dining structures to have one open wall, rather than install HEPA or MERV-13 air filters and/or far-UVC disinfecting lamps. Adequate air filters would cost at least a couple hundred dollars each, and far-UVC disinfecting lamps are significantly more expensive than that. To balance patrons’ medical and accessibility needs and restaurant owners’ financial concerns, simply having enclosures with one open wall for passive ventilation makes the most sense as a rule.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:35pm
  • Anon

    I live in Brooklyn and deeply appreciate outdoor dining as an option for customers and restauranteurs alike. Please keep outdoor dining ‘outdoors’, and amend the rule so it’s not full enclosure. It’s so important to be able to eat out, engage socially, participate in the economy, without worrying about contracting airborne viruses.
    Thank you for all the work you’re doing!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:53pm
  • Suzanne

    Outdoor dining is not actually outdoors if it is fully enclosed and no fresh air enters the space, it’s just an extension of an indoor space. To ensure that outdoor dining is accessible to all, all spaces should be required to have at least one side fully open to allow for fresh air circulation.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:54pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. I love dining al fresco and it’s a deal breaker to my decision process often!

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:57pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 9:58pm
  • Anonymous

    Please allow restaurants to keep ventilation in outdoor areas for dining. By allowing restaurants to fully enclose dining areas restaurants will be losing a great deal of business and discriminating against those of us who want clean air while we are dining.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:05pm
  • Sam Wrigglesworth

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. This will create better air quality that allows myself and my loved ones to dine out when we otherwise would not be able to.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:13pm
  • Anonymous

    Hello, I am a frequent out of state visitor to NYC. I am immunocompromised and depend on being able to dine in wide open air if I am going to dine at a restaurant. Which, as it happens I do enjoy doing despite not feeling safe to dine indoors. While there is still inherent risk of contracting disease from being near other diners and waitstaff even outdoore, it is measurably reduced by the air currents outdoors. Please do not enclose *all* outdoor dining. The open air is more important to some people than you think.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:14pm
  • Donna M Herinya

    As a COVID-savvy New Jersey resident who enjoys going into NYC, I strongly support making outdoor dining permanent, but it must remain genuinely safe and accessible. Fully enclosing these structures on all sides defeats the entire purpose of outdoor dining, effectively turning them into poorly ventilated indoor spaces. This completely shuts out high-risk, COVID-conscious, and immunocompromised persons who rely on true open-air seating as a safe way to enjoy the city’s restaurants. The DOT should mandate that at least one full side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe remain entirely open to the outside air at all times. Keeping these spaces truly open-air protects public health, ensures ADA compliance, and preserves an essential lifeline for a dedicated community of diners.

    Thank you,
    Donna M. Herinya

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:14pm
  • Kendra Todd

    As a immunocompromised visitor to NYC, having unenclosed outdoor dining is a lifeline for me. In order to eat more safely and still patronize these wonderful restaurants, I need access to an unenclosed space which provides more airflow and is much safer relative to the spread of airborne illness. Allowing unenclosed outdoor dining will help people like me continue to support small businesses and remain healthy.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:24pm
  • Jessica Richter

    I love New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining, but if a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can’t eat there. The issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:31pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. Many airborne viruses circulate throughout the year and outdoor seating provides the only way for people to safely eat at restaurants. Shouldn’t everyone have the opportunity to enjoy the amazing food NY has to offer?

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:31pm
  • Gem Stone

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:33pm
  • anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:39pm
  • Barrie Covington

    While I’m grateful that year-round outdoor dining is being supported by New York City, fully enclosing dining structures negates the benefits of outdoor dining, particularly for immunocompromised and covid conscious individuals. An enclosed structure is indoor dining, and not safe for vulnerable populations.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 10:59pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining without full enclosure. Outdoor dining is supposed to protect against viruses. If you enclose everything it is the same as indoor dining. .

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:01pm
  • Madeline

    I love New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining!!! It is an absolute gem that came out of the pandemic, and incentivizes me to go out to eat far more in the wintertime than I would otherwise. However, I am concerned about the concept that all outdoor dining need to be “enclosed,” which greatly affects airflow and is the reason I so prize outdoor dining. Winter has much more indoor activity and is generally when Covid and flu spikes due to more indoor air being recycled and less “fresh.” I love to go out to eat, and especially love eating outdoors as it allows me to better avoid getting sick. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open and not enclosed!! I care about my health and that of other New Yorkers, and as temperatures look to be potentially warmer this winter, I would love to be able to continue safely eating outdoors in the glorious air.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:03pm
  • Zeynep Korkman

    Open air dining areas are essential to individuals who are seeking ti minimize risk of airborne infection and thus an accessibility issue to many residents and tourists with chronic illness, disability or medical treatment that renders them high risk. Please keep some areas accessible by keeping them open air

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:30pm
  • Anonymous

    I love visiting New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining, especially during times of nice weather. But if a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can’t eat there. The issue is air flow and health. At least one side has to be open and at least have privacy screens and that allow air to go through or adequate ventilation. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:34pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:34pm
  • Joanna Daniels

    Fully enclosed outdoor dining would not be safe because it does not have the ventilation that reduces the transmission of airborne pathogens, including measles, SARS-COV-2, and whatever is the next novel virus or influenza variant. I am interested in returning for extended visits for both work and family while remaining more cautious for the asthma and other conditions that are found among my friends and family.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:48pm
  • Caroline McArdle

    My name is Caroline and I am a resident of Brooklyn, New York. I am writing to speak up for those in the disability community who want to have a chance to dine out, socialize, have work meetings, support local businesses, and participate in public life in the colder months. To provide accessibility for all New Yorkers, one side of every outdoor dining structure should still remain open, rather than being fully enclosed on all 4 sides. I oppose the full enclosure of outdoor dining structures. Leaving dining structures partially open will make a huge difference for so many people, and is a simple change to make. Patrons who want to dine indoors can still do so. Thank you for your consideration.

    Comment added November 8, 2026 11:58pm
  • An

    Outdoor dining at the end of the day is a key accessibility need in New York. Millions of New Yorkers are at high risk for viral transmission and can not eat indoors. This is including but not limited to immunocompromised people, cancer patients, long COVID patients, and many citizens with invisible disabilities and chronic illnesses.

    The following sections threaten this: §§ 5-11(a)(1)(i), 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C), 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D) and §§ 5-01 and 5-11. The use of winterization and vertical coverings would not enable a fully outdoor space. The legislation must include language to ensure at least 1 lengthwise side of any outdoor dining must be fully open to outdoor air in order to prevent enclosed structures. Roof coverings would be compatible and potentially encouraged, but sides must enable air flow. Viral transmission is highest in the winter across pathogens, so it is imperative to preserve the integrity of outdoor spaces for disabled New Yorkers and their surrounding communities.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:06am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining, but I do not support fully enclosed setups. If setups are fully enclosed, they do not accommodate the many New Yorkers who rely on outdoor dining to remain healthy and still participate in our vibrant restaurant scene, such as those who are immunocompromised and those who simply want better ventilation to prevent falling ill. Cities such as Paris have open outdoor dining setups year round with sufficient heating, and I don’t see why NYC cannot do similarly. Please ensure outdoor dining remain accessible to all New Yorkers by ensuring proper ventilation and preventing fully enclosed setups.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:16am
  • Hannah

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors who dine outside for the added ventilation.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:32am
  • Jamie

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Airflow is important.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:39am
  • Anonymous

    Resident of Hell’s kitchen since 1971.
    Ban all restaurant outdoor dining.
    It’s hard enough already to travel the sidewalks.

    Comment attachment
    97a43e47089df37f785e4163b612dcae-2.pdf
    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:43am
  • Anonymous

    Ban all outdoor restaurant facilities.
    I am full time resident of Hell’s Kitchen
    since 1971. It’s hard enough to negotiate the sidewalks. And find a way to keep bicycles of all kinds off the sidewalks.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:48am
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining should be year round and can use heating systems in the winter. Removing this option reduces the amount of customers that can enjoy a meal outside without having to worry about compromising their immune system. Indoor dining should not be the only option following the COVID-19 pandemic. I personally would like to go to more restaurants but I am deterred if there is no outdoor dining options, even in the cold months. There are ways to prevent obstructive outdoor seating areas and adapt to the cold using heating options like in other countries or skiing locations that have restaurants. There is not just a handful of the population that does not go to restaurants if there is only indoor dining. Businesses could lose thousands of dollars if there are no options for those with immunocompromised conditions or health preferences.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:12am
  • Anonymous

    I always use outdoor dining when available, but never fully enclosed spaces. I can’t dine in restaurants indoors due to respiratory health reasons. If the outdoor seating is fully enclosed, it defeats the purpose of staying outside in the fresh air. Please always keep at least one side or section open to the air.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:26am
  • FM

    I strongly support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. Believe it or not, some of us HAVE regularly patronized restaurants outdoors via a sidewalk cafe or roadway restaurant in prior winters!

    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live. However, these enclosures should not be permitted to be fully walled off; doing so defeats the purpose of outdoor dining for those of us who support this. At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air.

    The need for proper outdoor dining that is regulated and ensures ample outdoor ventilation is also a disability justice issue. There are many of us who avoid indoor dining for for a number of reasons, as the risk of catching respiratory infections in poorly ventilated and tight spaces can harm any of us, especially those who are immunocompromised and with chronic illness.

    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues. The expansion of outdoor dining in 2020 opened new possibilities for socializing with my friends with physical disabilities, given that many NYC buildings are not well equipped or built by default to support those using mobility aids.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:42am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:45am
  • Rebekah Cross

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures because they prevent the circulation of fresh air to make the space safer for everyone. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 2:15am
  • Brittany Holmes

    I support outdoor dining but I do not support full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors that cannot eat indoors and need access to clean air.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 2:19am
  • Anonymous

    It’s not really outdoor seating if it’s enclosed and I’d like to eat outdoors and get some fresh air sometimes. What’s the point in taking that away?

    Comment added November 9, 2026 2:25am
  • DJ Hon

    There is no good reason for outdoor eating spaces to be fully enclosed!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:16am
  • Gregg Levine

    Dear NYC DOT,

    This is regarding Dining Out NYC Rule Amendments 5-01, 5-02, 5-03, 5-07, 5-09, 5-10, 5-11, and 5-12 of Chapter 5 and section 3-01 of Chapter 3 of Title 34.

    I am a New York City resident, and the reason I am not signing up to testify in person at the November 9 hearing on these matters is because I will be inside an MRI tube, one of the hundreds of medical procedures and doctor visits I have endured since my first Covid infection almost four years ago. The acute infection was bad enough, but the years of Long Covid and related health problems since have been life changing.

    Every month seems to bring a new problem, but one thing remains consistent: doctors tell me to avoid another Covid infection at all costs, as every new acute case seems to multiply my health problems.

    With that in mind, I am submitting this comment to urge that when NYC makes rules for year-round outdoor dining, it makes sure to require that the dining setups are truly outdoors. That means that the DOT should amend Sections 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D), along with the corresponding provisions governing vertical protective coverings, to require minimum ventilation opening standards that can be achieved by requiring at least one entire side of every sidewalk or roadway cafe remain fully open to outside air whenever patrons are present.

    Without truly fresh air in truly outdoor dining structures, there is no way I can patronize the city’s restaurants and cafes that I consider a central part of why I live here, and essential to my ability to maintain a social life.

    When I am inside public places, I wear a high-quality, well-fitting respirator—it remains one of the best ways to avoid contracting an infectious respiratory virus, or passing one on to others—but clearly, it would not work if I wanted to eat or drink. That is why I urge my public officials to consider drafting rules that allow me (and many like me) to participate in this part of city life.
    I should also emphasize that DOT has obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), as well as applicable provisions of the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL), to ensure that people with disabilities have meaningful access to public programs and services. Disabled people currently do not have true access to public space and yet these protections extend to people with a wide range of disabilities, including those whose medical conditions make them particularly vulnerable to respiratory infections. DOT should therefore consider whether its proposed regulations create unnecessary barriers to access for disabled New Yorkers.

    So, as they say, making sure outdoor dining is actually outdoors isn’t just a good idea, it’s the law.

    It’s also the right thing to do. Covid is still very much here, and not respecting our collective need to avoid repeated infections would show a callous disregard for the numbers of New Yorkers who still die each week from Covid, along with the thousands who will spend years battling Long Covid after an acute infection.

    That is why we need proper consideration in the outdoor dining rules, and why you should make clear that the requirements apply year-round, including during winterization and adverse weather conditions.

    Thank you for your attention to this important issue.

    Sincerely,
    Gregg Levine
    Manhattan resident; five-borough restaurant patron

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:26am
  • Frankie

    I strongly support outdoor dining, but fully enclosed spaces defeat the very purpose of it. Please ensure that at least one side of every outdoor dining area remains genuinely open to the air. For those of us who are immunocompromised, open-air dining is often the only way we can safely enjoy restaurants and participate in everyday social life while protecting our health. We rely on these spaces because indoor dining can pose a significant health risk. Please don’t take away one of the few options that allows us to enjoy dining out with some peace of mind. Keep outdoor dining open air, not enclosed – thank you!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:40am
  • Anonymous

    One of the best parts of eating outdoors is having fresh air circulating so you’re not stuck breathing in a neighboring table’s cough spread germs. By fully enclosing these outdoor so dining spaces, the charm of sidewalk dining disappears and you’re just in a colder room outside. I oppose these new rules as a NYC resident of more than 30 years.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:43am
  • Norah Mason

    I am writing to ask that you amend the rules so that businesses cannot fully enclose outdoor dining spaces. Open-sided sheds are one of the few reasons my husband and I can eat out when we go back multiple times a year to visit my family in my hometown of NYC. To me, this is an important way to be able to eat more safely and support local businesses. Not having this option would severely limit dining options for those of us who are Covid aware. Businesses already do have a fully enclosed space in which people can dine: inside their restaurants! The open-air outside option is critical to maintain for those of us who want to stay healthy and not get sick or make others sick. Especially as one of the times Covid and other viruses tend to spike is during colder months when businesses might want to close in their outdoor seating, this option is critical to reducing transmission and keeping people safer. If people don’t want to eat outdoors, they can go inside, but please reserve the outdoor option for those of us who do not want to be part of the transmission chain. It is also the only way (other than eating in my family’s backyard in Harlem) that we can share a meal with my family and friends who are less cautious, and that has been so important to our relationships. Thank you.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:50am
  • Christina Virgil

    Please allow outdoor dining to continue year-round, while honoring the spirit of the word “outdoor.”

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:52am
  • Sebastian Guzman

    Keep outdoor dining outside! We need to be able to have fresh air.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:59am
  • Kendell Tylee

    Please— as someone who is immune compromised and easily prone to COVID… but also needs to socialize and be in community, eating outside is how I can do it! This is literally a lifesaving measure for me. Thank you!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:59am
  • Sebastian Guzman

    Keep outdoor dining!! We need fresh air!!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:00am
  • Anonymous

    As someone who regularly visits NYC, I rely on _non-enclosed_ outdoor dining to remain safe from respiratory illness. Thank you for accommodating the needs of older visitors of your beloved city.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:02am
  • Lisa

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:43am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining, but with the caveat that full enclosures not be required. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Requiring full enclosures for outdoor seating could discourage vulnerable customers from attending and reduce future clientele. Instead, policy makers should look to encourage dining establishments to install patio heating for use in outdoor dining areas during cool weather conditions.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 5:22am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining. It enables those who are unable to dine indoors to access dining out.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 5:30am
  • Anonymous

    As a tourist who loves New York, I actively look for restaurants with outdoor dining for ventilation and health reasons. If a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really outdoors and I can’t eat there. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces to support everyone, including those with health issues who want to enjoy the city

    Comment added November 9, 2026 5:56am
  • Lori Del Percio

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 6:19am
  • Ronnie B

    Please do not require outdoor dining to be fully enclosed. As an immunocompromised person, I am hyper-conscious of air quality when dining out. Restaurants rarely have sufficient air filtration or circulation, so I rely on outdoor dining season to “get my fix” of restaurant dining. I’m really sad at the idea of that going away for reasons I can’t understand. Covid is still in our air, still infecting our people. It disabled me and millions of others worldwide. Forcing all dining to be enclosed forces immunocompromised people like me out of restaurant dining altogether. Please, I beg you, do not do this. 🙁

    Comment added November 9, 2026 6:59am
  • Anonymous

    I fully support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Policymakers should remain mindful of immunocompromised and medically fragile people (residents and tourists) who regularly seek out and need open air dining options to be able to engage in public dining freely without compromising their health. Please remain accessible and disability-friendly.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:10am
  • Sarah

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:13am
  • Kate Green

    I support outdoor dining but it’s so important that at least one side remains actually open. This is a necessary accommodation for access to cleaner air and directly affects my ability to dine out.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:14am
  • Anonymous

    Hello,

    Outdoor dining is a lifeline for me and my family to socialize more safely from airborne pathogens, especially in the winter. At least one side of every outdoor dining set up should remain open for air flow. Fully enclosed spaces are not outdoors and remove this accessibility option for so many who need it.

    Thank you for your time.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:20am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining, but not full enclosures. Without air flow many residents and visitors would no longer be able to dine in at restaurants. Air flow makes it safer and therefore accessible for immunocompromised people and those who are avoiding getting sick for various reasons to dine at a restaurant.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:31am
  • Anonymous

    I love New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining, but if a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can’t eat there. The issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:40am
  • Eleanor Broughton

    I support outdoor dining but not full closures. At least one side must remain open to ensure airflow. Diners deserve to breathe fresh air! Leaving an opening will also prevent the spread of diseases like the flu, and will take less time for restaurant workers to clean and sanitize. Thank you.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:51am
  • Anonymous

    I support the move to allow outdoor dining year round. However, I do not support the ability to make the dining fully enclosed and at least one side should be required to remain open. Allow this airflow makes the experience much safer from airborne viruses including Covid-19.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 7:52am
  • JH

    I support outdoor dining areas but I do not support them being fully enclosed. For many members of the community, fully enclosed outdoor areas removes all utility for avoiding exposure to infectious diseases. These people would still love to patronize these businesses and this can completely limit/remove their safe access to them.

    Outdoor dining that is enclosed by 4 walls, with no airflow IS indoor dining by nearly any metric.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 8:25am
  • Nicole Matz

    Please please please, I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. We eat outside all year round for proper ventilation. Many of us can’t get sick again but want to support restaurants and have an ability for a social life. Enclosing them just makes for indoor seating. I beg you to rethink this.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 8:30am
  • Ryan F.

    I love New York and enthusiastically support and enjoy outdoor dining, but if a restaurant is enclosed then it’s not really ‘outdoors’ and I can’t eat there. The issue is air flow and health. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces. More options are better for everyone, and allow for greater personal freedom when it comes to dining out and supporting our restaurants and small businesses.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:01am
  • Alice Dreyer

    As a immunocompromised person and frequent visitor to NYC, I support outdoor dining that is really OUTDOORS and allows air to circulate around the diners. I have not eaten inside a restaurant since February 2020, because I cannot do so without seriously risking my health and functioning, but I have had every kind of cuisine outside, and I have been immensely grateful that I have not lost access to this important part of life. Please do not close people like me out of public life. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. Thank you.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:11am
  • Eman Rimawi-Doster

    Dear Commissioner and Staff of the Department of Transportation:

    Thank you for the opportunity to testify regarding the proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC program. My name is Eman Rimawi-Doster and I’m a Senior Community Organizer for the Disability Justice Program at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest.

    When outdoor dining rules and outdoor structures were first introduced, I worked closely with the Regional Planning Association to make sure that New Yorkers with disabilities were involved and heard. As the City moves toward expanding and making outdoor dining permanent, it is essential that the program continue to listen to the voices of the disability community and remain genuinely accessible, inclusive, and safe for all New Yorkers.

    I fluctuate between using a wheelchair and a walker. I also have lupus and long Covid and take serious precautions against airborne illnesses. For me, outdoor dining is not simply about having another restaurant option or having a meal outside. It is about being able to fully participate in my community, spend time with friends, support local businesses, and experience the city without having to choose between my health and my social life.

    During the pandemic, outdoor dining opened doors that had historically been closed to many disabled people. It created opportunities to socialize and participate in public life while avoiding the risks associated with enclosed indoor spaces. It also offered alternatives to restaurant interiors that are often physically inaccessible to wheelchair users.

    We should be building on that progress, not dismantling it through regulations that prioritize convenience over accessibility.

    Let me be clear: Outdoor dining that excludes disabled people is not accessible outdoor dining. And a program that is only accessible on paper is not an accessible program.

    The proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC rules are an opportunity for the City to demonstrate that it understands accessibility as a fundamental civil right, not an administrative detail.

    The proposed rule would amend multiple sections of Title 34 of the Rules of the City of New York to implement recently enacted local laws, clarify existing requirements, and improve the administration and operation of the Dining Out NYC program.

    But as DOT considers these changes, I want the Department to ask a much more important question:

    Are these changes making outdoor dining more accessible to everyone, or are they creating new barriers for the people who already face the greatest barriers in public space?

    The City must not forget the disability community in the process.

    Thank you for the opportunity to testify. I can be reached at (212) 336-9311 or [email protected] if you have any questions or would like to discuss these issues further.

    ###

    About New York Lawyers for the Public Interest 

    For 50 years, New York Lawyers for the Public Interest (NYLPI) has been a leading civil rights advocate for New Yorkers marginalized by race, poverty, disability, and immigration status. Through our community lawyering model, we bridge the gap between traditional civil legal services and civil rights, building strength and capacity for both individual solutions and long-term impact. Our work integrates the power of individual representation, impact litigation, and comprehensive organizing and policy campaigns. Guided by the priorities of our communities, we strive to achieve equality of opportunity and self-determination for people with disabilities, create equal access to health care, ensure immigrant opportunity, strengthen local nonprofits, and secure environmental justice for low-income communities of color. 

    NYLPI’s Disability Justice Program works to advance the civil rights of New Yorkers with disabilities. In the past several years alone, NYLPI disability advocates have represented thousands of individuals and won campaigns improving the lives of hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers. Our landmark victories include mandating that the MTA equitably provide its Access-A-Ride services to all applicants and riders with limited English proficiency. We have worked together with the MTA to bring about an “on demand” Access-A-Ride program and to enable New York’s most indigent residents to obtain Fair Fare discounts when using Access-A-Ride.

    We are currently litigating a class action lawsuit seeking to permit all Access-A-Ride users to access the same discount programs available to all other MTA transit users, as well as a class action to remedy the enormous gaps between subway cars and subway platforms system-wide.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:15am
  • Noah Parker

    Dear Commissioner,

    I am a regular diner who has spent a good part of the last several years
    reading the public health and building science literature on where
    people can eat safely, and I am writing to support the proposed
    amendments permitting transparent winterization coverings on all sides
    of sidewalk and roadway cafes. I do so with a clear understanding of the
    risks, and I believe the evidence supports a conditional approval rather
    than an open-ended one.

    The core finding is that open air is protective. A systematic review of
    respiratory virus transmission found that fewer than 10 percent of
    COVID-19 infections occurred outdoors, and that the odds of indoor
    transmission were 18.7 times higher than the odds of outdoor
    transmission. The reason is airflow. Experts I have read consistently
    describe the outdoors as a place where exhaled aerosols dilute quickly,
    which is exactly what a closed structure reduces.

    That is why I do not dismiss the objections. The Guangzhou restaurant
    outbreak, studied by the Guangdong Centers for Disease Control, involved
    three family clusters in an air-conditioned room, and the airflow
    direction was consistent with droplet transmission. A University of Hong
    Kong team later found that the restaurant’s ventilation was only about 1
    litre per second per person, and that infections occurred well beyond
    the 1.5-metre range of close contact. Their analysis concluded that
    transmission becomes more likely when ventilation falls below 3 litres
    per second per person, and they recommended carbon dioxide sensors, with
    readings above 1,000 parts per million indicating insufficient
    ventilation.

    Those numbers are the reason I ask that enclosed cafés be built to a
    ventilation standard, not merely covered in plastic. A transparent
    enclosure with a mechanical air exchange requirement, CO2 monitoring,
    and a cap on the number of diners per structure would protect patrons in
    ways that an open-sided patio on a windy day cannot always match. I also
    support limiting enclosed structures to a single party at a time,
    because the epidemiologist Linsey Marr has noted that a tent holding one
    party shares far less air with others than a shared room does.

    I ask the Department to adopt the amendments with these conditions
    attached, so that the people sitting inside a winter café can be
    confident the space was designed for their safety.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:17am
  • Eric

    Let businesses keep their dining enclosed.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:18am
  • Eden D

    I and many others oppose any option for outdoor dining that allows for or encourages fully enclosed dining shacks. The more elaborate these builds are, the more they obstruct sidewalks and create hazards for pedestrians, wheelchair users, and people pushing strollers or carts. A fully enclosed shack will provide none of the benefits of outsoor dining–aka being en plein air–by creating an accessory unit that is built and maintained with questionable standards. I am also concerned about owners running extension cords into these shacks to run heaters which create both trip and fire hazards. Outdoor dining should be outdoors, open to the air on at least two sides to ensure proper ventilation. Otherwise we are giving away public space to shoddy construction, trip hazards, and fire hazards to help proprietors create another dining room, when ostensibly they already have one inside the actual building housing their kitchen and main seating that is required to be up to code and has plumbing, electrical, and ventilation. People sit outside to be OUTSIDE, not enclosed in some second rate shack with no airflow and also no regard for how much sidewalk traffic is interrupted. Cover it from sun and rain, but leave the sides open so that people who want to support restaurants can do so more safely without worrying about fire, fumes, or getting sick from being in an enclosed space, and impose stringent regulation on providing and preserving a clear path for pedestrians, workers making deliveries, and the disabled.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:20am
  • Anon

    Hi! I’m just writing to say that I support outdoor dining. However, I do not support full enclosures. I support at least one side of every outdoor dining to remain open air. Thank you for your consideration.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:25am
  • Michelle Stockwell

    I value access to outdoor dining as an option for lowering my risk of exposure to covid and the flu, especially in colder months. I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. Thank you!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:26am
  • James Wheeler

    I operate a restaurant in New York City, and I am asking the Department
    to adopt rules that allow fully enclosed winter cafés, with a
    performance-based framework that makes them both safe and financially
    viable. The current model does not work for small operators, and the
    proposed amendments are the first realistic path forward.

    The economic stakes are documented. In a 2020 report, the state
    comptroller estimated that one-third to one-half of New York City’s
    restaurants and bars could close within six to twelve months, and the
    city’s restaurant association warned at the time that diners would not
    sit outside in freezing temperatures and snow. Those warnings have not
    gone away. A café that cannot be used for four or five months of the
    year cannot carry its rent, its payroll, and its insurance on warm-
    weather revenue alone.

    The rules that existed during the pandemic illustrate the problem. In
    2020, New York treated tents with at least half of their sidewall open
    as outdoor dining, but fully enclosed tents were limited to a 25 percent
    occupancy cap, the same as indoor dining. A room limited to a quarter
    of its capacity is not a business model. The proposed amendments should
    replace wall-counting with measurable performance standards.

    Engineering answers exist. A public health guide prepared for Canadian
    municipalities recommends either treating an enclosed patio as an indoor
    space with a mechanical ventilation system that meets indoor standards,
    or adapting the enclosure to weather conditions, such as closing it on
    windy days and opening it on still ones. I support both approaches and
    would accept either as a condition of permitting. I also propose that
    the Department adopt a fixed ventilation requirement per seat, air
    quality sensors that trigger ventilation or opening when carbon dioxide
    rises, and a prohibition on fuel-burning heaters inside enclosures,
    since carbon monoxide exposure from misused patio heaters is a
    documented hazard.

    Operators who build to these standards should be rewarded with clear,
    predictable approvals, and operators who cut corners should face
    penalties strong enough to deter them. I ask the Department to finalize
    the rules on that basis.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:27am
  • Anomymous

    I am not an NYC resident but a frequent visitor. I support outdoor dining, but I’m opposed to fully enclosed outdoor dining. Keeping at least one side open allows for necessary airflow that makes outdoor dining desirable for people with immune health concerns. In my hometown, when structures are built to allow closure of patios/outdoor spaces, these remain closed and thus inaccessible to me for most of the year, open only on the very nicest days. Many of the patrons who prefer a fully enclosed space would actually prefer to be fully indoors, meaning that fully indoors outdoor dining does not serve any group particularly well. I’m concerned about how fully enclosed outdoor dining excludes people who are avoiding airborne pathogens from participating in local economy and fully enjoying what the city has to offer.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:33am
  • Shayla Black

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:36am
  • Liesa Abrams

    I work in New York, and frequently eat at restaurants with outdoor dining options. If these outdoor areas became fully enclosed, I would no longer be able to enjoy meals there safely. Anyone who is comfortable eating indoors can eat inside the restaurants. I would greatly implore you to retain some open airflow outdoor seating options for the many people who can only feel safe dining out in that context. Thank you!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:37am
  • Jaycee Miller

    As a long time resident of New York, I live in a neighborhood where the
    street is part of daily life, and I am writing to support fully enclosed
    winter cafés, provided they are built and managed in a way that
    protects pedestrians, neighbors, and the people sitting inside them. The
    community benefits from active street life through the winter, but only
    if the structures work for everyone who uses the sidewalk.

    The concerns I hear from neighbors are real and deserve specific
    answers. Public health researchers have flagged the risk that temporary
    structures can obstruct other users’ rights of way, particularly for
    people with disabilities. The proposed rule’s clear-path requirements
    and six-foot clearance for drive rails are the right starting point, and
    I urge the Department to enforce them as strictly for enclosed
    structures as for open ones. A wheelchair user or a parent with a
    stroller should never face a wall of plastic on a narrowed sidewalk.

    Structural safety also needs attention. Researchers have identified the
    structural safety of temporary structures during heavy or wet snowfall,
    along with emergency egress, as key challenges for winter dining. I ask
    that structures be engineered for local snow loads, that exits remain
    unobstructed and clearly marked, and that enclosures be taken down
    during declared snow emergencies. These are not hypothetical concerns. A
    sidewalk structure that collapses or blocks a fire lane creates exactly
    the kind of incident that makes neighbors oppose these programs.

    Noise is another community issue that the rule should address. One
    infectious disease specialist advised restaurants to turn down the music
    in enclosed spaces, noting that louder conversation increases the
    potential to expel more particles. For residents living above or beside
    a café, enclosed structures can also trap sound, so I ask for hours
    limits and noise standards that apply to enclosed seating just as they
    do to indoor restaurants.

    Finally, the Department should publish inspection results and respond to
    complaints openly. Community confidence in enclosed cafés will depend
    on whether the rules are enforced evenly, from the largest restaurant
    group to the smallest neighborhood bistro.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:39am
  • David

    I strongly support outdoor dining. The proposed rules must be amended so that one side of every open air set up remains open during dining service for proper ventilation.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:47am
  • Mitchell C

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air. Open-air, well-ventilated outdoor dining is a necessary accommodation for all, especially sick and disabled people who must avoid airborne infectious diseases.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:58am
  • Haley

    I support outdoor dining, but if an outdoor space is enclosed, that is no longer outdoor dining. The issue is air flow. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air for health purposes. Enclosures make this a non-accessible option. Please allow restaurants to keep their outdoor spaces as open air spaces.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 9:59am
  • Russ A

    I really support year-round outdoor dining in NYC at both sidewalk cafes and roadway setups. Varenyky, burgers, hot drinks all great outside in the winter!

    Year-round, outdoor dining makes NYC a better place to live and we are grateful for this! But for these to be fully accessible for everyone, we need for there to be air circulation inside and not closed off.

    At least one full side or two half sides of every outdoor dining setup should remain open to the air. This would increase ventilation for those of us who avoid indoor dining because we don’t want to keep catching respiratory infections over and over again.

    Please also ensure that all outdoor dining is ADA accessible for all of us who have mobility issues.
    Thank you so much for all you do!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:02am
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. I believe at least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:08am
  • Mark W.

    Outdoor dining Is great but should not be enclosed. Look at other great international cities. Even places like Copenhagen and Amsterdam have year round outdoor spaces with a blanket for warmth. Unenclosed dining is important for people who are immunocompromised and who can get sick from indoor air

    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:08am
  • Erin

    Will there be people recommended “Companies” who can advise on what the specifics are, in real time, what are the options we can use for a more permanent winterization of the enclosures?

    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:11am
  • Chelsea West 200 Block Association

    My name is Jesenko Vukadinovic, and I am the President of the Chelsea West 200 Block Association. The Chelsea West 200 Block Association covers the blocks bounded by West 19th and West 22nd streets and Seventh and Eighth avenues in the Chelsea neighborhood in Manhattan.

    My block association is generally supportive of the proposed rule changes. We believe strongly in the positive role outdoor dining can play in promoting the well-being of our neighborhood, and we are hopeful that the proposed rules will help support existing and future outdoor dining venues. Within our block association area, we currently have about 20 businesses with sidewalk cafes and roadway cafes, and we would be happy to welcome more.

    Toward that end, we are eager for DOT to adopt common sense rules that will: (1) be clear to both businesses and residents; (2) be embraced by businesses, resulting in higher levels of compliance; and (3) make enforcement by DOT more efficient and effective.

    Many of the proposed rule changes are steps in the right direction, but some also pose concerns about compliance and enforcement:

    Perimeter barriers: Eliminating the need for a perimeter barrier for restaurants with a single row of tables makes sense, particularly for businesses that do not provide table service. We are concerned, however, that without some demarcation separating the cafe boundary and the clear path, cafe tables and chairs will inevitably extend beyond the boundaries of the sidewalk cafe and block the clear path. How are restaurant users and pedestrians supposed to know what the boundaries are? How does DOT intend to enforce this requirement?

    Vertical winterization coverings: The proposed rule allowing for readily removable vertical winterization coverings also makes sense. We are concerned, however, that such coverings will be attached to awnings that extend beyond the boundaries of the sidewalk cafe. While not permitted it is common for awnings, especially extendable ones, to go beyond the boundaries of sidewalk cafes and cover clear path areas. We suspect that compliance with this new rule will be low, and that enforcement will be limited. Moreover, while the rules use the simple terms “clear visibility” and “transparent” these terms are not defined, inviting non-compliance. Must the coverings be 100 percent transparent? What constitutes “clear visibility”? Are only panels that are entirely clear permitted? If so, say so. If not, say what is permitted. We suggest that these terms be made more explicit, so that businesses will have a better sense of what is required, and DOT will have specific standards to enforce.

    Other changes are welcome and not problematic. We applaud the changes that clarify the definition of a major building entrance and that include curb width in the measurement of a clear path. Both changes resolve uncertainties in the existing rules.
    We are hopeful that public comments will help inform the final set of rules.

    Thank you for your time and consideration.

    Comment attachment
    DoT-Comments-.pdf
    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:13am
  • Christine Berthet

    Testimony, Outdoor Dining rules 11-9-26
    Manhattan Community board 4.

    We support sidewalk and roadway cafes. We oppose rigid panels that literally privatize the sidewalk café space.

    We are alarmed that the rules do not provide for a consistent clear path for pedestrians in the 3% of sidewalks that experience the most pedestrian crowding.

    On the contrary, the new language in the rules makes an exception for pedestrian barricades and does not require the clear path to be “straight” which would allow for more recesses. The perpendicular measurement method is maintained instead of radius as required in the Pedestrian Mobility plan. This will cause frequent bottlenecks that defeat the purpose of the clear path on those busy avenues.

    This change is done surreptitiously by removing the word “straight” from the clear path definition, but omits to show the DELETED MATERIAL IN {BRACKETS} per the NYC rules’ convention. This undermines the integrity of this hearing. Per New York City (CAPA, City Charter § 1043): “A notice that obscures a significant change can support an argument that notice was inadequate,”

    There are also inaccuracies and ambiguous measurements. The definition of the “curb” conflicts with the New York State traffic law (1-1-111) current definition. The requirement that the vertical winterization comply with the contour of the café is missing. The clearances measurements are in conflict with the clear path.

    These rules as written will take away crucial space for pedestrians, they will introduce many uncertainties and conflicts with the communities and will make it costlier to enforce the law.

    We urge you to correct these items to make the overall program as successful and easy to operate as it should be.

    Comment attachment
    testimony-cafe-rules.-docx.docx
    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:28am
  • Eric Vasquez

    Please do NOT get rid of outdoor dining options in New York City. We do NOT want the outdoor dining to become ‘enclosed dining’.

    Thank you.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:34am
  • Emily Mervosh

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. Like thousands of New Yorkers, I am immunocompromised and can’t eat indoors safely. Outdoor dining with enclosures poses the same risk as eating indoors and is therefore just as inaccessible. There are so many of us that want to support or local restaurants – please make it safe enough for us to do so.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 10:58am
  • Nicole Lopez-Jantzen

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors. If it is fully enclosed, it will not be accessible to me, as I have long COVID and cannot risk getting sick due to lack of air circulation.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 11:38am
  • Nicola Perry

    No restaurants are going to do outdoor dining unless they are allowed to enclose the space. Also we need to be able to have gates at night to keep out homeless people from sleeping and deficating. The covid original sheds were fantastic and could be used all year round. Whoever designed what is in place now should go back to architecture school. What is the point of putting in heaters if one end is wide open. This makes zero sense. People with health issues can sit in the multitude of open sidewalk cafes then we will have something for everyone.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 11:42am
  • Dara Haas

    Outdoor dining must have proper ventilation—or it isn’t truly outdoor dining!

    The purpose of outdoor dining is to benefit from fresh air that continuously dilutes and carries away airborne pollutants and infectious aerosols, including viruses like COVID-19. When restaurants enclose outdoor spaces with plastic walls, windows, or roofs without adequate airflow, these areas can trap exhaled air, allowing infectious particles to accumulate—much like indoor dining.

    A roof alone doesn’t make a space unsafe, but enclosing the sides without sufficient cross-ventilation defeats the purpose of dining outdoors. True outdoor dining requires substantial open-air circulation, not simply a table placed outside a building. This is an important public health and accessibility issue, especially for immunocompromised and medically vulnerable people.

    If the air can’t circulate freely, don’t call it outdoor dining!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 11:44am
  • Anonymous

    In 2020, NYC permitted outdoor, open air dining structures in order to reduce the risk of catching or spreading Covid while dining indoors. Enclosure of these spaces was strictly prohibited. They needed to be open air to work!

    Almost seven years later, Covid is still here. Risk of death has been replaced by risk of disability. To date, approximately 1 in 7 NYC residents have developed long term symptoms after a Covid infection. Many have not recovered. There is no cure.

    The primary risk of Covid is not death, it is long term disability. That is a risk to our people and our economy. Acting like this is no longer the case hurts diners, restaurants, public health, and the social fabric of our city.

    Structures must allow for the free flow of fresh air or they don’t accomplish their primary reason for being. Please keep outdoor dining truly outdoors!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 11:59am
  • Mark Matuska

    To NYC Department of Transportation:

    I appreciate the opportunity to comment on the proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC regulations.

    I would like to raise a concern regarding the impact of Global Corridor designations on sidewalk cafés, particularly on narrower historic streets where the required 12-foot clear path leaves very little space for outdoor dining.

    DOT’s published pedestrian-demand classifications reveal some interesting disparities. Gansevoort Street is designated a Global Corridor, while other streets adjoining High Line access points, including West 18th and West 23rd Streets, are classified as Regional Corridors. West 20th, 26th, and 28th Streets are classified as Neighborhood Corridors. Similarly, streets adjoining major museums, including MoMA and the Metropolitan Museum of Art, generally carry less restrictive designations.

    While these differences may be supported by DOT’s modeling, their basis is not readily apparent from the published data.

    I encourage DOT to clarify how these classifications are determined and whether there is a process for reconsidering individual street or block designations based on actual pedestrian conditions. Given the significant effect these designations have on the viability of sidewalk cafés, greater transparency and a means of reviewing them would be valuable.

    Thank you for your consideration.

    Mark Matuska, AIA
    M Squared Architecture PLLC

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:17pm
  • Joshua Prila

    Hello, I am a fan of visiting New York City as a tourist and visiting many restaurants in different areas of the city. If the city were to stop outdoor dining that is not enclosed, I will no longer be visiting and spending money in the city. Thank you

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:30pm
  • Merry

    I love visiting New York, and I am a full time caregiver for a family member who is high risk and was hospitalized just last month from complications from a cold. Outdoor dining that isn’t enclosed allows me to eat with safer air quality that protects me and my front from illness. Enclosed outdoor dining is not really any safer from a viral transmission perspective than indoors, and a move to only that type of outdoor dining in NYC would, as a tourist, have me start diverging my travel time and money to other cities. Yes, I really love Broadway, but other cities also have theater and keeping my family safe is priority one.

    Please reconsider this proposed outdoor dining rule for the vulnerable and their family members and caregivers, both your local residents and your tourists.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:34pm
  • Joanna Gallai

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:36pm
  • Josh Hughes - Manhattan Community Board 5

    Resolution Text:

    Dear Commissioner Flynn,

    At the regularly scheduled monthly Community Board Five Executive Committee meeting on Monday, November 2nd, 2026, the following resolution passed with a vote of 14 in favor; 0 opposed; 0 abstaining:

    WHEREAS, The New York City Department of Transportation has proposed regulatory amendments to the Dining Out NYC program rules governing the design, winterization, operation, eligibility, accessibility, and enforcement of sidewalk and roadway cafés; and

    WHEREAS, The proposed amendments introduce a framework allowing roadway cafés to operate on a year-round basis, establish an 11:00 p.m. daily outdoor closing hour, set standards for winter coverings, enclosures, and material transparency, restrict café setups strictly to customer food and beverage service, refine pedestrian clear-path and siting geometries, and expand enforceable violations and penalties; and

    WHEREAS, Manhattan Community Board Five recognizes the cultural and economic importance of outdoor dining to the vitality of New York City and our local business community, while maintaining that the primary public purpose of streets and sidewalks must remain safe, unobstructed pedestrian circulation and civic accessibility; and

    WHEREAS, Community District Five contains some of the highest pedestrian volumes and most heavily congested sidewalks in the city, where sidewalk café installations and enclosed structures can constrain foot traffic; and

    WHEREAS, Transparent and visible materials for café enclosures are vital to preserving sightlines, visual permeability, and public safety, preventing bulky opaque sheds from degrading the historic streetscape or creating concealed alcoves; and

    WHEREAS, Equal and dignified access is an essential requirement, necessitating rigorous adherence to Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) standards across all outdoor dining setups, including seamless transitions, accessible routes, and barrier-free seating; and

    WHEREAS, Significant concerns exist regarding program equity and affordability, as rising administrative fees, design compliance costs, and winterization expenses risk pricing out independent, small, and medium-sized culinary businesses, thereby favoring larger corporate entities that can occupy disproportionate shares of the public realm; and

    WHEREAS, This resolution will be transmitted as formal public comment to NYC DOT; therefore, be it

    RESOLVED, Manhattan Community Board Five expresses general support for the proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC rules, while strongly urging NYC DOT to incorporate the following crucial protections and modifications prior to final rule promulgation:

    1. Pedestrian Clear Paths & Sidewalk Circulation: Rigorously protect sidewalk circulation by preserving the contextual clear path standards of Dining Out NYC in high density corridors, prioritizing year-round roadway dining over expansive year-round sidewalk structures, and ensuring that sidewalk dining does not compromise pedestrian flow or crowd safety.
    2. Small Business Affordability & Equity: Implement reduced fees, fee relief, or phased financial assistance for small and independent local businesses to ensure equal and equitable access to year-round dining opportunities.
    3. Transparent Enclosures & Streetscape Design: Mandate high standards of transparency and visibility for all winterization coverings and enclosure elements to eliminate visual blight, maintain clear public sightlines, and preserve open streetscapes.
    4. Universal ADA Compliance: Strictly enforce comprehensive ADA accessibility standards for all sidewalk and roadway setups, guaranteeing unobstructed routes and fully accessible dining accommodation.
    5. Robust Enforcement & Penalties: Implement proactive monitoring and support strengthened penalties and swift corrective actions for setups that encroach upon pedestrian paths, utilize dining footprints for unauthorized storage, or violate operating hours.
    6. Mandatory Public Posting of Permits: Require all participating establishments to post their active Dining Out NYC permits and approved setup plans in a visible location facing the street, improving accountability by empowering inspectors, agency personnel, and community members to readily verify compliance and streamline enforcement; and, therefore be it further

    RESOLVED, Manhattan Community Board Five urges NYC DOT to ensure community boards maintain a meaningful and timely role in reviewing, receiving notice of, and providing local input on outdoor dining applications within their boundaries.

    Comment attachment
    MCB5-Comment-to-Rues-Hearing-on-Dining-Out-NYC.docx.pdf
    Comment added November 9, 2026 12:50pm
  • Katie Thompson

    As a former NYer who visits 3-4 times a year, having the option of outdoor dining is vital to enjoy the incredibly culinary offerings of the city with my immunocompromised family members. I fully support outdoor dining but structures should not be fully enclosed — having fresh air is vital to this remaining a safe option for those who can become seriously ill from common viruses like the flu.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:14pm
  • Anymous

    I’m a tourist who regularly visits New York city truly outdoor venues are the only restaurants I am able to eat at this when I visit with this new policy I won’t be able to eat at any place. I support outdoor dining but not fully enclosed spaces. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:14pm
  • Anna Humphrey

    To the NYC Department of Transportation,

    My name is Anna Humphrey, and I am the Transportation and Voting Community Organizer for the Center for Independence of the Disabled, New York (CIDNY). Thank you for the opportunity to submit testimony regarding the proposed outdoor dining rule changes to amend sections 5-01, 5-02, 5-03, 5-07, 5-09, 5-10, 5-11, and 5-12 of Chapter 5 and section 3-01 of Chapter 3 of Title 34 of the Rules of the City of New York.

    New York City’s outdoor dining program provides New Yorkers with the ability to enjoy our many restaurants immersed right in our streets. The proposed rule changes, allowing weatherproofing for outdoor dining shacks to allow for year-round enjoyment, is an exciting step forward since the decline in outdoor dining participation since the end of the global COVID 19 pandemic.

    However, without proper forethought, people with disabilities and immunocompromised individuals may be excluded from the experience. Allowing weatherproofing using ground to overhead cover vertical screens without adding guidelines to ensure accessibility would inadvertently exclude the population of New Yorkers who would most benefit from these structures. New Yorkers with disabilities, especially those who are immunocompromised, rely on accessible outdoor dining structures to safely dine at our city’s establishments. If restaurants are permitted to completely enclose structures on all four sides without proper ventilation, immunocompromised individuals will be more susceptible to airborne pathogens, potentially even more so than if they were to simply dine inside. We ask that the proposed rule change be amended to include language that would require these establishments to leave one side of the structures open to allow for adequate airflow.

    Further, allowing these structures to be fully enclosed may obstruct seating and mobility access for wheelchair users. The updated rule language also should include strict regulations so that coverings do not impede wheelchair access to or inside the structures. Restaurants must also provide an accessible table that is designated for wheelchair users in each structure.

    The structures should also not make accessible pedestrian pathways outside the structures narrower. More specifically, even where these outdoor dining structures are present, 36 inches of continuous clear sidewalk passage must remain in accordance with the ADA. When placed in the street; bike lanes, bus lanes, and designated Access-A-Ride drop off zones should not be blocked under any circumstances.

    The Center for Independence of the Disabled, New York (CIDNY) supports these proposed rule changes to allow for winterization of outdoor dining November 30 through March 31, but we urge the DOT to include the aforementioned accessibility specifications to ensure that no New Yorkers are excluded from the experience.

    Thank you for your commitment to the inclusion of all New Yorkers in this program, and for your attention to this matter.

    Sincerely,

    Anna Humphrey

    Transportation and Voting Community Organizer

    Center for Independence of the Disabled, New York (CIDNY)

    Comment attachment
    DOT-NYC-Rules-Testimony-11.9.docx
    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:26pm
  • Michael J

    I strongly support extending outdoor dining year-round, but allowing these spaces to become fully enclosed defeats the entire purpose of outdoor dining.

    For immunocompromised people, those with underlying health conditions, and anyone taking precautions against airborne viruses like COVID-19, genuinely open-air dining is essential. Enclosing these spaces with plastic walls or panels restricts airflow and allows infectious aerosols to accumulate, creating many of the same risks as indoor dining.

    At least one entire side must remain fully open at all times, with two fully open sides strongly preferred to allow better cross-ventilation. This means no plastic curtains, windows, or temporary panels closing off those openings.

    Outdoor dining is an accessibility issue, not just a matter of comfort or convenience. Many people cannot safely eat inside restaurants, and fully enclosing outdoor structures effectively excludes them from participating in public life.

    Please ensure the updated regulations protect genuine outdoor dining rather than allowing it to become indoor dining under another name.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 1:44pm
  • Sarah Chandler

    Yes! This is so important. Outdoor dining is something many folks need.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 2:06pm
  • Anonymous

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 2:12pm
  • Jennifer

    I support extending outdoor dining year-round, but allowing them to be fully enclosed makes them inaccessible for immunocompromised people, those with underlying health conditions, and anyone taking precautions against airborne viruses like COVID-19.

    Cross-ventilation with at least 2 sides fully open is essential to reducing the risk of infectious aerosols accumulating and thereby enabling access for many people to fully participate in public life.

    Please ensure the updated regulations protect genuine outdoor dining, not indoor dining with another name.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 2:35pm
  • Evan Yankey - Brooklyn Center for Independence of the Disabled

    BCID Testimony for the New York City Department of Transportation Dining Out NYC Rule Amendments, November 9, 2026
    The Brooklyn Center for Independence of the Disabled (BCID), an Independent Living Center, supports the plan to expand accessible outdoor dining because we know that street and sidewalk cafes often are more accessible than the interior of restaurants. Outdoor dining gives more opportunities to people with disabilities to be part of their community, a key part of BCID’s mission.
    However, we have outstanding concerns about the proposed rules being discussed today.
    First, we call on the Council to make sure that outdoor dining spaces are not enclosed on all sides. This would reduce access for people with disabilities, in part by increasing physical barriers to get into the venues.
    Second, we call for the Department of Transportation to inspect plans for outdoor dining spaces to make sure they are actually accessible to people in wheelchairs and other mobility devices. The DOT must conduct periodic inspections for accessibility. Finally, the City must also require restaurants to post a sign with a visible phone number to call with accessibility complaints, including about the flow of pedestrian traffic, and the DOT must respond swiftly to rectify them.
    Fully enclosed outdoor dining spaces defeat the purpose
    The City allowed outdoor dining, including structures on city streets, at the height of the Covid-19 epidemic as a way of allowing New Yorkers to dine more safely and for restaurants to survive. But a fully enclosed space is contrary to those goals. Enclosed outdoor spaces are outdoor in name only. There is significantly less air circulation and accessibility than a truly outdoor space, which is vital for some disabled New Yorkers who depend on open-air venues.
    For a person with a mobility disability, having a venue on the street without having to pass through an inaccessible door or entrance increases people’s opportunities. Allowing outdoor venues to be enclosed on all sides will make it more difficult to enter and maneuver in these venues with a wheelchair or other mobility device.
    Beyond that, allowing venues to be enclosed on all sides makes the venue no longer “open-air,” impacting air-circulation for people with respiratory disabilities and COVID-conscious people with disabilities. Venues that were once available to people who needed “open-air” would now be closed to them, providing a barrier to access.
    It is our request that the current rules be amended to require “one open side” of the venue, using the following language:
    “When utilizing vertical protective coverings, at least one entire side of a sidewalk cafe or roadway cafe shall remain fully open to outside air whenever the cafe is occupied by patrons. Such opening shall extend across the full available width of that side, from above any required safety barrier or perimeter demarcation to the overhead covering, if present, and shall remain unobstructed by curtains, panels, or other materials that substantially restrict natural airflow.”
    We hope the Department of Transportation will consider this change today and allow increased access for people with disabilities at these necessary venues. We also urge it to more forcefully monitor outdoor establishments, proactively inspecting them and responding to accessibility complaints.
    Thank you.

    Comment attachment
    BCID-Outdoor-Dining-Testimony-11-9-26.docx
    Comment added November 9, 2026 2:54pm
  • Sara Johnson

    I strongly support permanent, year-round outdoor dining. I urge DOT to prohibit fully enclosed dining structures that eliminate a critical public health and disability-access benefit.

    Outdoor dining must remain genuinely outdoors. For people with or avoiding Long COVID, ME/CFS, immunocompromising conditions, and other disabilities that increase vulnerability to airborne infections, open-air seating can determine whether they can safely participate in restaurants and community life. Fully enclosing these spaces removes that access.

    The proposed rules expressly permit coverings on all sides of sidewalk and roadway cafés, including during broadly defined adverse weather conditions. Yet CDC recognizes that respiratory viruses accumulate less readily outdoors, and NYC’s 2020 guidance required two open sides for airflow, treating structures with fewer openings as indoor dining.

    The 2026 legislation authorizes temporary winterization and weather protection without requiring full enclosure. NYC Administrative Code § 19-160 directs DOT to protect public safety, the general welfare, and the beneficial purpose of outdoor dining.

    DOT must also consider its obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act, particularly 28 CFR § 35.130(b)(6), which prohibits discriminatory public licensing requirements, alongside applicable state and city disability protections. Permitting the elimination of meaningful open-air access raises substantial disability-access concerns that warrant examination before adoption.

    I request the following amendments:

    1. Require at least two fully open sides during dining service. Amend §§ 5-11(a)(2)(iv)(C)–(D) and 5-11(b)(2)(iv)(D)–(E) to prohibit coverings that close more than two sides of a four-sided dining structure. Required openings must extend across the usable width of each side, from above any mandatory safety barrier to the overhead covering, without curtains, vinyl panels, or other materials restricting airflow.

    2. Allow a narrow, evidence-based exception. Where two open sides are demonstrably infeasible, DOT may authorize one fully open side only through a written, site-specific determination establishing comparable natural ventilation under objective, publicly available standards. No exception should permit full enclosure during dining service.

    3. Preserve reasonable weather protection without sacrificing accessibility. Permit protective coverings on other sides and closure when unoccupied. Limit adverse-weather exceptions to genuinely temporary conditions, preserve accessible entrances and wheelchair maneuvering space, and establish enforceable inspection and compliance requirements.

    Before finalizing these rules, DOT should explain how it evaluated disability access, airborne-infection evidence, and feasible alternatives to full enclosure.

    New York can protect restaurants from the weather without eliminating the outdoor access that allows medically vulnerable and disabled people to patronize them. Preserve that access in the final regulations.

    Thank you,
    Sara Johnson

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:00pm
  • PAUL VERSHBOW

    I am in favor of outdoor dining if it is done intelligently; I do not think that it is intelligent to enforce a “one size fits all” agenda. I understand why it makes sense to create a standard outdoor structure, but I think there should be room to welcome interesting and attractive design that doesn’t abide by the standard look, but is appropriate for both the location of the restaurant and the attempt to create something of interest. (The Empire Diner on 10th Ave. at 22nd St. was a fine example of what I mean). There should be a committee to field requests that aspire to this sort of design. And please make sure you enforce the rules.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:09pm
  • Julia Linder, Harlem Independent Living Center (HILC)

    On behalf of the Harlem Independent Living Center (HILC), a disability-led nonprofit organization providing independent living services and advocating for the civil rights of people with disabilities, we support the proposed expansion of year-round outdoor dining and urge the NYC Department of Transportation (DOT) to ensure that accessibility and public safety remain central to the final regulations. Outdoor dining has expanded access to restaurants for New Yorkers with disabilities, including those who encounter inaccessible entrances and interior seating areas, as well as people with chronic illnesses, immunocompromised individuals, older adults, and their families who depend on open-air dining. We support extending these opportunities throughout the year, provided that outdoor dining structures do not restrict pedestrian access or create additional barriers in public spaces. Sidewalk and roadway cafés must maintain adequate, continuous, and unobstructed pedestrian clearances that account for wheelchair and walker users, blind and low-vision pedestrians, service animal handlers, and others who need sufficient space to navigate safely. We urge DOT to ensure that the proposed changes to pedestrian clear-path requirements and café design standards preserve usable sidewalk space and prevent tables, chairs, barriers, and other structures from obstructing pedestrian travel. Café installations must also maintain safe access to curb ramps, crosswalks, transit stops, and building entrances, while preserving adequate clearance for emergency vehicles and first responders. Regarding the proposed winterization provisions, we urge DOT to establish appropriate safeguards for ventilation, accessible entry and exit, and emergency evacuation, ensuring that seasonal coverings and other modifications do not compromise the safety or accessibility of outdoor dining spaces. These requirements must be consistently enforced, with inspections accounting for conditions during normal café operation rather than relying solely on approved site plans. DOT should also establish a clear, accessible process for people with disabilities to report accessibility violations, with timely investigations, corrective action, and follow-up on the resolution of complaints. We also encourage DOT to maintain ongoing engagement with diverse members of the disability community, including people with mobility, sensory, and non-apparent disabilities, throughout the implementation and enforcement of these regulations. Direct input from people with disabilities is essential to identifying barriers, assessing accessibility concerns, and informing future improvements to the program. HILC supports year-round outdoor dining as an important opportunity to expand access to New York City’s restaurants while ensuring that people with disabilities can safely and independently navigate the surrounding streets and sidewalks.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:27pm
  • Anonymous

    I strongly support extending outdoor dining year-round, however allowing these spaces to become fully enclosed defeats the purpose. For immunocompromised people, those with underlying health conditions, and anyone taking precautions against airborne viruses, genuinely open-air dining is essential. Enclosing these spaces with plastic walls or panels restricts airflow and allows infectious aerosols to accumulate, creating many of the same risks as indoor dining.

    At least one entire side must remain fully open at all times, with two fully open sides strongly preferred to allow better cross-ventilation. This means no plastic curtains, windows, or temporary panels closing off those openings.

    Outdoor dining is an accessibility issue, not just a matter of comfort or convenience. Many people cannot safely eat inside restaurants, and fully enclosing outdoor structures effectively excludes them from participating in public life.

    Please ensure the updated regulations protect genuine outdoor dining rather than allowing it to become indoor dining under another name.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:38pm
  • Betty Kay

    I am chair of Manhattan CB1’1 transportation committee, but these are my personal comments on the proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC regulations.

    Outdoor dining is important and enjoyed by many, but I am very concerned about the continuing loss of accessible public sidewalk space, the proliferation of structures that are inconsistent with outdoor dining requirements, and the difficulties in getting rules enforced. As a mobility scooter user, I find it increasingly difficult to get around due to shrinking and less direct clear paths (on sidewalks) and a concern about sightlines obstructed by road dining with walls when entering a crosswalk.

    Our sidewalks are public spaces that serve everyone; including those with wheeled devices including wheelchairs, strollers, delivery carts, etc). Their primary purpose must remain the safe and accessible movement of pedestrians. Commercial activity must not increasingly compromise the public’s right to move freely throughout our neighborhoods. It should also not obstruct daylighting at any corner.

    I urge DOT to:

    1. Protect pedestrian clearances:
    Preserve the existing minimum pedestrian clear-path widths, generally eight feet or more depending on corridor classification and sidewalk width, without counting space that cannot reasonably be used for pedestrian circulation.

    Require a continuous, unobstructed path rather than allowing irregular café boundaries and recesses to create narrow pinch points.
    Clarify that the proposed six-foot clearance from drive rails does not supersede the otherwise applicable pedestrian clear-path requirement.

    2. Reconsider reduced setbacks near crosswalks and intersections
    The proposed amendment to Section 5-11(b)(1)(vii) would reduce the minimum setback on the approaching-vehicle side of certain crosswalks.

    Roadway dining structures must not interfere with sightlines between pedestrians, drivers, and cyclists. The safety of wheelchair users and children, due to their short stature, need to be considered when visibility when entering crosswalks is considered. I support the proposed eight-foot clearance from pedestrian ramps, provided that it protects a fully accessible path to and from those ramps.

    3. Make enforcement meaningful and timely
    The proposed penalties provide a first-offense fine of $200 and a subsequent-offense fine of $500 for many violations, including failures to maintain required pedestrian clearances and comply with approved site plans.

    A restaurant must not be able to treat a fine as an acceptable cost of occupying public space. I urge the DOT to establish clear correction deadlines, prompt follow-up inspections, and escalating enforcement for repeated violations, including suspension or revocation of licenses when appropriate.

    Violations that obstruct accessible pedestrian routes should receive priority attention and require immediate corrective action.

    My primary concern is that we should not continue expanding the use of public sidewalks and roadways for private commercial purposes without strong protections that allow the public to use the right-or-way safely. I also urge that an emphasis be placed on the experiences of pedestrians, older adults, people with disabilities, parents with strollers, and others who rely on unobstructed public sidewalks.

    Thank you for considering these comments.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:41pm
  • Jane Gottlieb

    I am a resident of 45 Christopher Street for 41 years. This is a 18 story residential building with a mix of families, elderly people and single working individuals. All of us are law abiding, tax paying, voting citizens.

    I was unable to attend the meeting in person; I am guessing is that it was held on a weekday at 10am to minimize the number of people who could attend in person.

    Year round dining coupled with the horrendously unfair bill that passed last Tuesday has destroyed our neighborhood. We are now in effect, Times Square — but Times Square doesn’t have residential apartment buildings and residents who pay exorbitant property taxes

    The Hospitality Alliance has received everything they wanted and much more. All of us do wonder what they’ve given to receive it. Beginning with the pandemic (7 years ago), their privileges have only expanded along with their food and alcohol prices. To wit: an unregulated and UNENFORCED outdoor dining program, a zoning amendment that brought outdoor dining to previously peaceful residential neighborhoods, legislation that makes the program permanent and now, new legislation that expands the program even further and with unbelievably, even less regard for residents

    Citing some examples on the present state of things — as recent as this past weekend (will get even worse with the new bill)
    Tables and patrons block sidewalks and we are forced to walk in the streets — this is a safety issue
    Rats and trash proliferate; a dog in our building died from rat bait that was placed by a restaurant
    The noise and amplified music from the bars and restaurants is constant and beyond disruptive (this goes on past midnight)
    Open Streets should never be on a residential street, yet it persists and has expanded to year round and:
    In inclement weather the restaurants set out tables which remain 100% empty but our vehicles, cabs and Ubers are blocked from dropping us off in front of our own building. We must unload vehicles elsewhere and walk to our homes. This is particularly unfair to the elderly.
    We pay ever increasing property taxes for the benefit of bar and restaurant owners to destroy our quality of life. For many of us the only alternative is to move out of the city now.

    And finally we, as tax paying citizens, by eliminating the public hearings prior to election day, are now forced to entirely give up our rights to have a voice in this crucial matter of importance to our lives. Proposal 1 that passed in Tuesday’s election restricts our ability — we, the people directly affected — even to comment on outdoor dining. And clearly the rules at the ballot box on Tuesday were written in fuzzy language in order to mask their true impact

    The grotesque infringement on our basic personal rights and quality of life keeps growing and is now at unmanageable proportions.

    I urge you to listen and to consider the very negative impact on our daily lives.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:43pm
  • Anonymous

    Outdoor dining is a lifeline for those of us trying to avoid COVID, flu, and other illnesses. Please keep open airflow by requiring one side open. It’s a joy to dine out with fresh air!

    Comment added November 9, 2026 3:51pm
  • Eman Rimawi-Doster

    Eman Rimawi-Doster

    Senior Community Organizer for the Disability Justice Program

    At New York Lawyers for the Public Interest

    To New York City Department of Transportation

    Public Hearing and Opportunity to Comment on Proposed Rules

    Regarding the Dining Out NYC program

    November 9, 2026

    Dear Commissioner and Staff of the Department of Transportation:

    Thank you for the opportunity to testify regarding the proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC program. My name is Eman Rimawi-Doster and I’m a Senior Community Organizer for the Disability Justice Program at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest.

    When outdoor dining rules and outdoor structures were first introduced, I worked closely with the Regional Planning Association to make sure that New Yorkers with disabilities were involved and heard. As the City moves toward expanding and making outdoor dining permanent, it is essential that the program continue to listen to the voices of the disability community and remain genuinely accessible, inclusive, and safe for all New Yorkers.

    I fluctuate between using a wheelchair and a walker. I also have lupus and long Covid and take serious precautions against airborne illnesses. For me, outdoor dining is not simply about having another restaurant option or having a meal outside. It is about being able to fully participate in my community, spend time with friends, support local businesses, and experience the city without having to choose between my health and my social life.

    During the pandemic, outdoor dining opened doors that had historically been closed to many disabled people. It created opportunities to socialize and participate in public life while avoiding the risks associated with enclosed indoor spaces. It also offered alternatives to restaurant interiors that are often physically inaccessible to wheelchair users.

    We should be building on that progress, not dismantling it through regulations that prioritize convenience over accessibility.

    That is why we oppose the proposed regulations to close off the dining structures, rather than leaving at least one side open to the air. The existing structures provide a safe space for people with disabilities to dine, and closing off the structures, and thus reducing ventilation, will remove outdoor dining as safe option for many with disabilities.

    Let me be clear: Outdoor dining that excludes disabled people is not accessible outdoor dining. And a program that is only accessible on paper is not an accessible program.

    The proposed amendments to the Dining Out NYC rules are an opportunity for the City to demonstrate that it understands accessibility as a fundamental civil right, not an administrative detail.

    The proposed rule would amend multiple sections of Title 34 of the Rules of the City of New York to implement recently enacted local laws, clarify existing requirements, and improve the administration and operation of the Dining Out NYC program.

    But as DOT considers these changes, I want the Department to ask a much more important question:

    Are these changes making outdoor dining more accessible to everyone, or are they creating new barriers for the people who already face the greatest barriers in public space?

    The City must not forget the disability community in the process. Please don’t alter outdoor dining structures to be fully enclosed.

    Thank you for the opportunity to testify. I can be reached at (212) 336-9311 or [email protected] if you have any questions or would like to discuss these issues further.

    ###

    About New York Lawyers for the Public Interest 

    For 50 years, New York Lawyers for the Public Interest (NYLPI) has been a leading civil rights advocate for New Yorkers marginalized by race, poverty, disability, and immigration status. Through our community lawyering model, we bridge the gap between traditional civil legal services and civil rights, building strength and capacity for both individual solutions and long-term impact. Our work integrates the power of individual representation, impact litigation, and comprehensive organizing and policy campaigns. Guided by the priorities of our communities, we strive to achieve equality of opportunity and self-determination for people with disabilities, create equal access to health care, ensure immigrant opportunity, strengthen local nonprofits, and secure environmental justice for low-income communities of color. 

    NYLPI’s Disability Justice Program works to advance the civil rights of New Yorkers with disabilities. In the past several years alone, NYLPI disability advocates have represented thousands of individuals and won campaigns improving the lives of hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers. Our landmark victories include mandating that the MTA equitably provide its Access-A-Ride services to all applicants and riders with limited English proficiency. We have worked together with the MTA to bring about an “on demand” Access-A-Ride program and to enable New York’s most indigent residents to obtain Fair Fare discounts when using Access-A-Ride. We are currently litigating a class action lawsuit seeking to permit all Access-A-Ride users to access the same discount programs available to all other MTA transit users, as well as a class action to remedy the enormous gaps between subway cars and subway platforms system-wide.   

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:13pm
  • Alan Gomberg

    When I moved into the building where I live in Hell’s Kitchen in 1991 (moving from a building a few blocks away, having lived in the neighborhood since 1984), there was a restaurant on the ground floor. It closed on the early side and there was no street dining. In 1991, no one would have wanted to eat on the street in this neighborhood. Then after two or three years, that restaurant closed and a bar-restaurant opened. It’s open till 4 a.m. and they blast loud music, including through open doors. It soon started a sidewalk café. For approximately seven months of the year, I have to hear loud talking in my apartment till midnight during the week and till 1 a.m. on the weekends. I keep all the windows closed most of the time. But even with the windows closed, the sound of people talking loudly and often simply screaming, as people who are drinking often do, is quite audible in my apartment. (I continue to live here because the apartment is rent-stabilized and I cannot possibly afford to move.) For seven months a year, much of the time it’s like a party is going on in another room in my apartment. Keeping my windows closed is often not my preference but it’s what I must do to try to keep out street noise. Again, the noise from people in the sidewalk café still comes through all too well with the windows closed. So I applaud one thing I see in the proposed Dining Out NYC Rule Amendments. That is the reduction of hours. I cannot tell, however, whether that means 11 p.m. every night since, as I understand it, the current rules allow street dining to two different times, as I stated. My hope would be that the hours would be reduced by two hours: to 10 p.m. during the week and to 11 p.m. on the weekends. But I want to make clear that any reduction would be welcome. I hope that the 11 p.m. change would apply to weekends as well. Also, I hope this is not just for the sheds but for all sidewalk dining.

    Here are some other suggestions, but the first applies only to the kinds of sidewalk cafés that have been present going way back in time, not to the sheds. They all regard noise.

    First, I wish all sidewalk dining would be required to have some sort of covering, some canopy or something, that would perhaps reduce the amount of noise that travels to those who live near the street dining. The sheds have coverings, but the kind of sidwalk café dining with which I have had to put up for decades does not. The coverings should be both low enough and extend far enough to reduce the transmission of noise.

    Second, I suggest that signs be posted with print large enough so that people can’t miss the text stating something like this: “Please be considerate of our neighbors by keeping the volume of your conversation low.” While I’m sure many would ignore such a request, I am also sure that the idea that their conversations might be loud enough to disturb residents doesn’t even occur to many people who dine in sidewalk cafes and in the sheds. There should be such signs every five or six feet or so on the outsides walls of all establishments that have sidewalk cafés.

    Third, I know this is not the focus here, but why are restaurants and bars allowed to blast loud music while keeping their doors and floor-to-ceiling windows open? Council-member Carl Wilson told me that restaurants and bars are not allowed to have speakers outside playing music, but the volume that comes through doors that are perpetually open and floor-to-ceiling windows is often so loud that they might as well have speakers outside.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:18pm
  • Nicole Matz

    After the zoom hearing restaurant say they loose $ to outdoor not fully enclosed seating I would like to see the proof on. I see elderly, disabled and just smart people eating outside all the time. I went to school in LA, different climate but if you live by the water, its downright cold and we would sit outside with heat-lamps. People do it in Europe. This is not new. I did not get Covid till the end of 2023. Almost 4 years in, I got it at work where I was NOT allowed to mask. I still suffer from long covid. My birthday is January. Every year I go to the same restaurant that has an igloo. But my choices are slim, I still feel lucky to have that choice. Please do not make outside eating just another place to get infections. It’s not good for our economy to have more of us sick with long term illness. People spend less money if they are ill. Right now we are in largest peak of covid we have ever had in November. With less and less people vaccinating their children in general, please please leave outdoor seating with one side at least open. I beg you.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:24pm
  • M

    If outdoor dining structures are enclosed on all sides, they are no longer actually outdoors, and that defeats the purpose of these otherwise essential structures. Fully enclosed, they would not be a benefit to the many New Yorkers with disabilities who are only able to dine while actually fully outdoors so that they don’t become at risk of becoming even more chronically ill from long COVID and other serious health conditions. Outdoor dining should be actually outdoors and it should be year round. Thank you.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:36pm
  • Anonymous

    Comments on Proposed Rules on Outdoor Dining

    November 9, 2026

    Proposed New Rules Reducing the Clear Path

    Under the proposed rules, drive rails such as utility poles, wayfinding signs, traffic regulation signs, parking signs and meters would not be considered an obstruction when measuring the clear path on sidewalks. This a conspicuous denial of reality. The fact is that such structures constitute an obstacle to the through passage of pedestrians. People cannot ignore these structures, cannot walk through them, and cannot hop over them. They must go around them. This is particularly difficult for people in wheelchairs or using walkers, or pushing baby carriages or shopping carts, or pulling suitcases. Not only does this constrict the space available for uninterrupted passage, but it creates congestion on the sidewalk for other, unencumbered pedestrians. DOT implicitly recognizes this fact by including a proposed requirement that a sidewalk café cannot be built closer than 6 feet from a drive rail. In addition, DOT admits that this proposed rule may create irregular café perimeters. This would leave pedestrians with only a zig-zag path on the sidewalk. Moreover, this proposal contradicts the City’s Street Design Manual, which says that “Streetscape elements such as lighting, … wayfaring signs, utility poles, … and bicycle parking are typically located in the furnishing zone … [so that] the rest of the sidewalk remains clear for uninterrupted pedestrian flow….”

    Moreover, since the proposed rules call for measuring distance from obstructions on the perpendicular, rather than on a radius, a thin obstacle such as a drive rail would require only a very thin setback in a café perimeter, something that is unlikely to be carried out and would be ineffectual even if it were.

    In sum, this proposal is antithetical to pedestrian needs and should not be adopted.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:41pm
  • Cory

    I support outdoor dining but not full enclosures. At least one side of every outdoor dining setup should remain open air to maintain accessibility for all New Yorkers and visitors.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:47pm
  • Lois Uttley

    Please do not allow restaurants to fully enclose outdoor dining sheds. Ventilation is essential to reducing the risk that infectious diseases such as COVID will be spread among diners and waiters. Three walls and some heat lamps will do for cold weather.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 4:49pm
  • Gale A. Brewer

    Testimony before the New York City Department of Transportation
    Rules Hearing on Seasonal Sidewalk Enclosures (Local Law 143 of 2026)
    November 9, 2026
    Council Member Gale A. Brewer

    Good morning – thank you for the opportunity to weigh in on the proposed rules for Local Law 143 of 2026 (formerly known as Intro 894 of 2026).

    I am the prime sponsor of Local Law 143 of 2026, and from my bill’s introduction to negotiating the final version for passage, the legislative intent was clear to the Council and to the Administration: to allow restaurants the option to install high-quality winter vestibules enclosing their licensed sidewalk café areas—spaces for which they already pay the City of New York year-round.

    The increasingly frigid and wet weather across the city’s fall and winters prevent the practical use of sidewalk cafes – especially between November 30th thru March 31st. Some businesses are unclear on what is allowed and what is prohibited, and their confusion is understandable. This legislation aimed to provide clear guidance to help owners plan better for their workers and customers – as these businesses are a crucial force in our City’s economy and neighborhood life.

    Unfortunately, DOT’s proposed rules as related to Local Law 143, define both “vertical protective coverings” and “vertical winterization coverings” as “retractable, non-rigid, transparent” materials installed vertically along the sides of a sidewalk café. These specifications contradict the express purpose of the law.

    I strongly urge DOT to amend the proposed rules to allow for the seasonal use of structured enclosures which can be readily removable as needed – that can be secured overhead and to the building. DOT should make clear that flexible materials can be used between April and the end of November and high-quality rigid winter vestibules between November 30th thru March 31st. DOT rules should also allow restaurants to opt for a design to allow a window or flap to be opened for additional ventilation. This request is a priority for the disabled community for obvious reasons.

    Manhattan Community Board 4 (CB4) raised additional issues for consideration, which I shared with Commissioner Flynn and his staff in my September 18 letter. The board is very concerned that DOT’s proposed rule changes include removal of the word ‘straight’ to the definition of ‘clear path’, compromising a consistent clear path for pedestrians in the 3% of sidewalks that experience the most crowding. In addition, CB4 members are concerned that the proposed rules, as written, are likely to confuse owners or create conflict in neighborhoods because the definition of ‘the curb’ conflicts with the NYS traffic law’s definition; the requirement that the vertical winterization comply with the contour of the café is missing; and clearance measurements are in conflict with the clear path.

    Implementation of year-round outdoor dining must protect pedestrian circulation and accessibility. In particular, the rules should require that the cafe footprint and coverings – regardless of the season – preserve the required clear path; comply with accessibility requirements; and provide for proactive inspection and enforcement. Please take into consideration the issues raised by CB4 and members of the disabled community.

    Thank you for your attention to these concerns.

    Comment attachment
    2026-11-09-CM-Brewer-Testimony-DOT-Sidewalk-Dining-Rules-Hearing.pdf
    Comment added November 9, 2026 5:04pm
  • JM Sala

    Street dining should have ended at Covid. The streets are for transportation and sidewalks for people – not restaurants.

    However as street dining will continue due to the City Council legislation and ballot proposal:

    1. NYC DOT must ensure more sidewalk space for pedestrians (including wheelchairs, strollers etc.) The space must be actual sidewalk – not trees or grates or bike racks or any other pedestrian impediment.

    2. NYC DOT must ensure that restaurants do not place their trash and recycling in neighboring space/property/sidewalk. This has been an ongoing problem which NYC has failed to address.

    3. NYC DOT must ensure that restaurants do not use sidewalk or streets for “hostess” furnishings or use for supplies such as plates, linens etc.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 5:07pm
  • JM Sala

    Also:

    1. It must be said that restaurant dining is not an “entitlement”.
    Many people cannot afford to eat at restaurants at all – and there is no effort or assistance to allow them to eat at a restaurant.
    Likewise no one is “entitled” to outdoor restaurants either.

    2. It is shocking to see so many comments from tourists/visitors who believe that their desire to eat at a NYC restaurant should be the priority and that tourist/visitor opinion should outweigh the needs of NYC residents whose daily life is adversely impacted by outside restaurants.
    Would it be appropriate for a NYC resident to comment or lobby about restaurants in Maplewood NJ or San Diego?
    Of course not.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 5:17pm
  • Sid

    I strongly support and look for outdoor dining as I am immunocompromised. I am advised by my doctor not to dine indoors in a restaurant. I also want to make sure the outdoor dining spaces should not be enclosed from all sides due to winterization. If the outdoor space has at least one side open for airflow with proper heaters many guests like me will look for these restaurants.

    Comment added November 9, 2026 6:38pm
[shared_counts]